 |
Meet the "scholar" who is turning the concept of "evidence based" upside-down (Photo by Nick Youngson, pix4free.org)
|
This post quotes from many tweets. I have not tried to
correct the typos in those tweets.
Have you noticed something new about the “child welfare”
establishment lately? You know, the wonderful people who created the child
welfare surveillance state that tears apart at least 200,000 families a year and
subjects more than half of all Black children to traumatic child abuse
investigations based on reports that are almost always false. The tone of their writing seems to be
increasingly desperate.
After 50 years of health
terrorism – misrepresenting the nature and scope of a problem, in this
case, child abuse, in the name of “raising awareness,” people are catching
on. People are noticing that all that
misery inflicted on millions of children in the name of stopping child abuse
fatalities has done nothing to stop child abuse fatalities. And they’re noticing that the
misery is inflicted almost exclusively on people who are poor and
disproportionately on people who are nonwhite.
I wouldn’t say people aren’t buying the fearmongering anymore, but it’s
getting harder to sell.
Among those sounding increasingly frantic is Richard Barth,
former dean of the School of Social Work at the University of Maryland. Barth, you may recall, is the one who
declared that – unlike any other profession in America, child
welfare is 100% free of racial bias!
The evidence, including study
after study, says otherwise.
Perhaps that’s why Barth now is trying to stand the whole
concept of evidence on its head.
This can be seen most recently in his response to an
op-ed column in the Hartford Courant by Prof. Kelley Fong,
author of the forthcoming book Investigating
Families. In that op-ed, she
writes:
Research finds that following high-profile child
fatalities, child welfare agencies respond by removing more children from their
homes in a “foster care panic.” There’s no evidence, however, that this makes
children safer. Instead, such panics leave more children and their parents
traumatized by family separation, and spread child welfare workers even
thinner.
Barth responded on his increasingly shrill feed on The Site
Formerly Known as Twitter. (No, I will not be linking to it or anything else
Barth has written. There’s enough here for anyone to find it if they are so
inclined. But I’ve reprinted the tweet
in full, pausing for analysis.) Let’s
have a look, line-by-line. He begins with this:
Nice to see acknowledgment of the many ways that child
welfare services do help support families.
That’s sort of like saying “what about Officer Friendly?” in
response to issues of police brutality. Of course, sometimes individual police
officers do good things. That does not justify stop-and-frisk and choking Black
people to death. And the very fact that in order to – maybe – get help,
families have to go to what is really a police force adds enormous stress and
drives many away from seeking help.
Misreading We Were Once a Family
Barth similarly misunderstood
We
Were Once a Family, Roxanna Asgarian’s brilliant book about Black
children who were adopted to death by their white foster/adoptive parents.
Almost every reader
understands
what that book is all about: the racism that led to these children being
taken from extended families who could have raised them and the racism that
prompted family police agencies (a more accurate term than “child welfare”
agencies) to ignore signs of abuse by the white savior foster / adoptive
parents.
But not Richard Barth. In a commentary for The Imprint
about Asgarian’s book, he can’t bring himself even to mention the fact that the
children were Black and the murderers were white. And his only solutions are
more study and ramping up constant surveillance of all adoptive families.
Now, back to Barth’s tweet, as he switches gears and
discusses foster-care panics:
I agree that the
standard of removal should not change, markedly, after a child death
So, how much is “markedly”?
Often there is a 10% increase in a single year. Is that “markedly”? Sometimes it’s 20% or 30%. In the worst example I know of, Florida in
1999, removals skyrocketed 50% in a single year.
More important, where is the evidence that every time there
is a high-profile tragedy there should be any increase in the number of
children torn from their homes? It
doesn’t exist.
That does not stop Barth, who continues:
--these deaths and serious injuries should be factored in
to decision making before then.
So does that mean we all should be tearing apart families at
higher rates to begin with? Again, where
is the evidence? We tear apart vastly
more families than we did 50 years ago.
But, as is discussed further below, there is no evidence that child
abuse deaths have decreased.
And now we get to the heart of the matter. Says Barth:
But not sure what it means that no evidence shows that
removals after high profile deaths don't make children safer...
Really, Prof. Barth? You don’t know what “no evidence” means? It means: No. Evidence.
In fact, no evidence means pretty much what you said
yourself in the very next sentence:
I'd surprised if there is evidence that shows anything
about the impact of subsequent removals after failure to protect children. Is
there?
Actually, there is some evidence about this. It is, indeed, limited, but it does not
support Barth’s position.
In one sense the relative lack of evidence is a good
thing.
Though each is the worst
imaginable tragedy, child abuse deaths are as rare as they are horrifying.
So in all but the largest jurisdictions, they
may rise or fall due to random chance.
