Sunday, June 21, 2020

Will the racial justice reckoning ever reach child welfare?

#BlackLivesMatter protesters march on New York City family courts, and the
city Saturday, in a demonstration organized by the Parent Legislative Action Network
(Photo by Joyce McMillan)
THIS POST HAS BEEN UPDATED TO REFLECT THE FACT THAT THE HEAD OF THE WASHINGTON STATE CHILD WELFARE AGENCY, WHOSE CALLOUS AND CRUEL STATEMENT IS QUOTED BELOW, HAS NOW SAID SOMETHING EVEN WORSE.


 The link to this story that appeared on the New York Times homepage on June 13 said: “Calls for Racial Justice Touch Seemingly Every Aspect of American Life.” It should have said: Every Aspect But One. 

Not only has the child welfare system, which needlessly separates countless Black families every year, been untouched, it continues to engage in racist behavior and messaging. Sometimes journalists have been its enablers.

So it’s worth remembering again how Robert Latham of the University of Miami School of Law summed it all up: “The child welfare system has nothing to say about anti-Black state violence because the child removal system engages in it daily.”

The most obvious example is one I’ve alluded to before: One agency after another issues dire warnings about what often is called a “pandemic” or “epidemic” of child abuse now supposedly underway because schools are closed and teachers and other “mandated reporters” are not calling in reports to child abuse hotlines.

Of course there is reason for concern that a tiny fraction of parents will respond to the stress of COVID-19 by lashing out. But 97 percent of calls to child abuse hotlines are false reports or cases of “neglect” which often means poverty.  

It should be obvious that it is racist to assume that the moment mostly white, middle class “eyes” are averted form overwhelmingly poor disproportionately nonwhite children their parents will unleash savagery upon them in pandemic proportions.  Endless calls to ratchet up the child welfare surveillance state only drive families away from seeking help and overload child protective services workers, so they have even less time to find children in real danger.

The reduction in surveillance is viewed differently in communities of color. As Kendra Hurley writes in Citylab:

Some parents living in neighborhoods with historically high rates of child welfare investigations say the dramatic dip in maltreatment reports feels more like the pollution lifting — a much-needed respite from the intense and relentless surveillance of low-income moms, and especially those who are black and Latinx.”…
“One parent told [family advocate Joyce McMillan]: “They’re not opening my refrigerator. They’re not opening my dresser drawers. They’re not strip-searching my children and they’re not asking me to take their clothes off for the camera, because that would be child pornography.”


"Poor people are usually constantly inspected by all these agencies,” [one mother] said. “Now there is kind of a peacefulness.”

As Emma Ketteringham of the Bronx Defenders told Hager:

We have a child welfare system that is particularly, extremely sensitive to the media, so we should be very sure of narratives before we put them out there.

Child welfare, and a large chunk of American journalism, would do well to consider the words of David Kelly, special assistant to the Associate Commissioner of the Children’s Bureau in the Department of Health and Human Services:

“If confined to telling binary stories of heroes and villains, an objective view may reverse the roles. Who is the hero, the parent doing the best they can under circumstances more difficult than most of us will ever know or experience, or the folks writing about the likelihood they will fail or actually seek to harm their children?”

But that is only the tip of the iceberg.  Consider the other ways in which child welfare seeks to set itself apart from racial justice:

Defund the child abuse police? Child welfare establshment says: No way!


The Times story notes that

The flood of corporate statements denouncing racism “feels like a series of mea culpas written by the press folks and run by the top black folks” inside each organization, said Dream Hampton, a writer and filmmaker.

It also reprints a tweet from Prof. Crystal Fleming, author of How to be Less Stupid About Race:


In other words, in other fields no one is fooled.  No one should be fooled by the similar statements coming from the child welfare establishment.  Because none of those groups is willing to put real money where its press releases are.

A key component of the racial justice movement is defunding police; that is, transferring large parts of police budgets into better alternatives such as education, housing, and public health. Not only have there been no similar calls from the child welfare establishment, they actually have teamed up with several liberal Democrats in Congress to try to use COVID-19 as an excuse to increase funding for the child abuse police – child protective services investigations -- by up to $500 million.

Just as harmful: They propose funneling the money through the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act, an odious law deliberately crafted to avoid issues of race and class in child welfare.  To get their share of this additional $500 million states would have to comply with racist provisions of CAPTA, most notably the so- called “Plan of Safe Care” provisions, which target substance using mothers and drive them away from prenatal care.

Apparently, to the child welfare establishment, forcing more than half of all African-American children to endure the trauma of a child abuse investigation – almost always needlessly – just isn’t enough.

In contrast, in the Senate it took two Republicans and two conservative Democrats to propose spending $800 million on what families actually need to prevent what the system calls child abuse: aid for things like housing, transportation and child care.

The proposal to put more federal dollars into child abuse policing is in keeping with a long, ugly  tradition of mainstream child welfare groups opposing real child welfare finance reform.

They successfully blocked a proposal to allow – not require, just allow – states to take the money they now receive through the huge, open-ended foster-care “entitlement” known as Title IV-E as a flexible flat grant that could be used both for foster care and for better alternatives.  Then they tried to block something even more modest: state-by-state waivers. And when they couldn’t block waivers they tried to undermine waivers through regulations.

Radical finance reform


What’s really needed is much more radical finance reform. The federal government should stop paying for foster care, period.  Not only should the open-ended entitlement be converted to a flexible grant, over several years states should be required to transfer the proportion of that grant used for foster care to better alternatives.  No, that doesn’t mean there would be no money for foster care. It just means that the state and local governments that put children in foster care would have to pick up the tab themselves.

Real finance reform also means ending the obscene practice of paying bounties to states for every finalized adoption over a baseline number, a practice that encourages a mad rush to needlessly terminate parental rights, as was well documented more than a decade ago.

The bounties are part of another racist law that needs to be repealed, the so-called Adoption and Safe Families Act.  In addition to the bounties, ASFA demands that, with certain exceptions, states presume parents unfit and move to terminate their  children’s right to any relationship with them based solely on how long a child has been in foster care – even if the child never needed to be in foster care at all, and/or is still there because of the agency’s failures. 

Just as harmful is the mentality enshrined by the law: the racist dogwhistling Big Lie of  American child welfare, that child removal equals child safety and that child safety and family preservation are opposites.In fact, family preservation is the safer option for the overwhelming majority of children the overwhelming majority of the time.

It’s no wonder ASFA led to a surge in foster care placements and an increase in the number of children “aging out” of foster care with no real home at all.

ASFA was one of a trilogy of racist bills passed during the mid-1990s.  But while the other two, the crime bill and the so-called welfare “reform” bill, have been called out for their underlying racial and class bias, child welfare has remained willfully blind to the fact that ASFA used the same myths and stereotypes to target the same population: poor women, especially poor women of color.

Jobs not on the line


In a section headed “Jobs on the line,” the Times story discusses the many people forced to resign  because they “made offensive statements.”  But in child welfare, you can make such statements and worse, act in ways that do enormous harm to families of color, and not only will you not have to resign, you might even get promoted.

Consider this offensive statement:



            “There are some things we’re finding with visits on video that are actually more positive than in-person visits.”

            That offensive statement came from Ross Hunter, secretary of the Washington State Department of Children, Youth and Families.  He was attempting to justify a cruel, blanket ban on in-person visits between foster children and their parents, something that is not necessary to curb the spread of COVID-19.

            But in a state where Black and mixed-race children are in foster care at twice their rate in the general population, and Native American children are in foster care at five times their rate in the general population, Hunter appears to have issued the ban to appease a bunch of appallingly selfish, white foster parents – like those who signed an online petition, which reads in part:

They say what about the bio parents who will miss [their children]? I say to this. [sic] They are the ones who made the choices which in turn lead [sic] to losing their children in the first place. They should not be worried about missing visits at this time.

            I know of  no calls in Washington State for Hunter to resign.    

UPDATE: The statement about visits isn't even the worst thing Hunter's said. He just outdid himself.

One month ago, the NCCPR Child Welfare Blog broke the story of Hunter's agency warehousing children who tested positive for COVID-19 in an office building.  Now that the Seattle Times has finally caught up, we know Hunter's response.

First, here's what some family defenders said:


Tara Urs, special counsel for civil practice and policy for the King County Department of Public Defense ... said its use amounted to “warehousing children in an office building,” sending a message to kids that no home will take them.
Already marginalized, exposed to COVID-19 and put at such a site, “it has to be terrifying for them,” said S. Annie Chung, a lawyer who represents youth separated from their parents.


But Hunter saw it differently: 


“It’s not palatial, but it’s a reasonable alternative for two weeks” — one not unlike the confined spaces millions of people are stuck in, Hunter said. “This is the challenge of the pandemic.”
       Illinois, where Black children are in foster care at triple their rate in the population, has the same blanket visitation ban.  The Shriver Center on Poverty Law has been leading efforts to get it overturned.  On June 12, they tweeted:

For Black lives to matter, Black families must also matter. For close to 3 months, @IllinoisDCFS has kept over 11,000 parents, children, and siblings apart, many of whom are Black. This is unacceptable. #LiftTheBanIL


That prompted a response from a deputy communications director for Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker, which concluded:

To claim @IllinoisDCFS does not care about black families is frankly disgusting.


No. What is "frankly disgusting" is when a p.r. person for a white governor lectures a Black-led group fighting for racial justice about what they should say - while distorting what they actually said. 

I know of no calls from Illinois for the p.r. guy to resign.

The Illinois Department of Children and Family Services now claims it will begin a slow, grudging resumption of in-person visits, starting on June 26. [UPDATE, JUNE 24: But as the Shriver Center explains, it's not nearly enough.]

Nor has anyone I know of demanded the resignation of the California district attorney who declared that “For the most vulnerable people in our community ‘shelter-in-place’ is the same as putting them in a cage with a violent gorilla.”

Failing up


And then there is the case of Cynthia Figueroa, former commissioner of the Philadelphia Department of Human Services.  She has repeatedly tweeted support for #BlackLivesMatter, even posting a selfie as she took part in a march.

But during her tenure – and for long before – Philadelphia DHS tore apart familiesat the highest rate among America’s biggest cities, even when rates of child poverty are factored in. , More than 85 percent of those families are nonwhite, When confronted, the agency’s response was misdirection and obfuscation. Only now has DHS finally admitted what it sought to obscure for so long.

But that’s only the beginning. Not only does Philadelphia also ban all in-person visits, Philadelphia DHS falsely blamed federal guidance for the ban. Federal guidance is precisely the opposite.  And now, DHS has published a guide that effectively urges people to turn virtual visits into ways to spy on families.

Yes, I did say Figueroa is a former commissioner. But that’s not because she was forced to resign. On the contrary, she keeps failing up. Mayor Jim Kenney promoted her to a deputy major job. She still oversees DHS.

And then Kenney gave Figueroa new job: Chairing what the Philadelphia Inquirer says will be “a steering committee to help the city move toward reconciliation with residents.”

The reckoning is a long way from reaching child welfare.

Tuesday, June 16, 2020

Week in review special edition: Challenging the (mostly white) master narrative about child abuse and COVID-19. When will more journalists step up?




Scores of stories state as fact that the decrease in child abuse reports because COVID-19 has closed the schools is, as one reporter flatly declared, “bad news.”  But that is mostly the white view. In communities of color it’s often seen differently.  This week-in-review is devoted to the harm done by journalists when they buy into this master narrative, and the good they can do when they challenge it.

Consider the premise that underlies this narrative: Story after story accepts as fact the claim that now that so many white, middle-class professional "eyes" are averted from overwhelmingly poor disproportionately nonwhite children, their own parents will unleash upon them child abuse in "pandemic" or "epidemic" proportions. Multiple stories put it just that way.

It's one thing to tell readers about why some people think the stress of COVID-19 will cause some small number of parents to lash out - and why others disagree.  It's another thing to simply amplify the white "master narrative" about a "pandemic of child abuse" to the exclusion of all dissent.

How many journalists have stopped to so much as ask if the "pandemic of child abuse" claim is rooted in racialized fears and stereotypes?

What does it say about journalism – especially now - that so many reporters and editors assume only the white view is the right view?  As the racial justice reckoning reaches so many other walks of life, why does child welfare, and so much of the journalism of child welfare, remain trapped in an earlier era?

The exceptions illustrate the rule. Two stories, in particular, challenged this white master narrative during the past week.


Some parents living in neighborhoods with historically high rates of child welfare investigations say the dramatic dip in maltreatment reports feels more like the pollution lifting — a much-needed respite from the intense and relentless surveillance of low-income moms, and especially those who are black and Latinx. …
One parent told [family advocate Joyce McMillan]: “They’re not opening my refrigerator. They’re not opening my dresser drawers. They’re not strip-searching my children and they’re not asking me to take their clothes off for the camera, because that would be child pornography.”

 "Poor people are usually constantly inspected by all these agencies,” [one mother] said. “Now there is kind of a peacefulness.”

As Emma Ketteringham of the Bronx Defenders told Hager:

We have a child welfare system that is particularly, extremely sensitive to the media, so we should be very sure of narratives before we put them out there.

More on this theme:


For families of color, agencies like New York City’s Administration for Children’s Services can be every bit as oppressive as the police, and even more powerful. Police can stop a black teenager on the street, throw him against a wall and frisk him. ACS can march right into the home, strip-search a black child and walk out with him, consigning the child to the chaos of foster care.

● From Prof. Martin Guggenheim of New York University School of Law (and President of NCCPR) in the Chronicle of Social Change:

[The so-called Adoption and Safe Families Act] has been responsible for the massive destruction of black and brown families. More than 2 million children’s parents’ rights have been terminated ... since ASFA was enacted. … It is an unpleasant truth that many of the organizations whose collective voice is condemning racist police practices now have for decades celebrated the approach enshrined in law by ASFA, some by explicitly celebrating adoption and others using the euphemism “permanency.”


● And consider the warning in the Chronicle of Social Change from Prof. Dorothy Roberts of the University of Pennsylvania Law School (also an NCCPR Board Member), who, when almost no one was talking about it, literally wrote the book on child welfare and race, Shattered Bonds: The Color of Child Welfare: 

Prison abolitionists should support defunding the family regulation system and be careful not to enrich it more with funds divested from the police. Calls to divert money wholesale to federal and state health and human services departments, without exempting CPS and foster care, will further empower these engines of community surveillance and control.

● Still more calls for extending the abolition/defund movement to child welfare are in the video of this webinar from Black Lives Matter – LA.

● Another example of racism in child welfare: Blanket bans on visits between children in foster care and their parents.  Such bans are not necessary to curb the spread of COVID-19. Illinois has such a ban.  Here’s what Laura Matthews-Jolly, a lawyer who regularly represents children in child welfare cases wrote in The Chicago Tribune:

As a guardian ad litem, I represent children in foster care who have not visited with their parents since the ban took effect and can personally attest that denying meaningful contact between a child and parent is one of the most punitive acts a state can take. Separation from a parent, for whatever reason, can result in lifelong trauma.

● The challenges are not coming only from the Left.  In fact, even as many of my fellow liberals push Congress to spend up to $500 million more on the policing functions of child welfare, two Republican Senators and two conservative Democrats propose putting $800 million into better alternatives. Here’s the bill text.

● One reason challenging the white master narrative concerning child welfare and COVID-19 is so important: It’s already leading to appalling acts of racism such as this, from a hospital in New Mexico.

● Another reason: As I note on this blog, it can turn into a self-fulfilling prophecy.  In other words:

If you tell teachers over and over again that while their students were out of school, they were abused in pandemic proportions, then the bruise that last year would have been seen for what it was, an accident, suddenly is child abuse.  The hungry child for whom they might have called a food bank now becomes a call to child protective services.

The “pandemic of child abuse” narrative is only the most recent example of the white narrative being assumed correct among journalists who cover child welfare.  The problems go much deeper and have been around for much longer.

The journalism of child welfare needs a reckoning all its own.

Monday, June 15, 2020

NCCPR in the New York Daily News: Dismantle the racist child welfare system, too


As communities of color rise up against police brutality and the other day-to-day brutalities they face, we are reminded again about the dangers of walking while black, driving while black, birdwatching while black and doing almost every other daily activity-while-black. But there’s one area of profound bias against people of color that keeps getting left out: parenting while black.

For families of color, agencies like New York City’s Administration for Children’s Services can be every bit as oppressive as the police, and even more powerful. Police can stop a black teenager on the street, throw him against a wall and frisk him. ACS can march right into the home, strip-search a black child and walk out with him, consigning the child to the chaos of foster care.

As with so much else in American life, COVID-19 has highlighted the problem — and worsened it.

Sunday, June 14, 2020

Child welfare and COVID-19: If there’s a surge in foster care, it won’t be because of actual child abuse, it will be a self-fulfilling prophecy

That makes the heartfelt response to the fearmongering from a top child welfare official even more important.


            I have previously noted some of the problems with the whole notion that because mostly white, middle-class professional “eyes” no longer are gazing upon overwhelmingly poor disproportionately nonwhite children, there is now underway a “pandemic of child abuse” at the hands of their parents.  Among the problems with this claim: It’s racist.

            There is also another danger that hasn’t gotten enough attention: self-fulfilling prophecy.

            The fearmongering stories often are followed by a prediction that, once schools reopen and the army of “mandated reporters” is back in action, there will be a big increase in foster care placements as soon as they spot all that supposedly previously-hidden child abuse. 

But if you tell teachers over and over again that while their students were out of school, they were abused in pandemic proportions, then the bruise that last year would have been seen for what it was, an accident, suddenly is child abuse.  The hungry child for whom they might have called a food bank now becomes a call to child protective services.

            So yes, there may well be a surge in foster care placements when the kids go back to school – but the relationship between rates of foster care placement and rates of child abuse have has always ranged somewhere between slim and none – as can be seen by the vast differences in rates of removal among the states, even when rates of child poverty are factored in.

The coming surge in foster care placements, if there is one, will be no exception.

That’s why it’s more important than ever to heed the words of David Kelly, special assistant to the Associate Commissioner of the Children’s Bureau in the Department of Health and Human Services.  In this time of reckoning for all walks of life, Kelly’s words deserve the attention not only of everyone in child welfare, but perhaps even more from journalists.


There remains a deep-seeded distrust and lack of faith in the poor families and families of color that disproportionality populate the child welfare system. It may not be as blatantly visible in all places and all times as it has been historically and can be quite implicit, but it is there just below the surface, insidious.
We need look no further than the daily features in newspapers across the country in recent weeks forecasting spikes in child maltreatment. Words typically used to describe natural disasters and war, such as surge and tsunami, describe what we should expect. Concerns about declines in reporting and leaps to grim conclusions abound. …
 If we take a rational look at what we know, there is good cause to question the legitimacy of the alarmism. …

            Kelly also discusses another double standard:


Several commentators have pointed to the prevalence of parents joking about losing patience with children and restraining them or parents calming their nerves with adult beverages or substances—or even allowing kids to use them. These are deeply troubling images that mock lack of parental supports, resiliency, and protective capacity in times of deep stress, regardless of one's income level.
While there is value in discussing shared experiences and challenges, there is also a stark double standard on display. As parents with lived experience have told us in recent conversations, these are not jokes that poor parents and parents of color would ever feel safe making in public. They are statements that, even if made light heartedly, heighten scrutiny and the risk of separation in very real ways.

I particularly hope journalists will consider this:

 If confined to telling binary stories of heroes and villains, an objective view may reverse the roles. Who is the hero, the parent doing the best they can under circumstances more difficult than most of us will ever know or experience, or the folks writing about the likelihood they will fail or actually seek to harm their children?

I also hope they will take time to question their assumptions and see how all this looks in communities of color, as Kendra Hurley did in this excellent story for CityLab and Eli Hager did for The Marshall Project.

Tuesday, June 9, 2020

NCCPR news and commentary round-up, week ending June 10, 2020

● We start this week with an exceptionally courageous column in the Chronicle of Social Change. It’s from the Chronicle’s publisher, Daniel Heimpel. He writes about how his understanding of child welfare and racism have evolved:

For years, I intellectualized the racist ferocity with which child protective services targets and then tears black children from their mothers and fathers. I strung together data into a simplified worldview wherein racial disproportionality within the child protection system was mostly about the institutional racism that has left black people at such a stark economic disadvantage in this country. 
This denied what many black people told me and what the studies and analyses made plain: that child protection is far from immune to racism, but often an instrument of it.

I hope other journalists will read it, and learn from it.

● In honor of National Reunification Month, the new issue of the federal government’s Children’s Bureau Express is devoted entirely to family reunification. There are several outstanding articles, but right now, I want to single out one in particular, from David Kelly, special assistant to Children’s Bureau Associate Commissioner Jerry Milner.  Because Kelly has a message not just for child welfare, but for journalism as well:

There remains a deep-seeded distrust and lack of faith in the poor families and families of color that disproportionality populate the child welfare system. It may not be as blatantly visible in all places and all times as it has been historically and can be quite implicit, but it is there just below the surface, insidious.
We need look no further than the daily features in newspapers across the country in recent weeks forecasting spikes in child maltreatment. Words typically used to describe natural disasters and war, such as surge and tsunami, describe what we should expect. Concerns about declines in reporting and leaps to grim conclusions abound. …
If we take a rational look at what we know, there is good cause to question the legitimacy of the alarmism. … If confined to telling binary stories of heroes and villains, an objective view may reverse the roles. Who is the hero, the parent doing the best they can under circumstances more difficult than most of us will ever know or experience, or the folks writing about the likelihood they will fail or actually seek to harm their children?
 And if you’re thinking, “I knew there was a foster care month and an adoption month, but I didn’t know there was a National Reunification Month” then please take a moment to consider what that tells us about child welfare’s real priorities.

● Meanwhile the only thing various agencies and trade associations that make up the child welfare establishment seem to have learned from recent events is how to exploit them for their own advantage. I have a blog post on how child welfare responds to racism in the usual way: unctuous hypocrisy and pious posturing.

● This actually was best summed up by Robert Latham, associate director of the University of Miami School of Law Children and Youth Law Clinic, who wrote:

The child welfare system has nothing to say about anti-Black state violence because the child removal system engages in it daily.

That’s how he began what he calls “A starter reading list on how child welfare policies harm Black people, families, and communities.”

● One of those harms, of course, is arbitrarily barring foster children from in-person visits with their parentd.  The Center for Public Integrity has a very good story about the harm this does to children. WBUR Public Radio has a story about a lawsuit seeking to lift the ban in Massachusetts.

● And the Seattle Times Education Lab interviewed family defender Tara Urs about the visitation issue and a host of other failings in Washington State child welfare – including the story this Blog broke about the state child welfare agency warehousing COVID-19 positive children in an office building.  The interview transcript is here, or you can watch it here:

Sunday, June 7, 2020

Child welfare responds to racism in the usual way: Unctuous hypocrisy and pious posturing


Statements of solidarity ring hollow when they come from groups that prop up a racist system. Or, as one lawyer for children put it:




 The first to call it out may have been Angela Burton of the New York State Office of Indigent Legal Services who tweeted:


At about the same time Vivek Sankaran, director of the University of Michigan Child Advocacy Law Clinic and Child Advocacy Appellate Clinic tweeted:


On Saturday, Robert Latham, Associate Director of the University of Miami School of Law Children and Youth Law Clinic wrote:  
 “The child welfare system has nothing to say about anti-Black state violence because the child removal system engages in it daily.”

            As America is forced once again to confront racism, America’s child welfare establishment has responded with an outpouring of pious posturing and unctuous hypocrisy.  Go to the website or check the Twitter feed for almost any mainstream “child advocacy” organization and you’ll find a press release with boilerplate like “stands in solidarity…” “we have felt anger, hurt, fear, despair, … “Our nation must confront this crisis head on …”

Sins of the past


            To understand why the rhetoric is so empty, it’s worth reviewing some fundamentals:

            ● Foster care was racist from its inception.  The system as we know it today has its roots in the racism of Charles Loring Brace – a white, Protestant minister, and raving bigot, who hated and feared New York City’s impoverished immigrants, deemed them genetically inferior, and forcibly removed more than 120,000 children from the city to the South and Midwest on so-called “orphan trains.”  Many of the children were not orphans – they were, however, poor and of ethnic groups deemed inferior.  To accomplish this mass exercise in racism Brace founded the Children’s Aid Society, which still exists and still defends the orphan trains.

● From the 19th Century through the 1960s, American child welfare agencies tried to effectively eradicate Native American culture and, indeed, Indian tribes, through the expedient of taking away children. First, they were warehoused in hideous orphanages, where the mantra was “Kill the Indian, save the man.” Later, there was a campaign of mass adoptions. Melissa Harris Perry called the orphanages an “explicit cultural extermination mission.” The Lakota People’s Law Project is calling for a Truth and Reconciliation Commission.  It wasn’t until 2001 that child welfare’s most famous trade association, the Child Welfare League of America, apologized.

The Carlisle Indian Industrial School, 1900

            ● But the apology means next to nothing, because CWLA and other trade associations, such as the one with the Orwellian name Alliance for Strong Families and Communities, continue to oppose real child welfare reform. Such reform must begin with changing federal law to allow all of the billions of federal dollars now used to hold overwhelmingly poor, disproportionately nonwhite kids in foster care to be spent on better, safer alternatives. (And no, the overhyped Family First Act does not do that.)  

            Both these associations have issued the standard pious press releases in recent days.  Both also include in their membership many private foster care agencies that are paid for each day they hold children in foster care – so of course they will support no real reform.

            ● In fact, instead of real finance reform, the same organizations that condemn abuses by police are using COVID-19 as an excuse to urge Congress to pour vast sums of emergency aid money into a racist system that polices almost exclusively impoverished communities of color, and does those communities enormous harm. $500 million of that aid would be targeted largely toward the policing part of the system – child abuse investigations.


           So ask yourself: If an organization put out a statement of “solidarity” with #BlackLivesMatter while also urging Congress to spend hundreds of millions to give the police more tear gas, pepper spray and rubber bullets – would you believe that organization?

And make no mistake, child protective services is, in everything but name, a police force. In fact, CPS investigators have more power than police.  Their approach can best be called “knock and strip.” Effectively, they can enter homes and stripsearch children without a warrant. Say no, and they can come back with the police and even break down the door. Even when the entry is less drastic, the terror of the investigation is something a child may never forget.  More than half of Black children will endure such terror during their childhoods.  That’s best case. Worst case: the CPS caseworker takes away the children on-the-spot without so much as asking a judge first. (For a detailed discussion of the parallels between stop-and-frisk and CPS investigations see this City University of New York Law Review article by Michelle Burrell, former managing attorney of the Family Defense Team at the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem.)

There is no argument on behalf of this vast power to knock-and-strip that can’t also be made for stop-and-frisk. So why do so many of my fellow liberals think only one of those things is racist?

● Child welfare has its own “caucus of denial” dedicated to convincing the world that child welfare is the one and only field in America that is magically exempt from racism. (Just for the record, here’s a summary of the research that shows otherwise.) 

In what other field can a self-proclaimed liberal “scholar” call for the mass forced relocation of poor families from “terrible” neighborhoods – on penalty of losing their children to foster care if they don’t, blithely declare that “a relatively high percentage of adults who live in the worst neighborhoods are marginal to begin with…” go on to say it was wrong to close schools due to COVID-19 – because the risk of child abuse by those same “marginal” parents supposedly is greater than the risk of the disease – and still get himself a visiting professorship at Harvard?

            ● Then there’s the group that calls itself “Every Child Matters.” They tweeted “You may want to shield your kids from racial injustices in the world, but it’s important to support them in processing painful events & learning about social justice.”

            Nice thought.  But how does ECM propose to protect children from the racial injustice perpetrated by its own founder and past president, Michael Petit, when he told a Congressional committee that the states that do the best job preventing child abuse are the ones with “smaller, whiter populations.”  

            Petit has an ugly track record of misusing data to promote hype and hysteria. And he was instrumental in getting congress to create the so-called Commission on Child Abuse and Neglect Fatalities, where he treated one of the Commission’s two African-American members, Judge Patricia Martin with appalling condescension.  Judge Martin wrote a stinging dissent from the commission’s report.

            ● And let’s not forget the so-called “Alliance for Children’s Rights,” which specializes in dredging up ugly stereotypes about poor people, demeaning the lived experiences of foster youth, and denying that needless removal of children to foster care is a problem.  Yep, they’ve got one of those unctuous statements, too – and their using it for fundraising!

            ● Most of these groups also supported the so-called Adoption and Safe Families Act.  It was passed in 1997, one year after the welfare “reform” law, and its target was the same – poor women and children – especially poor women and children of color. Both laws carried the same racist subtext.  ASFA led to a surge in needless removal of children, a mad rush to needlessly termination of parental rights which helped create a generation of legal orphans with no ties to their own families and no adoptive homes either.

Sins of the present


            But it’s not just child welfare’s sins of the past that reveal the field’s hypocrisy. Even as they tell us how they really, truly oppose racism, all over the country, government child protective services agencies and the usual assortment of private groups are spreading fear, smear and stereotype about poor families of color.

They’re telling reporters that as soon as overwhelmingly middle-class mostly white, professional “eyes” no longer are fixed upon impoverished children of color – because COVID-19 has closed the schools – their parents will unleash a “pandemic of child abuse” upon them. And yes, they’ve repeatedly used that, or similar terms.  I have yet to see even one child welfare agency, or journalist condemn the California district attorney who said: “For the most vulnerable people in our community ‘shelter-in-place’ is the same as putting them in a cage with a violent gorilla.”

            Of course, given the increased stress of both COVID-19 and its major side effect – poverty – a very small number of parents will succumb to the pressure and lash out at their children.  But isn’t it obvious that the notion that Black people will unleash abuse in pandemic proportions as soon as white eyes are averted is, uh, racist?  In the few cases where the pressure is too much, the solution is to provide concrete help to ameliorate poverty, not ratchet up the same child welfare surveillance state model that has failed for more than half a century – and actually makes children less safe.

            And, of course, public and private child welfare agencies have been routinely cutting off all in-person visits between foster children and their parents, even though a blanket prohibition is not necessary to curb COVID-19.  A more likely reason: To placate white, middle-class foster parents.

           
         Among the worst offenders when it comes to this fearmongering are assorted chapters of Court-Appointed Special Advocates.  CASA is a failed program that a landmark law review article brands “an exercise of white supremacy.”

         For those unfamiliar with the program: A CASA is almost always white and almost always middle-class. They have no serious training in law or social work or anything else one might need to march into the homes of poor people of color and pronounce judgment upon them. But that’s what they do – by authority handed to them by juvenile courts.

           Judges take the assessments of these mostly white middle-class amateurs very seriously.  (And let’s not forget that CASA chapter that held a fundraiser that featured a blackface act.) UPDATE: As if all that were not sickening enough, now the National CASA Association is invoking George Floyd's six-year-old daughter to promote itself - and to promote rushing poor Black foster children into adoption.

But fear not, the National CASA Association has proclaimed that CASA, too, is ready to fight for racial justice – to the last press release!

            If CASA were really serious about racial justice it would recognize that racism is baked into the CASA model. It would limit its role to two areas where it can be genuinely helpful, and that some chapters do now: mentoring foster youth and family finding to seek out extended family for young people in foster care or at risk of placement with strangers.

An anti-racist agenda for child welfare


            As for all those other organizations, if they really want to be part of the solution instead of part of the problem, here’s what they can do for families, especially families of color:

            ● Stop issuing press releases about solidarity and show some solidarity.

            ● Take this time to pause and do some serious soul searching about who you really are and what you really stand for.

            Then come back with an anti-racist agenda for child welfare.  NCCPR will be glad to get you started. Here's a summary, details below:



● Demand real child welfare finance reform – at a minimum, make all foster care money available for better alternatives, better yet, require that the money be transferred from foster care to prevention and family preservation. 

● Demand an end to per-diem reimbursement of private child welfare agencies – paying them for each day they hold a child in foster care.

● Demand an end to federal funding of child protective services investigations.

● Demand full funding for high-quality family defense.

● Demand that states repeal mandatory reporting laws, which have backfired, increasing the danger to children.

● Demand that Congress repeal two odious laws that enshrine all the worst aspects of the American approach to “child protection”: ASFA and the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act.

Robert Latham, whom I quoted at the top of this post, also has an agenda, which he summarized at the start of  a blog post he calls “A starter reading list on how child welfare policies harm Black people, families, and communities”

He writes:

Do the reading, and then let’s get to defunding the removal system, redirecting billions in resources directly to communities experiencing problems, and stripping child welfare decisions from bureaucrats and locating them properly back with families.

            But the child welfare establishment isn’t very good at self-reflection. 

CWLA’s statement calls for rooting out “…vestiges of racism …” But the racism in child welfare isn’t vestigial; it’s part of the system’s DNA.  And if you look closely at CWLA’s statement you’ll find they can’t resist a subtle dig at families, and a reminder of the horror stories that the child welfare system exploited to build the current system. Can you spot it? Hint: It’s in the second paragraph.

            But when it comes to lack of self-reflection, or self-knowledge, CWLA isn’t even the worst offender. Guess who else has one of those pious proclamations up on its website.  Hint, in their statement they say that other people’s racism is “compromising our own success” and their services are “acts of justice…”  Who would be that clueless?  The Children’s Aid Society.

Tuesday, June 2, 2020

NCCPR news and commentary round-up, week ending June 2, 2020


Coronavirus-related:

● What does the needless elimination of all in-person visits between foster children and their families really do to children – and why is it really happening. A father writes about what’s happening to his family in Rise.  Elizabeth Brico has the big picture in Prism.

● In Ethika Politika, Lincoln Rise of Casa Maria in Milwaukee writes about how the reduction in reports to child abuse hotlines as a result of COVID-19 might at least reduce the number of children torn from their families when poverty is confused with neglect.

● Public defenders in New York City write in City Limits about the urgent need for funding to fight for those most harmed by the pandemic: poor families, especially poor families of color. “For many wealthy New Yorkers, the quarantine is more inconvenience than anything else, they write.  

It has meant fleeing to country homes and adjusting to working remotely, but it is ultimately a crisis they can wait out without worrying about putting food on the table, paying rent, or having the NYPD, ACS, or ICE knock on their door.

In other news:

● Lexie Gruber, a public service management consultant, child welfare advocate and former foster youth writes in the Chronicle of Social Change about how advocates sometimes use those in the latter category:

At times, alumni of the foster care system are flown to Washington for advocacy events. Too often, they are treated simply as spokespeople for sad stories. The power dynamics are clear and uncomfortable – those who “invite” former foster youth to the table set the stage, having already developed the agenda and crafted the policy ideas. Instead of empowering the young person to lobby for the bold ideas they genuinely believe in, they often give the young people pre-written language in support of incremental changes. The advocates aren’t brought to Washington to demand a revolution, they are only used to “pull the heartstrings.”

● Some prominent advocates of taking away far more children have launched an attack on homeschooling.  (One of those advocates is so extreme in his belief that child abuse is rampant that he didn’t even want schools to close due to COVID-19. Now there’s someone whose judgment we can trust!)  As a I wrote on this blog, the attack on homeschooling isn’t really about homeschooling – it’s about trying to find another way to take away far more children.  As for homeschooling, James Mason, vice president for litigation at the Home School Legal Defense Association has a response in the Chronicle of Social Change.

● Chris Gottlieb, co-director of the Family Defense Clinic at the New York University School of Law has a primer in the New York Law Journal on the changes to New York’s child abuse blacklist – its central registry of those alleged to have abused or neglected children.

And finally:

● A  HuffPost story that actually doesn’t tell you anything about systemic failure. Rather, it should be a reminder to those seeking to exploit horror stories, that such stories go in all directions.