Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Hornstein. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Hornstein. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, October 24, 2021

UPDATED: Another child welfare scholar with an agenda

 

The co-designer of Pittsburgh's notorious "scarlet number" predictive analytics
algorithm has some ideas that are even worse.

The same scholar who claims predictive analytics in child welfare isn’t biased also signs on to an extremist agenda calling for an automatic, mandatory extra level of family police surveillance of thousands of impoverished families.  They are disproportionately nonwhite families who have not so much as been accused of abuse or neglect.     

She also misunderstands abolition, mocks the words of a Black child welfare activist and doubled-down on the mockery after this post first was published.

Yet somehow, she’s been invited to speak on predictive analytics in New York City “child welfare” in November, but one of the foremost critics of that effort has not. [UPDATE, OCT. 30: After this post was published, she was added to the panel.]


Emily Putnam-Hornstein is probably America’s foremost proponent of using “predictive analytics” in child welfare – that is, mining vast quantities of data surrendered disproportionately by poor people and people of color and using it, without their informed consent, to determine if they are supposedly likely to be child abusers. 

Putnam-Hornstein co-designed the Allegheny Family Screening Tool, which stamps a risk score on every “neglect” case screened by the county’s child protective hotline, and the even more Orwellian – in both name and substance – “Hello, Baby,” which seeks to stamp the same sort of invisible “scarlet number” on every child in the county – at birth. 

Putnam-Hornstein says she is, in effect, just someone who just goes where the data lead.  She combines this with rhetoric about how her efforts are just ways to bolster prevention – and I think, in her own mind, she believes it. 

But every once in awhile we see something else: an ugly, extremist agenda. 

Earlier this year, Hornstein co-authored or “co-signed” (it’s described both ways on different pages), a paper with several of the most extreme proponents of tearing apart more families and/or denying that child welfare has a racism problem.  

The group was pulled together by Naomi Schaefer Riley of the American Enterprise Institute, someone who proudly compares her book attacking family preservation to the work of Charles Murray. Riley was kicked off a blog run by the Chronicle of Higher Education after one of her columns was widely condemned as racist.  More about her here.  

Other co-authors/co-signers include Elizabeth Bartholet, leader of child welfare’s “caucus of denial” – the group that says child welfare is magically immune from racial bias, Cassie Statuto Bevan, who co-authored the so-called Adoption and Safe Families Act – and maintains the law didn’t do enough to tear apart families, and Penn State Professor Sarah Font who, in a now-deleted tweet (thank you Wayback Machine) declares that an alleged failure to prioritize children’s health, safety or existing relationships is a “feature” of the Indian Child Welfare Act.  She neglects to mention that a feature of Indian child welfare before ICWA was, uh, genocide.  

Prof. Font, the undisputed lead author of the paper, also is the lead author of the paper discussed here which includes a graphic in which everyone accused of child abuse and neglect is labeled a perpetrator – even after they’re exonerated. 


Of course, working with people who differ with you ideologically and finding common ground can be entirely reasonable.  I come at this from the political Left.  I’m glad to work with like-minded conservatives with whom I disagree on almost every issue except child welfare.  But Putnam-Hornstein authored/signed a document that is as extremist as you would expect from the authors.  It’s what they all agree on about child welfare itself that’s the problem. 

Consider this recommendation: 

…reauthorization appointments for public benefits provided to children who are not attending school and have not been recently seen by a medical professional could require (in-person) verification of the children’s well-being. [Parentheses in original.] 

Putnam-Hornstein and her coauthors make clear exactly who they are targeting: 

Children in poverty are estimated to experience maltreatment at a rate five times that of other children, and the overwhelming majority of impoverished children receive at least one public benefit. 

Well, yes. If laws effectively define poverty itself as neglect, and they do, then of course more poor children will be “estimated to experience maltreatment.” 

This also, of course, is a form of racial profiling, since nonwhite children are proportionately more likely to be poor and, therefore, proportionately more likely to apply for “public benefits.”  As for the whole surveillance-state problem, don’t worry, say Putnan-Hornstein & Co.: 

Although concerns that [child welfare services] already entails “state surveillance” of poor and minority families make such proposals controversial, there is historical precedent for requiring home visits as a condition of receiving public assistance. 

Once again, well, yes. There also is historical precedent for things like “whites only” signs at lunch counters bus terminals and other public accommodations. That doesn’t make them a good idea.  And when it comes to “home visits as a condition of receiving public assistance” the first “precedent” I could think of was blatantly racist. 

In short, the document Putnam-Hornstein authored/signed calls for requiring every impoverished family in America whose children have not been seen lately by a “mandated reporter” of child abuse to produce the children for a child abuse inspection in order to, say, quality for TANF benefits or SNAP benefits.  These child abuse inspections would be triggered by nothing except the fact that the family is poor. 

The selling of the algorithms 

All this is on top of the track record of Putnam-Hornstein and her allies when it comes to selling the predictive analytics model in Pittsburgh. 

● There’s the so-called independent ethics review of the first Allegheny County algorithm –done by a faculty colleague who wrote papers with Putnam-Hornstein’s co-designer of that very algorithm. 

● There was the county’s reassurance that the “Hello Baby” algorithm wouldn’t be biased because it doesn’t use databases that involve exclusively poor people.  (Unless, that is, you count juvenile justice system involvement and homelessness databases which are, de facto, limited almost exclusively to poor people.) 

● There’s the claim that “Hello Baby” is purely voluntary – except that you’re in it unless you remember to take advantage of just one opportunity to opt out. 

Misrepresenting abolition 

Then there’s the matter of how Putnam-Hornstein concluded one of her presentations promoting predictive analytics, dismissing the work of Black scholars and Black activists. 

In her concluding slide, she writes: “We are not going to ‘abolish’ the child protection system. And calling people ‘mandatory supporters’ is not a policy change.” She then reprints something she’d apparently said previously: “…the best abolitionists can come up with is ‘expand your role as a helper’ and ‘what are you going to do today to build another conversation’. Seriously?” 

No, calling people mandatory supporters is not a policy change.  But abolishing mandatory reporting, a demonstrably failed approach that endangers children, and providing the tools to allow teachers, doctors and others who now have to call the family police to instead give families actual help – i.e. support – is a policy change – and a damn smart one, well-summarized by one the field’s best activists, Joyce McMillan. She first coined the phrase “turn mandated reporters into mandated supporters.” 

That’s what the phrase means. I’m surprised Putnam-Hornstein, who holds a named professorship at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, didn’t seem to know it.

UPDATE, NOV. 6, 2021: In an email shortly after this post was published Putnam-Hornstein doubled down on her statement, writing:

I definitely don’t feel badly for finding “mandatory supporters” a totally laughable concept and language. Frankly, I would have thought you would also get why that is absurd and would be a bit more intellectually honest about that. That is not how the system is designed. 

 No, it's not how the system is designed, Prof. Putnam-Hornstein.  That's why there's an abolition movement.

As for abolition, it’s a new concept, and different people who use the term may mean different things by it.  But you don’t have to agree with all of it or any of it to know that there is already a wealth of information about specific abolitionist alternatives – and even a real world example -  that goes well beyond the demeaning summary Putnam-Hornstein offered.  

Nor should abolitionists be required to have immediately at-the-ready a some kind of 75-point master plan for exactly how to get rid of the current family policing system in order to be treated with respect instead of ridiculed. 

There also are abolitionist critiques specific to predictive analytics.  While J. Khadijah Abdurahman’s critique was just published, Prof. Dorothy Roberts’ critique was published well before Putnam-Hornstein offered up her demeaning caricature of the abolitionist perspective. 

And yet, somehow, next month when two academic institutions stage an online “examination” of predictive analytics in child welfare, with a special focus on New York City, Putnam-Hornstein will be there to give another sales pitch.  (After all, she’s a member of the city family policing agency’s "Predictive Analytics Advisory Group.”) And though some excellent critics from the American Civil Liberties Union are included, Abdurahman, whose critique is centered on New York City, is not.  [UPDATE: She is now!]

One more thing about the whole abolition debate: All of the alternatives proposed by abolitionists beat stamping a “scarlet number” risk score on every child at birth and forcing poor families to produce their children for inspection before receiving public benefits. 

Seriously.

Monday, February 7, 2022

In child welfare, where do ethics reviews come from?


KEY POINTS
 

● A “scholar” who insists there is little or no racial bias in child welfare writes a “predictive analytics” algorithm for the State of California.  Somehow, the contract to write a so-called “independent ethics review” of the algorithm is given to another “scholar” who also insists there is little or no racial bias in child welfare.  In fact, they co-authored a screed on this very topic. 

● So we shouldn’t be surprised when the ethics review says it’s just fine if an algorithm says a parent is more likely to abuse a child based solely on the parent’s race. 

● A document from the California Department of Social Services indicates the agency was appropriately appalled by the “ethics review.”  They scrapped the entire algorithm project.  

● But it looks like the same ethics review is about to be used to justify still another algorithm created by the same team as the one the state scrapped.  This latest algorithm already is being rolled out, very quietly, in Los Angeles. 

● This is only the latest in a long line of predictive analytics “ethics reviews” that raise ethical questions.

First of two parts. Read part two here.

In the history of efforts to target families for child abuse investigations or otherwise harass them by using “predictive analytics” algorithms, also called Predictive Risk Modeling (PRM), one of the more spectacular failures was a system called AURA.  A product of a commercial software company, and a pet project of the then head of the Los Angeles family policing agency, Philip Browning, it was stopped during the testing phase after it was found to have one little flaw: 95% of the time, when the algorithm predicted something terrible would happen to a child, it didn’t. 

After that, California decided to try its hand at building a child welfare algorithm which could be used for a variety of purposes by the state and by county family policing agencies. (In California, family police agencies are county-run.)  They gave the job to a team led by Prof. Emily Putnam-Hornstein, the nation’s foremost predictive analytics evangelist.  She is co-author of two algorithms used in Allegheny County, Pa. (metropolitan Pittsburgh). One of those algorithms attempts to stamp an invisible “scarlet number” risk score on every child at birth.  Putnam-Hornstein’s own extremism is well-documented. 

As far as I knew, the California algorithm was still in development. 

It’s not. 

An excellent story in The Imprint reveals that, after extensive consultation with an impressive and diverse group of people, the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) has pulled the plug. 


CDSS concluded that Putnam-Hornstein’s team managed to deliver the worst of both worlds: an algorithm that was overlooking real safety threats and risked worsening racial bias in California child welfare. 

It appears that an “independent ethics review” written in 2018 that claimed there were no ethical problems at all may have backfired.  It may have contributed to alarm in CDSS and contributed to the agency’s wise decision to scrap the algorithm project. 

Unfortunately, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors and the county family policing agency, the Department of Children and Family Services, learned nothing from this.  They commissioned Putnam-Hornstein’s group to write an algorithm to, among other things, flag “complex risk” cases.  Then, as the Imprint story makes clear, they sneaked it online for three months in three regional DCFS offices, with no opportunity for the community to object – presumably because the community might point out the track record of predictive analytics and of Putnam-Hornstein. 

When you go to the web page where Hornstein’s group promotes the L.A. algorithm and click on “ethics review” what do you find?  The same appalling ethical review submitted to the state – with a promise that it will be “updated.” 

So let’s take a close look at that document, and who wrote it. 

Race as a risk factor 

Algorithms are not objective.  Human beings decide what factors an algorithm will consider when it coughs up a “risk score” concerning a child or family.  That risk score may determine anything from whether a family receives “preventive services” to whether a child is removed from the home.  Predictive analytics evangelists hate it when critics say “determine” – they say the scores are merely advice to give us humans a little help.  But imagine what would happen if it became known that a human ignored a high risk score and something went tragically wrong.  So while it is usually, though not always, possible for a human to override the algorithm it’s not likely to happen very often. 

Most of the time, designers of predictive analytics algorithms try to duck charges of racism by not explicitly including race as a factor.  Instead, they use lots and lots of criteria related to poverty – is the family on public assistance?  Was the family homeless?  Are they on Medicaid? etc. – that disproportionately include families of color. 

But that wasn’t enough for the authors of the California ethics review.  They went out of their way, apparently without even being asked, to say, in effect: It’s just fine if you want to say children are at higher risk of abuse for no other reason than the race of their parents! 

This is fine, the authors say, because it will make the algorithm more accurate.  But their measure of accuracy is not whether the algorithm predicts actual child abuse, it’s whether the algorithm predicts future involvement in the family policing system: Did the algorithm correctly predict that the family would be labeled “substantiated” child abusers or the child would be placed in foster care?  

But that’s not a prediction, that’s a self-fulfilling prophecy.  For example, in a system permeated with racial bias, Black families are more likely to be reported, more likely to be substantiated and more likely to have their children placed in foster care.  So when the algorithm looks at which families are more likely to be “system involved” the algorithm concludes that being Black makes you more likely to be a “child abuser” – instead of concluding that being Black makes you more likely to be falsely reported, wrongly substantiated and needlessly have your children taken. 


Or, as CDSS put it in a 2019 memo sharply critical of the ethics review 

CDSS does not agree that it is ethical to include race in the algorithm. Removing race from the algorithm does not eliminate bias, since race is correlated with many variables. However, explicitly including race as a variable simply provides an opportunity for more bias to seep into the algorithm’s predictions.

Go ahead: Slap a risk score on every child! 

The section on race only hints at the extremism of the ethics review’s authors. 

California never asked for an algorithm that would be applied to every child at birth – an Orwellian concept known as “universal-level risk stratification.”  It is so extreme one might think no one would ever do that – except that Putnam-Hornstein co-designed an algorithm that attempts to do just that in Pittsburgh. 

But even though this wasn’t on the table, the California “ethics review” went out of its way to say, in effect: By the way, that would be fine, too! 

The California DSS appeared to be appalled, and said so, sending a message that everyone in America, but especially in Pittsburgh, needs to hear: 

The Department believes that “universal-level risk stratification” is unethical and has no intention to use it now or in the future. Identifying and proactively targeting services to families with no [child welfare services] involvement is a violation of families’ privacy and their rights to parent as they see fit. This would be an overreach in the roles and responsibilities of a government agency. 

No wonder California DSS seemed appalled. They were handed a so-called ethics review that says it’s fine to slap a risk score on every child at birth – and fine to label the child at higher risk of abuse just because of the parents’ race. 

The Charge of the White Brigade 

Who in the world would take such an extreme position? Someone who is a charter member of child welfare’s “caucus of denial” – someone who insists that child welfare is magically immune from the racial bias that permeates every other aspect of American life.  Someone who says that the disproportionate rate at which the system intervenes in Black and Native American families is only because past discrimination (racism is so over, have you heard?) and the problems it caused has made Black people more likely to be bad parents.  In short, someone with views just like those of Emily Putnam-Hornstein. 

So now, meet the lead ethics reviewer for Putnam-Hornstein’s California algorithm, Prof. Brett Drake of Washington University. 


Not only does Drake hold the same views on all this as Putnam-Hornstein, something he makes clear in the ethics review itself, he and Putnam-Hornstein co-authored a screed taking the same position on race, and denying even that poverty is confused with neglect.  Another co-author is Sarah Font of Penn State, who issued a report with a graphic labeling everyone accused of child abuse as a “perpetrator” – even after they’ve been vindicated in the courts.  

The lead author of the screed is Naomi Schaefer Riley, who proudly compares her own book attacking family preservation to the work of her fellow American Enterprise Institute “scholar” Charles Murray. Murray wrote The Bell Curve, a book maintaining that Black people are genetically inferior.  The Southern Poverty Law Center labels Murray a “white nationalist extremist.” 

In addition to the four authors, the screed has 13 co-signers.  All of the authors and all but two of the cosigners appear to be white.  And that’s just the beginning.  I recommend taking a minute to Google them all. 

This Charge of the White Brigade is nominally a critique of the movement to abolish the family policing system.  The white authors label this movement led by Black scholars and Black activists “simple and misguided,” [emphasis added]. 

But the screed isn’t only about abolition. It recycles the same old attacks used for decades against any effort to curb the massive, unchecked power of the family police. Their argument, in somewhat more genteel language, boils down to: If you don’t let us do whatever we want, whenever we want to whomever we want, you don’t care if children die!!! 


So to review: An algorithm designed by someone who believes there is little or no racial bias in child welfare gets a seal of approval from an “ethics review” written by someone who believes there is little or no racial bias in child welfare.  

Though California DSS was not fooled, as noted above, Los Angeles County has turned to Putnam-Hornstein to design still another algorithm.  As the Imprint story revealed, it was rolled out on the sly for three months in three locations last year.  Presumably, this was done because the communities in question might object to computerized racial profiling and try to stop it in its tracks.  So even as predictive analytics proponents blather about consultation and transparency their real approach is different.  How ethical is that? 

As noted above, go to the webpage where Putnam-Hornstein and her colleagues try to sell this latest algorithm and click on “ethical review” and guess what turns up? The same review rejected by the California Department of Social Services in 2019, but with a note promising an update. 

If this latest experiment, using Los Angeles children and families as guinea pigs, is allowed to continue, presumably, Putnam-Hornstein, who does not believe there is racial bias in child welfare, will be in charge of determining if this latest algorithm exacerbates racial bias in child welfare. 

All of which raises one question: How was Brett Drake chosen to do the California ethics review in the first place?   It does not appear that he was chosen by California DSS.  They say that the ethics review 

was a required deliverable for a research grant that supported exploration of whether a [predictive risk modeling] tool could successfully assess risk of future [child welfare services] involvement.

If, when it comes to ethics reviewers Putnam-Hornstein has had a remarkable run of luck. 

A co-author of an ethics review of the Allegheny Family Screening Tool (AFST), the first algorithm Putnam-Hornstein co-authored for Pittsburgh is a faculty colleague of Putnam-Hornstein’s partner in creating that algorithm.  They coauthored papers together.  But even those reviewers said that one reason AFST was ethical is that it would not be used on every child at birth. 

Needless to say, this caused a problem when Allegheny County decided it wanted to use another algorithm co-authored by Putnam-Hornstein to do just that.  So they commissioned two more ethics reviews – including one from another ideological soulmate of  Putnam-Hornstein. 

But oddly, the county didn’t rush to publish them.  In 2019, county officials just declared that they’d gotten a seal of approval from the ethics reviewers.  That is true. But the story is a little more complex than that.  It’s a story for part two, which you can read here.

Wednesday, September 27, 2023

Child welfare’s “Scooby Gang” is getting desperate

This is a picture from the Twitter feed of Prof. Deadric Williams, during one of his lectures at the University of Tennessee.  As he explains “This is a slide I use to describe scholars looking for variables to account for the ‘racial gap’ in a given outcome.” 


In “child welfare,” or as it should be called, family policing, the Scooby Gang is getting desperate.  As the work of genuine scholars, such as Prof. Dorothy Roberts undermines the foundations of the family policing surveillance state, the Scooby Gang falls back on all it has left: misrepresenting what their betters have to say, and invoking horror stories. 

In a previous post, I documented the desperate efforts of a charter member of the Scooby Gang, former University of Maryland School of Social Work Dean Richard Barth, to use his increasingly shrill Twitter feed to stand the whole concept of “evidence-based” on its head.  

Now, he’s sunk even lower – to the level of Emily Putnam-Hornstein, the foremost evangelist for using “predictive analytics,” or, as it should be called, computerized racial profiling, in family policing.  She has turned her Twitter feed into the “child welfare” equivalent of Fox News -  devoting it almost exclusively to horror stories about child abuse deaths.  (You can read all about her and her track record here.)  

Putnam Hornstein claims she’s “sharing abuse and neglect deaths since advocates ignore.” That is demonstrably false.  We “advocates” pay constant attention to child abuse fatalities.  To cite just one example, two NCCPR Issue Papers are devoted almost exclusively to the topic, and you’ll find it discussed in scores of posts to this blog.  It’s just that we say things with which Putnam-Hornstein disagrees. 

Things like this:

There is irony in Putnam-Hornstein’s Foxified approach, since the rate of child abuse fatalities has remained the same for decades, even as the family police surveillance state has reached such gargantuan proportions that more than half of all Black families will be investigated.  So every Putnam-Hornstein tweet is, in effect, a refutation of the approach she and the rest of the Scooby Gang have championed. 

But exploiting horror stories while falsely claiming others ignore them is a great excuse to distort the entire debate while trying to maintain a veneer of “scholarship.” 

And now, Barth has joined in: 


 Retweeting Putnam-Hornstein, he cites a horror-story case and says it “doesn’t fit the abolitionist, neglect deniers argument that “neglect is really just poverty” that has been trumped up by [child welfare services] authorities. 

I know of nobody who has ever made the argument that all neglect is just poverty.  We’ve absolutely said that the confusion of poverty with neglect is rampant – because it is -- but we’ve never denied the existence of those very rare horror stories. (In contrast, Barth has denied that there is any racial bias in family policing.)  If you still don’t understand this, Prof. Barth, be sure to attend my virtual presentation on this very topic at the next Kempe Center International Conference (Oct. 4 at 9:30 a.m. e.t.) [UPDATE: ICYMI, Prof. Barth, the text is here.]

Or did I miss it somewhere?  If so, Prof. Barth, please provide a link, or at least a citation, to where anyone with whom you disagree has said that all neglect is “just poverty.”  

Of course, Barth and Putnam-Hornstein aren’t the only ones who link to horror stories.  We do it, too, concerning abuse in foster homes and institutions.  But there’s one key difference.  Six years ago, I offered a deal:  As long as people like the Scooby Gang keep invoking horror stories, the rest of us have to remind people that the horrors go in all directions. But, I wrote, while I will not unilaterally disarm, I am prepared to accept a mutual moratorium on the use of horror stories to “prove” anything. 

Instead, the Scooby Gang has doubled down – because horror stories are all they’ve got.  

At a minimum, the descent into fearmongering argues for excluding Barth and Putnam-Hornstein from any serious scholarly discourse on family policing. 

And actually using a so-called “predictive analytics” algorithm designed by anyone who behaves this way should be unthinkable.

Wednesday, March 15, 2023

Guess which child welfare “scholars” are in the group defending a “race realist” law professor beloved by Tucker Carlson

Self-proclaimed "race realist" law professor Amy Wax having a friendly chat with election denier Tucker Carlson

Prof. Amy Wax of the University of Pennsylvania Law School is quite a piece of work.  The school’s Dean, Theodore Ruger, has written a letter urging the University to consider imposing a “major sanction” against the self-proclaimed “race realist.” 

I’ll go into some of what Wax is accused of saying – and some of what she has unquestionably said – in a moment.  But I should explain at the top why this commentary is on a blog about the “child welfare” system. 

Wax’s most strident defenders include a group called the Academic Freedom Alliance.  AFA’s members include some of the most strident supporters of tearing apart more families and some of those deepest in denial about racism in child welfare.  

AFA members include Emily Putnam-Hornstein, America’s foremost evangelist for the use of predictive analytics in family policing (a more accurate term than “child welfare”) and someone who has gone out of her way to ridicule the work of a Black activist in the field. They also include Prof. Sarah Font, who issued a publication with a graphic labeling anyone accused of child abuse a “perpetrator” – even after they’re found innocent.  She also condemned the Indian Child Welfare Act.  

Font and Putnam-Hornstein have been brought in by that other bastion of the child welfare establishment, Chapin Hall, to advise them on a study that amounts to a whitewash of abuse in foster care. 

A founding member of AFA, Elizabeth Bartholet, is also the leader of child welfare’s caucus of denial concerning racism in child welfare. 

All three signed a paper (with Font as the lead author) calling for a massive increase in surveillance of poor families by family police even when they are not accused of abuse or neglect. 

As The New York Times reports, AFA sent a letter to University of Pennsylvania President M. Elizabeth Magill denouncing the call to investigate Wax and demanding that any and all attempts to discipline her cease.  Indeed, they are demanding the issuance and publicizing of “a complete exoneration of Amy Wax for her multiple exercises of academic freedom both in her teaching and public statements.” (There are links to Ruger’s letter and the AFA letter in the Times story.) 

Amy Wax’s “race realist” vision 

So now, some highlights from the work of Amy Wax: 

The Times cites comments the self-proclaimed “race realist” made while appearing on Tucker Carlson’s program on Fox Nation (which is like Fox News but without its subtlety and nuance). According to the Times, Wax 

said “American Blacks” and people from non-Western countries feel shame for the “outsized achievements and contributions” of Western people.
Wax appeared with Carlson in 2022, well after Carlson began spreading lies about the 2020 election and lies about the Jan. 6 insurrection that followed.  None of that deterred Wax.  The Times story continues: 

On a recent podcast, she said, “I often chuckle at the ads on TV which show a Black man married to a white woman in an upper-class picket-fence house,” she said, adding, “They never show Blacks the way they really are: a bunch of single moms with a bunch of guys who float in and out. Kids by different men.”… 

Here, from Ruger’s letter, are some more examples: 

• Stating, based on misleading citation of other sources, that “women, on average, are less knowledgeable than men,” women are “less intellectual than men” and there is “some evidence” for the proposition that “men and women differ in cognitive ability.” 

• Stating that “our country will be better off with more whites and fewer nonwhites.” 

• Stating that Blacks have “different average IQs” than non-Blacks, could “not be evenly distributed through all occupations,” and that such a phenomenon would not be “due to racism.” 

• Stating that Asians have an “indifference to liberty,” lack “thoughtful and audaciousindividualism” and that “the United States is better off with fewer Asians and less Asian immigration.” 

• Stating that immigrants with “Brown faces, Asian faces . . . feel anger, envy, and shame,”and expressing her disbelief that they would criticize the United States when “on some level, their country is a s---hole.” 

• Stating that “there were some very smart Jews” among her past students but that Ashkenazi Jews are “diluting [their] brand like crazy because [they are] intermarrying.”

 • Stating that low-income students may cause “reverse contagion,” infecting more “capable and sophisticated” students with their “delinquency and rule-breaking.” 

• Stating that “if you go into medical schools, you’ll see that Indians, South Asians are now rising stars. . . . [T]hese diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives are poisoning the scientific establishment and the medical establishment now.” 

The Times discussion of academic freedom does not discuss a concomitant responsibility: academic rigor.  But according to Ruger, Wax 

relies on outdated science, makes statements grounded in insufficiently supported generalizations, and trades on the University’s reputation to amplify her baseless disdain for many members of the University community. … When challenged regarding her unsupported and uncited claim that communities that are “more diverse” litter more, she responded that “[s]ociologists don’t study this stuff,” when in fact there are multiple studies on the topic. … Wax proclaimed that “there is essentially no science being done in a place like Malaysia. No science, no technology coming out.” This is patently false.

What Wax allegedly said to her students

 AFA and Wax’s other defenders say that, as a tenured professor, she should be free to go on whatever “race realist” rants she chooses without fear of consequences concerning her employment. 

But Wax also allegedly has made belittling, racist comments to her students.  From the Times: 

[A] Black law student who had attended UPenn and Yale said that the professor told her she “had only become a double Ivy ‘because of affirmative action,’” according to the administration. 

The complaint filed by Ruger lists more allegations: 

● Emailing a Black student, that “[i]f blacks really and sincerely wanted to be equal, they would make a lot of changes in their own conduct and communities.” 

• Stating in class that people of color needed to stop acting entitled to remedies, to stop getting pregnant, to get better jobs, and to be more focused on reciprocity. 

• Stating in class that Mexican men are more likely to assault women and remarking such a stereotype was accurate in the same way as “Germans are punctual.” 

• Commenting in class that gay couples are not fit to raise children …  

• Commenting after a series of students with foreign-sounding names introduced themselves that one student was “finally, an American” adding, “it’s a good thing, trust me.” 

Wax denies saying anything belittling or racist to students. But the Times reports that even another group that supports her suggested hers was a borderline case: 

Professor Wax is a test case of academic freedom, “right up on the line,” said Alex Morey, the director of campus rights advocacy for the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression [FIRE]. But, she said, “We have not seen any evidence that it crosses the line.” 

But is the line always bright and clear?  When a professor says Black people are cognitively inferior, nonwhite immigrants come from “s---holes” and that they are only in her classroom because of affirmative action, how can she be trusted to treat all students fairly and equally?  If even some of her defenders concede it would be wrong for her to tell her own students to their faces that they are cognitively inferior, come from “s---holes” and are only in her classroom because of affirmative action, why is it ok retain a tenured professorship after saying the same things about them using someone like Tucker Carlson has an intermediary? 

While FIRE might concede that a line might exist, even if they don’t think Wax crossed it, the letter
from AFA expresses no qualms about Wax’s statements at all.  It doesn’t even offer up the Voltaire defense:  You know, the quote attributed (
probably wrongly) to Voltaire which goes: “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”  

So one might expect AFA’s letter to begin with something like: “Make no mistake. We are appalled by Prof. Wax’s repugnant views and her actions, and we want to make clear in the strongest possible terms that we do not share them.  Nevertheless …” 

But no such statement appears.  The AFA letter contains not one word disapproving of what Amy Wax says amid the 1,109 words defending her right to say it.  And, as noted earlier, AFA is demanding “a complete exoneration” of Wax for what she has said “both in her teaching and public statements.” 

The letter is signed by the co-chairs of AFA’s Academic Committee.  There is nothing to indicate that Bartholet, Font or Putnam-Hornstein were involved in drafting it or even read it.  But it speaks volumes about all three that they are part of a group that would rush to defend the right of a self-proclaimed “race realist” to spew venom without one word of criticism concerning the venom she spews. 

It’s also unsurprising. 

Putnam-Hornstein’s most celebrated predictive analytics algorithm, the one in Pittsburgh was launched after stacking the deck on evaluations and ethics reviews.  When, finally, independent researchers got to evaluate it they found racial bias.  That same algorithm now is reportedly under investigation by the U.S. Department of Justice for possible discrimination against disabled families.  A just-published Associated Press story and an analysis by the American Civil Liberties Union make clear just how much havoc the Pittsburgh algorithm can cause. 

As for taking away children, Putnam-Hornstein has said "it is possible we don’t place enough children in foster care or early enough.”  And, taking an approach I suspect Wax would like, Putnam-Hornstein has gone out of her way to ridicule the work of a Black activist. 

As noted above, Sarah Font has condemned the Indian Child Welfare Act and claimed that families have too much due process when faced with the vast power of child protective services. 

Bartholet has made a career out of denying that there is racial bias in child welfare, proposing mandatory family police surveillance of every family with young children and calling for changes that would require taking millions of children from their families.  (But apparently, she’ll compromise. The document she signed with Putnam-Hornstein and Font only suggests requiring that people reapplying for public benefits be forced to produce their children for family police inspection if they are not otherwise seen by a mandated reporter of child abuse.) 

So it’s no wonder Putnam-Hornstein, Font and Bartholet joined – in Bartholet’s case co-founded -- a group that felt one of its highest priorities should be to rush to the defense of Amy Wax. 

Yet Chapin Hall has turned to Font and Putnam-Hornstein to advise them on that stacked-deck study of abuse in foster care – a study whose methodology guarantees that such abuse will be minimized. 

Chapin Hall should have the decency to dismiss Font and Putnam-Hornstein from their advisory board immediately – and to tell another advisory board for their “study,” a board made up of young people with lived experience in foster care -- why Font and Putnam-Hornstein were such a bad choice in the first place.

Tuesday, January 25, 2022

Garrett Therolf and the Magic Algorithm!


He co-authors a “news analysis” for the Los Angeles Times that sounds like a pitch by a company selling “predictive analytics” software for child welfare.  There’s also another cheap shot at family preservation and something that sure sounds like a dog-whistle.

Second of two parts. Read part one here.

Yesterday’s post to this blog reviewed the bad journalism practiced by former Los Angeles Times reporter, and current contributor, Garrett Therolf.  I noted that other journalists have accused him of repeated misrepresentations and, on one occasion, making up a quote.  The post talked about Therolf’s profound discomfort with any suggestion that there is systemic racial bias in child welfare. 

I said I believe this poor journalism contributes to the fact that Los Angeles County tears apart families at the second-highest rate among America’s biggest cities and their surrounding counties.  And I noted how he stacked the deck in a story about racial bias in child welfare. As Therolf portrayed it in a 2017 story, white people “marshal data,” Black people want to rely on anecdote and “folkways.” 

That post discussed what Therolf said during a January 20 “Ask the Reporters” video event presented by the Times.  But Therolf and a current Times reporter, Matt Hamilton, also wrote a “news analysis” for the Times headlined Anthony, Noah, Gabriel and beyond: How to fix L.A. County DCFS. 

Though called a news analysis, it was actually a sales pitch for a child welfare fad that is much beloved by those wedded to a take-the-child-and-run approach to child welfare: predictive analytics.  This is an approach in which a computer algorithm mines vast amounts of data – especially data about poor people – and tells the family policing agency whether a case is high-risk.  It amounts to computerized racial profiling.  

It was tried first in criminal justice – and proven to be racially biased.  Yet Therolf and Hamilton present it not just as a solution to the problems plaguing the Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services but the only viable solution.  They regurgitate favorite talking points of Emily Putnam-Hornstein, America’s foremost evangelist for predictive analytics in child welfare; someone whose own extremism and penchant for deriding the work of Black people is documented here. 

Analyzing the “analysis” 

The story is a great illustration of Therolf’s general approach. So in this post, I will go through parts of the story paragraph-by-paragraph, (excerpts are in italics) starting with that headline, which references the three horror story cases Therolf focuses on, to the near exclusion of all else: 

News Analysis: Anthony, Noah, Gabriel and beyond: How to fix L.A. County DCFS 

One could as easily have done a story headlined: “Los Angeles tears apart families at one of the highest rates in America’s largest urban areas – but children keep dying: How to fix L.A. County DCFS.”  But Therolf has shown no interest in L.A.’s outlier status.  While he has pointed out that Los Angeles has failed to prevent horror story cases for decades, he has not seen fit to remind readers that the rush to remove more children has done nothing to make them safer. 

In the long, troubled history of L.A. County child abuse cases, certain names stand out as avatars of how the system can go terribly awry. Anthony Avalos. Gabriel Fernandez. Noah Cuatro. 

Viola Vanclief, Joseph Chacón and Andreas F. could just as easily have become such avatars
– but Viola and Joseph died in foster care.  Andreas was allegedly tortured and beaten into a coma by his foster mother.  They didn’t become “avatars” because the way they were hurt doesn’t support Therolf’s “master narrative.” The Love family  (whose story does not appear to have been covered in the Times even once) and the mother who is the subject of this commentary in WitnessLA also would make excellent avatars of system failure. 
 

In fact, all of these children deserve to “stand out as avatars of how the system can go terribly awry.”  Therolf and his colleagues have chosen to emphasize some and pay far less attention to others. 

Is the racial justice movement really too influential? 

But since the spring of 2020, another name has wielded outsize influence over national perspectives and policies related to child welfare, and energized activists to push for sweeping reforms: George Floyd. 

Notice the use of “outsize” influence as opposed to “strong influence” or just “influence.”  Outsize can simply mean large, but it also can mean “exaggerated or extravagant in size or degree.” – as in: Beware! People are now way too concerned about not taking away Black children and that is putting them in danger.  

If anything, the impact of America’s racial justice reckoning on child welfare has been undersized, consisting largely of foster care agencies slapping Black Lives Matter statements on their websites while continuing business as usual. 


Indeed, it is a testament to the double standards that so many journalists apply when the issue is child welfare that in the midst of a racial justice reckoning, so many reporters bought into a racially biased, and now widely-debunked myth: the one that claimed that, due to COVID-19, in the absence of all those overwhelmingly middle-class disproportionately white “mandated reporters” keeping their “eyes” constantly on children who are neither, their parents would unleash on their own children a “pandemic of child abuse.”  Garrett Therolf, who in his current job writes for outlets besides the Times, jumped right onto that bandwagon.
 

Similarly, while the Los Angeles Times did a superb job confronting its own racism in many other fields, it neglected to scrutinize its child welfare coverage.  Perhaps the Times’ new editor, Kevin Merida, will remedy that. 

The murder of the Black Minneapolis resident by a police officer in May 2020 set off a national soul-searching over the country’s racist past and the prejudices that still haunt its institutions. In L.A. County, that process has focused intense scrutiny on what a number of racial justice advocates and elected officials say is an implicit bias that may make some Department of Children and Family Services workers more prone to regard poor families and parents of color as unfit to raise their children. 

Watch out for those bad apples 

Notice the “few bad apples”-type framing here.  Some workers may be biased.  As opposed to the idea that systemic racism poisons the entire system.  Therolf isn’t required to agree with that, but he has an ethical obligation to note the existence of that critique and explore it.  But as we’ve seen, Therolf has a record of dismissing that idea. 

In 2020, three-quarters of children removed from their homes in L.A. County were Latino or Black, according to a motion — authored by Supervisor Holly Mitchell and passed in July by the Board of Supervisors — to begin implementing a controversial pilot project called “blind removal.” 

The program, first adopted in Nassau County on Long Island in New York, redacts all race and race-related factors from the dossiers used by social workers and supervisors in determining child welfare cases. And it is gaining popularity, despite critics who say that it has shown insufficient evidence of its efficacy and that it adds one more task to an overtaxed workforce. 

Let’s take the last point first. What overtaxes the workforce is a flood of false reports, trivial cases, cases in which family poverty is confused with neglect and needless removals of children by workers terrified of being the Los Angeles Times’ next target if they leave a child in a home and something goes wrong.  So the notion that one small step to try to curb racial bias should be abandoned because the workforce is overtaxed is one more indication of Therolf’s own bias. 

Therolf is partly right about criticism of the program’s efficacy – criticism from his pal Putnam-Hornstein.  (He does not mention other criticism, that the change doesn’t go far enough in uprooting institutional racism.)  But that hardly makes the whole program “controversial.”  Even the revisionist critique shows an overall decline in removals of Black children.  In fact, the data may indicate that the process contributes to a decline in removals of all children – perhaps because the process also eliminates data suggesting whether or not a family is poor. 

But the best way to find answers is to create a pilot project to test the practice.  That is exactly what the Board of Supervisors has ordered. 

But while officials scramble to address these race-related concerns, other child welfare experts assert that another, relatively new methodology using machine learning and algorithms is more likely to yield race-neutral and reliable results that, among other benefits, will enable social workers to accurately identify incidents of child abuse at an early stage and move swiftly to intervene.  

Notice that this method gets a much friendlier introduction. A method widely criticized as magnifying racial bias is presented as the magic cure. 

Rather than relying on caseworkers’ limited ability to weigh a family’s full recorded case history — due to limited time and cumbersome technology — experts had urged the county to partially automate risk analysis with a new generation of predictive analytics tools to scan and evaluate hundreds of known variables regarding families, including prior hotline calls and the child’s age when the first hotline call was received. 

Stop and ask yourself: If you were writing promotional copy for a company selling predictive analytics software, would it have been any different from that?  

Better solutions 

One could, in fact, solve the limited time problem by curbing the deluge of false reports, trivial cases and poverty cases.  This could be done by things like eliminating mandatory reporting  -which has been found, in studies Therolf is unlikely to tell you about, to overload the system and drive families away from seeking help.  

The deluge of false reports is due in part to CYA referrals by mandated reporters terrified of what will happen to them - including what the Times will do to them – if they don’t report and something goes wrong.  As for cumbersome technology, how about fixing it, instead of building a whole new technology on top of it? 

The use of such tools to predict which children are at greatest risk has attracted controversy because of the chance that they might exacerbate racial disparities in child welfare. That’s because Black and Latino families tend to interact more frequently with entities such as public hospitals and mandated reporters who generate the data that are used to train the algorithm on how to detect risk. 

Actually, there’s far more reason than that. The algorithm in Pittsburgh, for example, which was co-authored by Putnam-Hornstein and for which Therolf has shown particular fondness, relies heavily on databases that sweep up data only on poor people. It also relies heavily on past involvement in the family regulation system itself. (By the way, Putnam-Hornstein hates the phrase “family regulation system.”) That makes the computer-generated risk score more like a self-fulfilling prophecy than an actual prediction.  Then there’s the fact that, as noted earlier, the same approach has been proven to be biased when applied in criminal justice. 

Those pesky civil libertarians! 

Pushback from the American Civil Liberties Union and others had stalled the development of the program for years, contributing to the decision by Cagle’s predecessor, Philip Browning, to retire in frustration. 

Darn those pesky civil libertarians!  But, wait, what did the ACLU actually say?   You don’t suppose they have an in-depth critique that they presented at a recent virtual conference, do they? Isn’t this where real journalists quote the ACLU in order to explain why there might be a problem?  But no; a hallmark of Therolf’s “reporting” is to minimize dissent from his own point of view, confining it to a brief paraphrase or not mentioning it at all. 

Oh, one other thing Therolf neglects to mention: Los Angeles County tried a predictive analytics algorithm during Browning’s tenure – and it failed spectacularly. The “false positive” rate was more than 95%. Much the same happened in Illinois.  What L.A. is trying now is supposedly a new, improved algorithm.  But it’s co-authored by Putnam-Hornstein – and her Pittsburgh algorithm has much the same problem. 

But [Browning’s successor, Bobby] Cagle gained the majority support of L.A. County’s supervisors that had eluded Browning, and the tool was piloted last summer to help flag children like Noah who may be at the highest risk. (Cagle resigned in November, as DCFS faced mounting criticism over a series of fatalities and abuse of children under the agency’s care.) 

A lead designer of predictive analytics, Emily Putnam-Hornstein at the University of North Carolina, emphasizes that the tool is designed to be advisory and can be easily set aside by caseworkers if their investigation verifies that no significant safety threats exist. 

Easily set aside? You’re kidding, right?  Again, imagine what would happen to the caseworker who overrides the algorithm and something goes wrong.  Here’s what would happen: A Los Angeles Times  headline that would say something like: “Caseworker ignored ‘high risk’ warning about [name of child] weeks before he died." 


Also, as Therolf describes it, the override would come only after the incredibly intrusive, traumatic investigation called for by the algorithm – and algorithm which, when it comes to predicting the kind of horror stories on which Therolf’s reporting thrives, will almost always be wrong.
 

Unfortunately, it seems that the chair of the Board of Supervisors, Holly Mitchell, buys this.  During a Times-sponsored video presentation, she actually said she knows there is an inherent potential bias in the algorithm but she was counting on caseworkers to both overcome their own biases and counter any bias in the algorithm. 

In a slide show presentation explaining the need for tools like L.A. County’s, Putnam-Hornstein wrote that her work stems from a “growing appreciation that current tools are inadequate, clinicians are poor at weighting factors (and time is scarce!).” An independent evaluation team will ultimately decide whether the tool helps. 

I’ve already addressed the “time is scarce” argument.  The “current tools are inadequate” argument is a Putnam-Hornstein favorite.  The problem isn’t that she’s wrong, it’s that she’s setting up a false choice: Either use the cruddy system you have now or the cruddy alternative I’m proposing. That’s something I’ve addressed before in the context of Los Angeles.  

There are other ways to go: Abolish mandatory reporting, allowing mandatory reporters to become mandatory supporters (Putnam-Hornstein hates that phrase, too), narrow neglect laws to reduce the confusion of poverty with neglect, and provide high-quality defense for families, just for starters.  All that would allow human caseworkers plenty of time to learn how to do the job better and with less bias. 

As for the claim about an independent evaluation, that needs to be checked closely, in light of the way a so-called independent ethics review was handled for Putnam-Hornstein’s Pittsburgh algorithm. 

Scapegoating family preservation 

And now, behold how, once again as he has so many times before, Therolf attempts to scapegoat any effort to keep families together: 

One near-universal assumption among social workers is that children belong with their own families in the absence of serious safety threats. 

That is near-universal rhetoric – but the data show that caseworkers in Los Angeles are far more prone to tear apart families than their counterparts in other large metropolitan areas.  

But critics contend that this can lead caseworkers to reflexively declare success whenever a child remains with their parents, without taking full account of whether the child could be at risk. 

Which critics – besides you, Garrett?  That sounds a lot like Donald Trump, who was fond of saying “many people are saying” or “a lot of people are saying” when he meant himself.  Also: 

● As is so common with Therolf’s stories, this implies that holding children in foster care is safe and only returning a child home can place a child “at risk.”  That is at odds with study after study showing high rates of abuse in foster care. 

● And where are the data to support the claim about placing children at risk?  Oh, wait, there’s one line by one lawyer in one report - from 2012: 

“DCFS should change its messaging from Do Not Detain/Keep The Numbers Down,” wrote the Board of Supervisors’ special counsel in a secret internal 2012 report. 

But then, as now, the numbers weren’t down. Los Angeles was, and remains, an outlier in child removal.  Therolf provides no link to the “secret internal 2012 report” and no documentation that any such messaging existed.  If there has ever been such messaging, the data show that the rank-and-file sure didn’t get the message. 

Yet workers in the cases of Noah Cuatro, Gabriel Fernandez and others went on to finalize decisions to leave children in dangerous homes without even reading their own agency’s case file. 

Note the leap here: The logical assumption when workers make decisions without reading the file is that they didn’t have time to read the file – as Therolf himself suggests earlier in this same story.  But if you’re pushing a particular point-of-view, you simply leap to the conclusion that they didn’t read the file because of some fanatical devotion to keeping families together. 

Research has shown that people who are not trained to assess and investigate child abuse are more successful than DCFS workers at predicting the most serious harms to children. Researchers have found that the number of calls made by the public to child protection hotlines was a better indicator of deadly risk than the conclusions of caseworker investigations. 

Inference peddling 

Here, as throughout the story, Therolf wants us to take his word for whatever inferences he chooses to make.  There are no links to actual documents, much less to research.  No way to see the context or to fact-check his claims. 

In fact, it appears that Therolf may be making a leap from a study – by Putnam-Hornstein, of course, showing that children reported to child abuse hotlines are more likely to die than children not reported to hotlines.  

But, as noted in yesterday’s post, of all children who are, in fact, the subject of hotline calls in the course of a year 99.998% do not die.  That makes the horror stories no less horrible and no less a cause for action.  But they are needles in a huge haystack.  

So Putnam-Hornstein’s findings tell us only that while the risk of child abuse death among children who are subjects of hotline calls is infinitesimal, the risk to children who are not subjects of such calls is even smaller.  If you then make the number of hotline calls a huge red flag in an algorithm, you will traumatize vast numbers of children in innocent families, encourage malicious false reports, and further inundate caseworkers, leaving them even less time to find children in real danger and less time to “read their own agency’s case file” – because, remember, “time is scarce!” 

Indeed, it is precisely because the horror stories we think of when we hear the words “child abuse” are so rare that predictive analytics experiments crashed and burned in Illinois – and Los Angeles. 

Over the last decade of relative paralysis by the Board of Supervisors to implement effective reforms, hundreds of children whose cases cried out for help have died at the hands of their caregivers. 

Actually, it wasn’t paralysis.  The constant outcry from the Board of Supervisors – and Therolf’s stories -- led Los Angeles County to take far too many children and overload the system – so of course child abuse deaths did not stop. 

Can’t you hear the whistle blowing? 

Therolf goes on to list a series of factors he says explain why child abuse deaths occur disproportionately in one part of the county, the Antelope Valley.  Then comes something that sure sounds like a dog-whistle: 

Complicating matters further is that the region has one of the highest shares of Black residents, so any misstep exacerbates concerns about racial justice. 

That sounds like a more genteel version of what you’d hear on Fox News: They won’t take Black kids in danger because the politically correct woke mob will get them! 

Now, as the county prepares to select its next DCFS director, that person will have to confront a central problem that has undermined … so many …  initiatives of the past: trust. 

At a recent forum held by Fordham’s School of Law to discuss Los Angeles County’s use of machine learning, Ron Richter, the former director of New York City’s child welfare system, said that even “when we talk about a tool that may help reduce disproportionality and family regulation, sincere issues of trust surface, especially for those of us who have witnessed firsthand what child welfare looks like on the ground.” 

That’s also true, Richter added, for “those who have been historically judged by this system and feel strongly that many children and families have been misjudged.” 

But Richter, who now runs a large private foster care agency, wasn’t the only speaker at the forum.  One of the others was Aaron Horowitz, chief data scientist for the American Civil Liberties Union.  So you see, Therolf knows full well why the ACLU disagrees with Richter and does not see this as “a tool that may help reduce disproportionality and family regulation” – but he doesn’t seem to want L.A. Times readers to know it.  He allows no one to actually make the case that predictive analytics can magnify racial bias.  Though Therolf won’t tell you, you can watch Horowitz’s presentation, and the entire Fordham event here. 

Note also the condescension.  What Richter is really saying is much like what Therolf himself suggested in that 2017 article: That we white people are using science, and those Black people are just scared because they rely on anecdote and “folkways.” 

As long as this is how the Los Angeles Times continues to cover child welfare, the commendable reckoning it undertook last September, when it looked at its own track record covering race, is incomplete.