And even in those large jurisdictions, there are other confounding
variables, including bias in determining if a given death was due to, say,
neglect, or an accident.
But in those very large jurisdictions, I have never seen a
foster-care panic followed by a decline in child abuse deaths. Several times,
there have been increases.
Correlation is not causation. But the best people like Barth can say is
there is no evidence one way or the other.
Yet this is how he makes his case to maintain the status quo: There’s no evidence foster care panics make
children safer, but you can't prove they don’t! So apparently, we shouldn’t worry
too much about them. In another tweet,
responding to Prof. Fong, who cited family defense attorneys who used
statistics from government agencies, Barth doubled down:
Hmm. Public defenders arguing from single trends don't
give me any confidence. It's time for public defenders, and attorneys, and CW
commentators, in general, to team up with scientists before drawing
conclusions. I see that lawyers have now tweeted out your claims that there is
no evidence. Sigh.
Darn those pesky lawyers!
If Barth wants to convince people that it’s
wrong to claim there’s no evidence all he has to do is provide the
evidence. But he can’t. Because there’s no evidence!
A failed defense of mandatory reporting
In an opinion column he co-authored for JAMA Pediatrics Barth
again turned the concept of “evidence-based” on its head to justify mandatory
child abuse reporting laws.
Those laws were deployed more than 50 years ago with no
evidence base at all. There were no studies beforehand to see if they would
work.
Now that research finally has been
done, those studies show
mandatory
reporting backfires, scaring families away from seeking help and
overloading workers so they have less time to find the relatively few children
in real danger.
So what does Barth say?
Keep mandatory reporting – but “Research is needed to find optimal approaches
to certain circumstances…”
So to review: Here is the traditional definition of
“evidence-based”: First you come up with an idea. Then you test the idea with rigorous studies. If the studies show it works, then you
deploy.
Here’s the Richard Barth approach when it involves something
he likes: Deploy mandatory reporting with no testing. After 50+ years, when zero evidence says it
works and the studies done so far say it’s harmful – then do more studies.
Notably, even child welfare establishment types are becoming
more reluctant to buy what Barth keeps trying to sell.
That JAMA Pediatrics opinion column was followed by a
comment from none other than Dr. Richard Krugman. Krugman is the very
personification of the child welfare establishment. He used to be director of the C. Henry Kempe
National Center for the Prevention and Treatment of Child Abuse and Neglect.
Here is his comment, in full:
This is a thoughtful commentary stressing the need for
balance in our views of Child Protective Services (CPS) agencies. As one who
has worked in this field for the past 40 years, I agree with Dubowitz and Barth
that just ablating CPS agencies is the wrong approach. BUT, we now have 40
years of experience with this approach and have made no progress in reducing
the mortality from physical abuse of children (decades with 1500-2500 children
dying annually). What is missing from CPS are data on the outcomes for children
and families of the "services" being provided to them. What is needed
are carefully designed studies testing alternative approaches to community
child protection efforts that can tell us in the next decade whether those
approaches lead to better outcomes for children and families that what we are
doing now. Doing the same thing for 40 years that doesn't seem (or can't be
shown) to be working was someone's definition of insanity. [Emphasis in original.]
Alas, like Barth, Krugman can’t bring himself to actually
call for not doing things that are not evidence-based. But for someone like Richard Krugman to offer
even this genteel critique, with its implication that Barth’s approach may be,
um, lacking in sanity, means that
extremists like Barth are becoming increasingly isolated.
Barth isn’t just trying to redefine evidence-based. When it suits him, he tries to redefine
foster care.
Consider this bizarre 2021 exchange on Twitter between Barth
and Prof. Alan Dettlaff:
Dettlaff tweets:
In April 2020, Cornelius Fredericks threw a sandwich at
another resident of the institution where he was placed. He was then killed by
staff members who restrained him until he could no longer breathe. This is what
happens to children in foster care.
Barth then replies:
This is tragic but did not occur in foster care. (This
was a residential center.) So it can't fit your sloganeering about what happens
to children in foster care. Lazy thinking amd imprecise language wont help us
serve children better.
Hey Prof. Barth, have you told the federal government? All these years, they’ve been under the
misimpression that residential treatment is foster care! For some reason, the federal database known
as the Adoption and Foster Care Analysis and Reporting System has a
whole category for “institutions” Similarly, this
excellent database from ChildTrends includes “Group Home or Institution”
under “Placement settings and stability for children in foster care” [Emphasis
added.]
And apparently, the entire federal
government got its regulations wrong, too.
Because Federal regulations define foster care as
24 hour substitute care for all children
placed away from their parents or guardians and for whom the State agency has
placement and care responsibility.
So, Prof. Barth, tell us again about “lazy thinking.”
UPDATE, AUGUST 28
Sometime today, Prof. Barth responded to having his tweets criticized: