Showing posts with label Cleveland Plain Dealer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cleveland Plain Dealer. Show all posts

Sunday, November 27, 2011

Foster care in Cleveland: Did Plain Dealer sleaze claim another victim?

UPDATE, NOV. 30: Citing court records WKYC-TV is now reporting that, in foster care “the child is having dreams of dying, is wetting the bed, and is anxious that the world is going to end in 2012.”  The station also reports that part of the reason Cuyahoga County DCFS took the child away is that the mother missed some appointments.  As noted below, the foster mother also is having trouble keeping up with appointments, but DCFS is responding somewhat differently.


            You’ve probably already heard about this one: the eight-year-old boy who weighed 218 pounds and has been consigned to foster care as a result.

            Apparently oblivious to the emotional trauma of tearing this child from his mother, (including the fact that, at age 8, this child may now believe he did something wrong and now is being punished) the Cuyahoga County Department of Children and Family Services showed up at his school one day last month and refused to let him go home.  They shoved him directly into a foster home.   His mother can’t even visit him for more than two hours a week.

            The Cleveland Plain Dealer actually did a very good job with the story.  Among other things the story noted that:

            ● The child was on the honor roll at his school and participated in school activities.

            ● The child only came to the attention of child welfare authorities, early in 2010, because his single mother, a substitute teacher who also is taking vocational school classes, brought him to the hospital because of breathing problems.  He was diagnosed with sleep apnea, which often is caused by obesity.

            The story doesn’t say exactly how this led to DCFS intervention, but, as we all know in the wake of Penn State, doctors and nurses are “mandated reporters” required to call in any suspicion of “child abuse.”

DCFS did not remove the child then and there; instead, the agency started monitoring the family.  There is no mention of the agency helping the family.

            ● The boy did, in fact, lose weight.  But recently he began gaining it back – apparently siblings were sneaking him food.

            ● The mother voluntarily enrolled the child in a special hospital program to help obese children.

            What mom could not do, of course, was hire a personal trainer, or enroll the child in special camps or even keep an eye on him at all times, as wealthy families can do.  So it’s no wonder that Dr. Arthur Caplan, America’s most quoted medical ethicist, told the Plain Dealer he was concerned that, as the newspaper put it, “families with the fewest resources, which often are minorities, will end up being the ones with their children removed.”

            No kidding.

            Prof. Vivek Sankaran of the University of Michigan Child Advocacy Center is dealing with a similar case in Detroit.  "This is really dangerous stuff we're talking about," he told a Time magazine blog in July.  "A lot of people don't realize how traumatic it is for children to be ripped away from their parents."

In the case he’s working on, Sankaran said:

What we've seen … is that the actual removal causes irreparable damage to the child — emotional problems, behavioral problems — and it's the type of thing that can't be remedied.  People think [removing the child] is a quick fix, but you need to make sure you have tried every other possibility to protect the child.

Clearly in the Cleveland case they didn’t.  Because here’s the kicker – according to Mom’s public defender it turns out that the foster mother, who lives in a nearby suburb, can’t keep up with all the child’s appointments – even though that’s what was expected of the boy’s single mother, even as she juggled her efforts to improve her education and make a living.

But The Plain Dealer reports that DCFS was far more solicitous of the foster mother.  The newspaper reports that, according to the mother’s public defender, “There was even a discussion about getting the foster mother additional help or moving the child again, this time to a foster home with a personal trainer.”

            That prompted the public defender to ask the obvious question: “I wonder why they didn’t offer the mother that kind of extra help.”
           
THE NEWSPAPER AS ENABLER

            So if the Plain Dealer covered the story so well, why do I think the newspaper shares responsibility for this travesty?  Because the Plain Dealer did so much to create the climate made it almost inevitable.

            Early in 2010, after the Plain Dealer rediscovered two facts:

1.       Cuyahoga County has a child protective services agency and
2.      sometimes children known to that agency die,

it was the sleazy reporting by Harlan Spector and the even worse editorials by Sharon Broussard, falsely blaming the deaths on efforts to keep families together, that set off a huge foster-care panic in Cuyahoga County.

            The panic began in March of 2010.  By September of that year, the number of children taken from their homes had soared 65 percent over the same period in 2009 – and the panic has continued at the same rate this year.

            So why did the Plain Dealer do better on this story?  Probably because it was written by a different reporter, Rachel Dissell.

            I don’t know how it happened that Dissell was assigned to the story.  Perhaps in the midst of all the misery this family has been forced to endure, they got one stroke of luck.  Maybe Harlan Spector was taking the days around Thanksgiving off.

Monday, August 30, 2010

UPDATED, SEPT. 5: Cleveland Plain Dealer does what LA Times won’t: covers the foster care panic in its community


BUT WILL THE PLAIN DEALER PASS THE "BEN BAGDIKIAN TEST"

After arguing on this Blog that the way the Cleveland Plain Dealer has been covering child welfare has set off a classic foster-care panic, I began to hear rumors that the reporter responsible for most of the stories, Harlan Spector, was going to do a story about the panic. I assumed it really would be a story minimizing the panic and/or spinning it to suggest that it was a good thing that was somehow making children safer.

    I'm pleased to report I was wrong.

    The story ran Sunday, on the front page. It was a fair, straightforward account of the surge in entries into care and the disagreements over why it was happening and the consequences. No loaded language, no nonsense of any kind. There even were allusions, for the first time, to Child Welfare Gone Haywire, the Plain Dealer's landmark examination of the last foster care panic in Cuyahoga County.

    There certainly are flaws in the story, and, of course, the usual run of excuses from the child welfare agency for the panic. Anyone interested in a detailed analysis can scroll to comment #5 (if viewing oldest comment first) under the story on the Plain Dealer website.

    Unfortunately, I doubt that editorial writer Sharon Broussard will follow in Spector's footsteps. I expect Broussard's next editorial will minimize the notion of panic and stack the deck with the false claim that NCCPR opposes the paper reporting on child abuse deaths – as opposed to our taking issue with how that reporting was done – a distinction made clear in the earlier posts. (UPDATE, SEPTEMBER 1: I am pleased to report that, in an editorial today, Broussard does not, in fact, misrepresent NCCPR’s position.  She does, however, repeat all of her earlier mistakes, including the demonstrably false claim that DCFS recently had placed “family preservation above all else” and the Big Lie of American child welfare: that child removal equals child safety. UPDATE, SEPTEMBER 5: it turns out that while Broussard didn't make the comments I'd expected herself, she "outsourced" the job to the paper's "reader representative."  His column, and my response on the Plain Dealer website, are available here.) 



    The big question now is whether Plain Dealer coverage will pass the Ben Bagdikian test.

In 1983, The former Washington Post editor wrote The Media Monopoly, among the finest works of media criticism in American history and certainly among the most prescient. When I taught journalism I used it as a textbook.

    One of Bagdikian's important observations is how newspaper editors who have strong feelings about a story deal with the side of that story they don't like:

They cover it. Prominently. Once.

That's just enough for the editors to say to critics "Oh, we covered that. We even put it on the front page" – when they know full well that anything covered only once has almost no impact. It's what's repeated over and over again that leaves an impression.

    So the question now is: Will there be follow-up? Will there be stories about children victimized by needless removal from their homes? Will references to the panic become part of the "boilerplate" in Plain Dealer stories, in the same way the stories recap the cases that started the panic?

    That's step two. A lot of papers, notably this year the Los Angeles Times, never get to step one.

    OK, Garrett Therolf. Now it's your turn.

Monday, August 23, 2010

Foster care task force in Cleveland: Horrors! They’re not relying on horror stories!


    That must have been an amazing scene outside the Jane Edna Hunter building in Cleveland week before last. The members of the Obligatory Blue Ribbon Commission studying the county's Department of Children and Family Services came marching out and gathered in front of the building. The chairman unrolled a scroll and read aloud: HEAR YE! HEAR YE! THE OBLIGATORY BLUE RIBBON COMMISSION INVESTIGATING THE CUYAHOGA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES DOES HEREBY PROCLAIM THAT ALL IS WELL! DCFS IS FUNDAMENTALLY SOUND!
    And what fools they looked like when, just two days later, it was revealed that they'd never gotten the very information they'd have to have to reach such a conclusion!


    None of that is true, of course. It is, however, the impression left by the King of Loaded Language, Cleveland Plain Dealer reporter Harlan Spector, in a story he wrote about the group's work published on August 13. In that story, Spector never actually lies, he just leaves an impression that is light years from the truth. It is a textbook example of the journalism of child welfare at its worst.

FROM SLEAZY…

    One can see the technique simply by comparing how Spector wrote the story first, before he found a way to spin it, and then a few days later. The first version, on August 10, at least began as a straightforward news account:

    …[T]he head of a task force examining the agency's reunification practices said the department is fundamentally sound.
   Even in the worst cases in which children known to the county were harmed, "there's nothing in these cases that suggests we need to upend . . . the system," said task force chairman David Crampton of Case Western Reserve University. He said the panel still expects to recommend systemic changes.
   "I don't think radical change is needed," he said. 


    
Spector then used the rest of the story to try to undermine that conclusion – recapitulating, and in one case, distorting the known facts, in the same litany of horror stories dredged up over and over in the Plain Dealer's attempt to stampede the county into tearing apart more families. The distortion concerns the "cat feces case" discussed in detail in the previous post to this Blog.

    Then came a paragraph alleging that "Critics say the county has been too quick to return children to troubled households, too slow to remove them from risky environments and too conservative in launching investigations" followed by five paragraphs of a foster parent claiming DCFS was doing too much to keep families together , with no rebuttal from anyone, let alone those who might think the agency takes too many children needlessly – especially now that the Spector and his colleagues have set off a foster-care panic sending removals soaring by 60 percent.

…TO SLEAZIER

    But apparently this wasn't sleazy enough for Spector and/or his editors. So on August 13, he essentially rewrote the story with a far more sensational lead:

    A review panel that proclaimed Tuesday the beleaguered county Department of Children and Family Services is fundamentally sound has not received critical information to do its job, including case files about children who were killed or harmed.
    The agency has refused to allow the task force to review agency files of high-profile cases that spurred department Director Deborah Forkas to appoint the panel last spring. 


    While none of that is literally false, (although the part about "critical information" is very much in dispute) all of it is grossly misleading. For starters, notice how what was "said" on Tuesday was "proclaimed" by Friday, making the statement sound like more of a whitewash, and making the Special Task Force, as it's officially called, look that much dumber when they discovered they wouldn't get those supposedly crucial files.

    As for "beleaguered," it is, of course, Spector himself, and editorial writer Sharon Broussard who are "beleaguering" the agency. (Editorials are unsigned, but Broussard wrote the early editorials on these issues and, as far as I know, still has responsibility for them.)

    In fact, there is no evidence that children are any less safe now than they were in past years. Indeed, DCFS maintains that the most reliable available safety indicator – reabuse of children known to the system – has remained unchanged; something the Plain Dealer has chosen not to report – just as the Plain Dealer has chosen not to report the 60 percent increase in children torn from their homes.

    As for the files on the horror story cases, when it comes to judging the overall performance of DCFS, they aren't crucial and the revelation is anything but new. Indeed, the entirely-unattributed claim that this is
"critical information to do its job," is simply Harlan Spector's personal opinion.

MEETING MINUTES TAKEN OUT OF CONTEXT

    While Spector attributes the revelation that the task force won't get this information to meeting minutes, he doesn't mention that this actually appears in the minutes of the task force's very first meeting, on May 20. Perhaps Spector simply didn't bother to read the minutes at the time.

    The next time this issue arises is in the minutes of a task force meeting on July 15. According to Spector:

   Minutes of the task force's meetings show that the panel has not been given information it requested about the cases. The minutes don't specify which cases were requested, referring to them as "high profile and reunification cases."
   "The data will help the panel determine where in the process is the break down," said minutes from a July 15 meeting.

    But Spector took the meeting minutes, available in full here, out of context. The minutes actually say that a subcommittee dealing with a practice known as Team Decisionmaking (TDM) discussed items including:

   The difficulty in getting adequate data on the TDM practice concerns in the high profile and recent reunification cases; the data will help the panel determine where in the process is the break down. [Emphasis added].


So, in fact, the quote in question pertained to:
--One subcommittee of the panel.
--Data from the files, not the files themselves.
--A "breakdown" not in the entire Cuyahoga County child welfare system, but in one facet of that system, Team Decisionmaking, in these particular cases.   

   And for the "reunification cases," which are 122 of the approximately 126 at issue, Forkas has said she will provide the data.

    As I've said often on this Blog, most recently just last week, I believe not only Obligatory Blue Ribbon Commissions but every member of the press and the public should be able to see nearly everything in every case file. But that's a separate issue from whether Harlan Spector grossly distorted what the task force actually said.

HEADS WE WIN, TAILS YOU LOSE

    Spector's distortions in these stories are part of a larger theme in Plain Dealer "reporting." From the moment the task force was announced, the Plain Dealer has whined about the fact that the members were "handpicked" by Forkas who told them what to look into.

    So after briefly noting DCFS' claims that they couldn't provide the actual files in the horror story cases because prosecutors asked them not to share those files, and after briefly paraphrasing the task force's reasoning for not needing horror stories to evaluate the overall performance of the agency (more on that below), Spector writes:

    The denial of case records nonetheless indicates the extent to which the county has shaped the outside review of the department. Forkas appointed the 32-member panel and assigned the group areas of study. [Emphasis added.]

   You do have to admire the work of a true master in almost any field – and once again, with that paragraph, Spector shows his mastery of loaded language. Because, again, it's literally true, but grossly misleading.

   Who, exactly would the Plain Dealer like to see name a task force like this? If, say, the County Commissioners had named the task force, that would make them no more independent, since the commissioners have ultimate responsibility for DCFS.

   In fact, the membership of the Task Force looks just about like the membership of almost every other Obligatory Blue Ribbon Commission named when newspapers rediscover that their communities have child welfare agencies and that sometimes children known to those agencies die.

   As for the claim that Forkas "assigned the group areas of study" in fact, Forkas gave the task force a very broad charge. According to the minutes from the first meeting:

The charge issued to the panel was as follows: to develop specific recommendations focusing on decision points related to the reunification process and the decisions that the agency makes; a review and recommendation on permanency, as well as recommendations to expand the agency's service delivery model related to evidence based practice.

    That covers pretty much anything the task force wants to cover – and neither Spector nor Broussard, has said what other issues they'd like to see the task force look at.

     But this kind of spin is perfect for the Plain Dealer's purposes. If the task force doesn't say what Spector and Broussard want it to say, then the spin is: "Well, what did you expect? Forkas named the task force." Had it issued harshly critical findings, then the Plain Dealer would have said "Even Forkas handpicked panel concluded…" Heads we win, tails you lose.

MISSING FROM THE TASK FORCE

    The real failing of the task force membership is that, like almost every other such panel ever created, it lacks either a birth parent who feels her or his children were wrongfully removed or at least a lawyer who regularly represents such parents. According to the minutes, once again, birth parents were to get a "focus group."

    Virtually every other constituency – doctors who specialize in child abuse, law enforcement, judges, lawyers who represent children in these cases, private agencies, and leading academicians are represented. It's the usual rounding up of the usual suspects. But that means that, as usual, the debate is limited to whether the child welfare agency is doing too much family preservation or just enough. The possibility that the county is doing too little to keep families together was off the table from day one.

    So when the task force says, (not proclaims, says), that DCFS is fundamentally sound, either:

      ● there is a massive conspiracy on the part of virtually every constituency involved in the study or practice of child welfare in Cuyahoga County, Ohio to cover up the failings of DCFS or,

      ● the system really isn't endangering children's lives by failing to take enough of them away.

   Take your pick.

THE EDITORIAL WRITER HAS HER SAY

    The next day, Broussard weighed in. She had a different explanation for why the task force somehow came to conclusions different from her own. They'd been duped!

   After regurgitating the same horror stories that supposedly prove DCFS is failing systemically, Broussard added that "On Friday came news that the task force has not been allowed to see the files on the very cases that triggered its formation." Apparently, Broussard also didn't read the actual minutes of the Task Force meetings. (It's not that much of a chore, they're only five or six pages each).

   But at least Broussard allowed the task force chairman, Prof. David Crampton to defend the task force's work:

    Task force chairman David Crampton, a respected child-welfare scholar and associate professor at Case Western Reserve University's Mandel School of Applied Social Sciences, understandably bristles at the notion that he or other panelists are being manipulated into a bias in favor of Forkas or her department.
   "My job is not to protect the job of a Deb Forkas; it is to have the best child-welfare system in the country," Crampton says. "I'm not doing this for any other reason than that."
   He adds that any best-practices review of child welfare won't dwell on a handful of tragedies but instead will take the widest-angled view possible of systemwide practices. [Emphasis added.]

TYPICAL FAILINGS ARE REVEALED BY TYPICAL CASES

    And that last sentence illustrates why the task force has been vastly smarter about all of this than either Spector or Broussard.

    As I've noted often on this Blog, the way to figure out how a child welfare system typically functions is to look at the typical cases.

    Suppose the Plain Dealer were judged solely by its greatest screw-ups, the stories that required the most embarrassing corrections? They'd be the first to say that this is an absurd way to evaluate anyone. "Why dwell on a handful of our worst blunders?" the newspaper would say. "You should be taking the widest angle view of our total performance."

   There is one crucial difference, of course: When DCFS screws up, children die. But that makes it all the more important not to use horror stories to fashion solutions that only make things worse.

   Unfortunately, the Plain Dealer's own crusade already has had just that effect. As is discussed in detail in the previous post to this Blog, the work of the Plain Dealer, mostly Spector and Broussard, has set off a classic foster-care panic – with entries into care up 60 percent and exits down by one-third.

   Not only does this do terrible harm to the children needlessly removed, it also overloads workers so they have even less time to find children in real danger. That's why all over the country, in systems that, unlike Cuyahoga County are so large that it's possible to detect a pattern, over and over foster-care panics have been followed by more deaths of children "known to the system."

   In other words, when caseworkers, terrified of landing on the front page react to hyped, distorted, news stories like the ones in the Plain Dealer exactly the way Cuyahoga County caseworkers are responding now, the typical result is that more children wind up dead.

   To the extent that the minutes of the task force meetings reveal any failings, they suggest that Forkas is too sanguine about the panic, and the task force itself has not yet addressed it.

   But, as I've noted in every post about Cleveland, two former Plain Dealer reporters did – in their outstanding dissection of the last foster care panic in Cuyahoga County, Child Welfare Gone Haywire. That 2004 story warned of exactly the type of journalistic failure that now typifies Spector and Broussard's approach.

   Come to think of it, maybe the worst screw ups of DCFS and the worst screw-ups of the Cleveland Plain Dealer aren't so different after all.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Foster care panic in Cleveland: Child welfare goes haywire - again


THE PLAIN DEALER STARTS A FOSTER CARE PANIC LEADING TO A 60 PERCENT INCREASE IN CHILDREN TORN FROM THEIR HOMES

    This may be the best indication of just how bad things are in Cleveland right now: The most reasonable, most rational, most sensible comments about child welfare are coming from politicians.

    Two of the three Cuyahoga County Commissioners have defended the county Department of Children and Family Services against claims by the Cleveland Plain Dealer that not only are misleading and out-of-context but also, sometimes, just plain wrong on the facts.

    Whereas the Los Angeles Times has committed largely sins of omission – and has backed off both from claims that recent child abuse tragedies are a "series" or a "spate" and from overt attempts to link such tragedies to family preservation, the Plain Dealer's coverage since March has been as sleazy as any I've seen, ranking right up there with what the Philadelphia Inquirer did in 2006 and 2007 – coverage that was superbly-critiqued by the alternative weekly CityPaper. Indeed, even the Inquirer did not have as much of a problem with basic accuracy.

    And it's having exactly the effect one would expect – the one we predicted in these previous posts about Cleveland.

The Los Angeles Times was only able to start a foster-care panic good for a 16 percent increase in removals (in part because of some unusual financial incentives in Los Angeles which counteracted some of the coverage). But from March, when the Plain Dealer launched its crusade, through June, the most recent month for which data are available, the number of children torn from their homes in Cuyahoga County has soared by 60 percent compared with the same period in 2009. During those same four months, the number of children freed from foster care plummeted by one-third.

That means it's only a matter of time before all the other problems associated with foster-care panic become apparent: DCFS becomes desperate for beds, foster homes become overcrowded, standards for foster parents are lowered, more children moved from home to home and more children are placed in group homes and institutions run by powerful private agencies paid for every day they hold those children in care. Indeed, it appears to be people at private foster care agencies who are fueling some of the Plain Dealer's coverage.

But a foster-care panic seems to be just what the Plain Dealer wants. A Plain Dealer editorial declared that DCFS' job "is to whisk youngsters out of dangerous homes…" In fact, DCFS' job is to ensure that children are safe – preferably by removing the danger and only when that isn't possible by removing the child.

And de facto editorial writer Harlan Spector (officially what he writes are referred to as "news stories") summed up the Plain Dealer party line in a story last week. According to the story:

Critics say the county has been too quick to return children to troubled households, too slow to remove them from risky environments and too conservative in launching investigations.

A foster parent then got five paragraphs to attack DCFS for doing too much to keep families together – with no rebuttal.

Of course there also were the usual features of these sorts of crusades: the ritual editorial page demand for the firing of the agency chief, in this case DCFS Director Deborah Forkas. Forkas herself followed the ritual – she named an OBRC (Obligatory Blue-Ribbon Commission) to study her agency.

The whole thing is all-the-more reprehensible because the Plain Dealer is the one place with less excuse than any other newspaper to make these mistakes. Because the Plain Dealer is the one newspaper to own up to these kinds of mistakes, and expose the price of panic, when very similar errors were made more than a decade ago.

Every time reporter Spector and the editorial writer who handles these issues (probably Sharon Broussard, who wrote the editorials cited in earlier posts to this Blog) repeats these blunders they also, in effect, spit in the faces of the far better former Plain Dealer journalists who wrote Child Welfare Gone Haywire in 2004.

SCRAPING THE BOTTOM OF THE HORROR STORY BARREL

    In calling for Forkas' resignation, a Plain Dealer editorial declared that "under Forkas' management, children's services staff have returned children to mothers who later killed them and they have dragged their feet on removing toddlers found in a home full of cat feces."

    Leaving aside the fact that the latter claim isn't quite accurate (more on that later), if that's the criterion for firing child welfare agency chiefs, almost every such job in every medium and large sized jurisdiction in America will be vacant – forever.

    Neither the editorial writer, presumably Broussard, nor anyone on the news side has produced any evidence that child abuse fatalities among children known to the system, or other tragedies, have increased under Forkas' watch. And given the size of Cuyahoga County a one-year change, for better or worse, in the most extreme cases wouldn't tell us anything. (More on that on Monday). Nevertheless, now that the Plain Dealer is paying attention to them, the tragedies have been declared a "series" a "string" and a "spate."

    But you have to wonder how desperate they are for horror stories when you get to the cat feces case.

    The "hook" there was that animal control officers removed the cats, but DCFS didn't remove the children. That, of course, implies they arrived simultaneously, the DCFS workers saw the filth and didn't care. Or, as a Plain Dealer news story by reporter Laura Johnston put it: "Two toddlers were removed from their cat-feces covered home five months after the Animal Protective League called Children and Family Services."

    Except that's not true.

    Although an animal control officer says he reported the case to DCFS as soon as he saw it, DCFS says they did not receive a call until more than a month later – and Forkas says she has a tape to prove it. By then, Forkas says – and no one disputes - the family had moved in with relatives and everything was neat and clean. DCFS helped the family move to a new home, monitored them for two months, then closed the case. A month later things had deteriorated. The new home allegedly was as bad as the old. On that occasion, there apparently is no dispute that animal control notified DCFS right away. DCFS responded right away – and immediately removed the children.

    Yet Johnston's news story implied the children were in the same filthy house for five months, and accepted the animal control officer's claim as true. Broussard wrote in an editorial that even if DCFS' account is correct, and they really did find the family living with relatives in a neat, clean home, that doesn't excuse their "failure" in this case. Apparently, Broussard expects DCFS workers to be psychic. It's a demand she has made of those workers in connection with at least one previous case as well.

THE NEWS COVERAGE WORSENS

    Initially the problem at the Plain Dealer was primarily with the editorial page. Their failures, including the accuracy problem, are described in these earlier posts to this Blog. At that time, the news coverage played it straight, and one reporter, Diane Suchetka, who once had been the regular reporter on the social services beat, tried hard to add context and perspective. But, for whatever reason, she's not covering these stories anymore. The work of her replacement, Harlan Spector, is a classic example of the sneer and swagger that is typical of the worst child welfare reporting.

    Spector's specialties are loaded language and declaring his own opinions to be fact. In his story about the cat feces case, Spector decreed that "Had the system worked like [sic] it's supposed to, the kids would have been taken into custody in November." One could as easily opine that had the system worked as it's supposed to, the family would have gotten intensive, ongoing help so their new home would not deteriorate. Neither opinion belongs, unattributed, in a news story.

    A month later, Spector was back, offering up the shocking revelation that Cuyahoga County's child abuse hotline screens out some calls – just like just about every other child abuse hotline in America. The story implies that this didn't happen at all before Forkas instituted a new policy – though it's clear from what amounts to the story's fine print that it did. The story claimed that half of all calls now are screened out. The story also claimed that "the policy has child welfare advocates in an uproar."

    In fact, Cuyahoga County always screened calls. What's new is that the county now is following state guidelines for screening – something buried in a brief mention far down in the story.

    The claim that the county is screening out half of all calls, "is simply not accurate" according to County Commissioner Timothy Hagan. In a Plain Dealer op ed column he wrote:

    In fact, less than one-third are screened out, primarily because: (1) They have already been reported and are under investigation (duplicates account for about 15 percent of screen outs); or (2) the call doesn't meet the state's criteria for abuse and neglect. For example, a caller might report poor hygiene, a dirty home, a spanking or a parent swearing at a child -- none of which alone meet state criteria. But even then, DCFS social workers consider both the child's age and the severity of the incident when determining whether to investigate. 

Finally, numbers don't tell the whole story. In December 2008, DCFS converted to a state-mandated data management system. Cuyahoga County resisted this switch because many other Ohio counties reported problems with the system. Under this system, every call is documented whether or not it involves a child at risk. A worker goes through 16 screens and multiple drop-down menus to document each call. If she makes a mistake -- perhaps misspelling a name or entering an incorrect birth date -- it counts as a "screen out," thus requiring a new record. This creates more records but not necessarily more cases that require investigation. 


    Of course I can't prove Hagan is right and Spector is wrong. But in the weeks since Hagan's op ed column ran, as far as I know, the Plain Dealer has neither corrected its reporting – nor challenged Hagan's rebuttal. That's often the way newspapers handle a blunder when they know they screwed up but don't want to admit it.

    As for those "child welfare advocates" supposedly "in an uproar," of the three quoted, two of them work for big private agencies that live on a steady supply of foster children. And lately, in Cuyahoga County, the living hasn't been so easy.

ARE PRIVATE AGENCIES BEHIND THE FEAR AND SMEAR?

    That brings me to the story that just might explain everything: The one about budget cuts.

    Like just about everywhere else in the country, Cuyahoga County is facing budget problems, and all departments were ordered to cut their budgets. Those that exceeded their targets in the last fiscal year got some of the money back this year as a reward. DCFS was one of those agencies.

    Some budget cuts last year and in previous years took a serious toll. But DCFS did most of the cutting in exactly the right way: by taking fewer children and, especially, by relying more on family foster care and less on group homes and institutions which are both the worst form of care and the most expensive.

    So, first DCFS cuts the number of children warehoused in institutions and group homes run by private agencies paid for every day they hold children in foster care. Then, a few months later, lo and behold: Stories appear in the Plain Dealer about the horrors resulting when not enough children are taken from their homes. Perhaps it's a coincidence. But if not, it certainly wouldn't be the first time people with a vested interest fed stories like that to credulous reporters.

    And the Plain Dealer wrote the budget cut story in exactly the way the private agencies would want. Laura Johnston's story began this way:

Cuyahoga County's child welfare agency ended last year with a $7.5 million surplus -- more than any of the county's other offices -- in part by keeping more children with their parents rather than in foster homes. And the county has rewarded that thriftiness despite recent high-profile cases in which children died or suffered severe malnutrition after the agency reunited them with their mothers.

    The story even rehabilitated the politician singled out by the Plain Dealer's excellent reporting in 2004 as most responsible for making child welfare go "haywire" in the 1990s. Whereas the 2004 stories exposed how much harm then-County Commissioner Timothy McCormack had done, when he gave the Plain Dealer the quote it wanted, criticizing the budget cuts, McCormack became "a long-time champion of child welfare services." The story did note that McCormack is running for the newly-created post of Cuyahoga County Executive.

    None of this would matter so much if not for the fact that children's lives are at stake – literally. Because while Cuyahoga County is too small to detect any pattern, the one thing we know from places that are big enough is that over and over again, foster-care panics have had the same result: More children die.

    It looks like the Obligatory Blue-Ribbon Commission named by Forkas to study the system understands that. And that probably explains why the Plain Dealer now is going after the commission. That story Monday.

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Foster care in Cleveland: The latest danger to children of battered mothers - Plain Dealer editorials

Perhaps the most common child welfare story in American newspapers is the story of the death of a child "known to the system." But all such cases are not alike.

In some cases, the failure of the child welfare agency to act is stark and obvious. These are the cases in which the file reveals more "red flags" than a Soviet May Day parade. Other cases are more ambiguous. Perhaps still another visit to the home would have revealed the danger, maybe some extra phone calls. But caseworkers are so overloaded with false allegations and trivial cases that they usually don't have time for that. I would argue that the tragic deaths of the children of Banita Jacks in Washington D.C. fit this category.

And then there are the cases in which the child welfare agency would have to be psychic to predict the tragedy. Based on the information made public so far, it appears that the case of Arshon Baker of Cleveland is one of those.

But such distinctions are of no interest to the editorial writers at the Cleveland Plain Dealer. They're on a righteous-indignation high right now, too busy reveling in their own fury to notice that, in their quest to scapegoat family preservation, they distorted the facts of the case - as reported by the Plain Dealer's own news staff. In the process they've heightened the risk to some of Cuyahoga County's most vulnerable children – those whose mothers have themselves been victims of domestic violence.

PLAIN DEALER VS. PLAIN DEALER

Compare how the editorial writers describe the case to what the Plain Dealer's own reporter found – keeping in mind that the editorial writers say they relied on the news story. Here's the editorial page version:

[Angel] Glass, Arshon's mother, was last in contact with the county child welfare department in October 2008. She subsequently lost her two part-time jobs, went off her medication and became so depressed she couldn't get out of bed in the morning.

But since her case was closed after she agreed to take a parenting class -- she had called the agency after her boyfriend slapped Arshon's sibling -- she was no longer on the department's radar screen as her life spiraled out of control.

Now compare that to the facts of the case, as reported by the same newspaper. (I've put some key points in bold):

Children and Family Services began helping her in June 2007, a year after her release [from prison on an assault charge].
It wasn't because she'd done anything to harm Arshon or his sister, who's 18 months older. Child welfare workers showed up after Glass called police to report that her boyfriend, Larry Wanzo, had slapped her 4-year-old daughter in the face. The little girl was trying to stop the drunken, 6-foot, 5-inch, 210-pound man from hurting her mother, according to the police report.
Glass was doing the right thing, [Cuyahoga County DCFS Director Deborah] Forkas said.

"She was trying to protect the child."

An investigation found no need for action against her. Because she was in a violent relationship, a case worker suggested that Glass enroll in weekly parenting classes and counseling sessions and agree to monthly visits from Children and Family Services.

Glass welcomed the help.

"She was very, very cooperative," Forkas said. "She could've said, 'no.' It was not a forced case plan."
Glass continued the classes and counseling until October 2008. Because she successfully completed the program, Children and Family Services closed her case.

"The professionals that were treating her really felt she had made a tremendous amount of progress," Forkas said. "She was completely stable."

Her office offered Glass ongoing counseling, paid for by Medicaid. Glass, she said, continued the sessions. But because Children and Family Services was no longer supervising her case, workers don't know for how long. [Emphasis added].

Glass also had an outstanding warrant for an assault charge – that occurred a year before she ever contacted DCFS. But the warrant never was served and DCFS never knew about it.

WRONG ON A KEY FACT

So for starters the Plain Dealer editorial writers are simply flat wrong when they claim the case was closed after Glass agreed to take parenting classes. The case stayed open far longer.

More generally, what do the facts actually show: A mother with a criminal record – before she ever reached out to DCFS - but no record of child abuse. A mother who did nothing to harm her child, and never was accused of doing so. A mother who reached out to protect both children, and accepted help when she was under no obligation to do so.

What, besides psychic powers, would have allowed DCFS to know that long after the case was closed she would lose her jobs, go off her medication and allegedly kill her child? How would DCFS know this case was different from all the other cases of poor people who lose their jobs in a recession, become depressed – and don't harm their children?

Unless, of course, the Plain Dealer is taking the position that DCFS should confiscate the children of any battered mother who reaches out for help – or any mother who reaches out for help when her boyfriend hits a child.

In fact, the trauma to a child of separation from a loving mother actually is heightened if that mother is, herself, a victim of domestic violence. One expert calls it "tantamount to pouring salt into an open wound." (Is the Plain Dealer now advocating a policy that amounts to "please pass the salt?") That's why a class-action lawsuit led to banning this pernicious practice in New York City (NCCPR's Vice President was co-counsel for the plaintiffs). Such removals are of sufficient concern in Ohio for the Ohio Domestic Violence Network to have filed a "friend of the court" brief in the case.

Even if this is not literally what the Plain Dealer wants, consider the message the editorial writers are sending to other women like Glass – if the newspaper gets its way, and pressures DCFS into taking a take-the-child-and-run approach in these kinds of cases.

If there's one thing we know about men who abuse their partners and their children it's that they can be highly manipulative. So what happens to the next mother in Glass' position who wants to seek help because a boyfriend has beaten her child, or her? Why shouldn't we expect the boyfriend to say: "Go ahead. Call the cops. They'll just call DCFS and they'll take away your kids. I read it in the Plain Dealer."

Monday, April 5, 2010

Foster care in Cleveland: Will child welfare “go haywire” again?

The 1990s were a time of chaos for the child welfare system in Cuyahoga County, Ohio (metropolitan Cleveland). Stories about child abuse deaths led to scapegoating and panic, making a bad system far worse. Thousands of children were swept needlessly into foster care, destroying their families and often, the children's futures.

I say things like that a lot on this Blog, of course. But this time, it's not just my conclusion. Those are the findings of one of the most extraordinary pieces of reporting on child welfare I've seen anywhere in the country, a 4000-word dissection of how the wrong response to tragedy collapsed a child welfare system, published in the Cleveland Plain Dealer on August 8, 2004. The headline said it all: "Child welfare gone haywire."

But let the Plain Dealer reporters explain it:

What has been described as a culture of hysteria had engulfed the Jane Edna Hunter Social Services Building. … Rather than risk censure for making a costly mistake, … social workers concluded that it was safer for them to just take the kids. The result was a six-year foster-care tidal wave … [The Cuyahoga County Department of Children and Family Services] started taking kids away from their families at a furious pace, overwhelming its foster-home network and burdening taxpayers with huge increases in costs.

DCFS Director James McCafferty acknowledges that many of the thousands of additional foster-care placements may have been unnecessary.

The story was extraordinary in another respect. The Plain Dealer acknowledged the role of lousy, out-of-context media coverage in fueling the panic and contributing to the disastrous results.

Ultimately, the system righted itself, and child safety improved.

But now, child abuse fatalities and near fatalities are back on the front page. And guess who hasn't learned a damn thing from all those mistakes in the 1990s: The
Plain Dealer.

Not everyone at the Plain Dealer. The news coverage has been largely careful and straightforward, and one reporter, Diane Suchetka, has tried to add some context. But the editorial board has systematically ignored all the lessons from "Child welfare gone haywire." In the process they've increased the chances of more child abuse deaths, increased the odds that battered women will be driven underground and away from seeking help, and figuratively spat in the face of Joel Rutchick and Kera Ritter, the two excellent former Plain Dealer reporters who wrote "Child welfare gone haywire."

●The Plain Dealer editorial board resurrected the canard that, because children known-to-the system sometimes die, and because two such cases, and one that came close, happened in rapid succession, the county must be putting family preservation ahead of child safety – even though, using measures that are far more reliable than horror stories, Cuyahoga County has a better record for keeping children safe than many Ohio counties that take away proportionately more children. (Details are in NCCPR's report on Ohio child welfare).

●A columnist assumed that all parents who lose their children to foster care must have done terrible things to those children, and it's too easy to get them back. In fact, children often are taken when poverty is confused with neglect. Then the children are bounced from foster home to foster home, emerging years later unable to love or trust anyone, while their parents are forced to jump through meaningless hoops.

●Another columnist says bring back the orphanage – even though there is overwhelming evidence that warehousing children even in "good" orphanages is, by far, the worst option.

Countering these very myths is a large part of what "Child welfare gone haywire" was all about.

WHAT DOESN'T WORK…

As has been noted often on this Blog, we know what really works, and what does not, to curb child abuse tragedies.

A major national study found that taking away more children doesn't work. That's not as surprising as it may sound. In Cuyahoga County, a county with nearly 300,000 children, there were six children previously known-to-the-system killed by their caretakers in 2009. Though each is the worst form of tragedy, they also are needles in a haystack. You'll never find all the needles by trying to vacuum up the entire haystack.

We also know that little is more dangerous for children than falsely equating child removal with child safety. Two massive studies of more than 15,000 typical cases found that children placed in foster care typically fared far worse in later life than comparably-maltreated children left in their own homes – even when those families got little or no help. Several other studies have found abuse in one-quarter to one-third of foster homes, and the record of orphanages is worse.

The worst option of all is another 1990s-style foster-care panic, with terrified caseworkers rushing to tear apart families not to protect children but to protect themselves from winding up on the front page of The Plain Dealer.

Researchers at Case Western Reserve University estimate that before they reach the age of ten, nearly one-third of all children in Cuyahoga County are put through the trauma of a child abuse investigation. And that's the countywide figure. Since it's unlikely that many of those investigations are occurring in, say, Pepper Pike, it is likely that such trauma has simply become one more hardship to endure for the majority of children in the City of Cleveland.

Now that figure, and entries into foster care, are likely to soar. Not only would that do enormous harm to the children needlessly investigated and taken, it also will overload caseworkers, making it less likely that they will find the children in real danger. That's why, in state after state, foster-care panics have been followed by increases in child abuse deaths.

None of this means no child ever should be taken away. But foster care is an extremely toxic intervention that must be used sparingly and in small doses. Nothing would hurt children more than returning to the days when Cuyahoga County prescribed mega-doses of foster care, and child welfare went haywire.

…AND WHAT DOES

What does work? Ameliorating the worst effects of poverty works. Curbing teen pregnancy works. Some child abuse prevention programs cited in some of Suchetka's stories work – but, as the stories point out, Cuyahoga County often is not using them.

They don't work perfectly. No state or county will be able to prevent every tragedy, not even every tragedy in which a child was "known to the system." But Cuyahoga's record, both when child welfare went haywire and then when it improved, shows that the way to reduce such tragedies is to do more, not less, to keep families together.

Unfortunately, there are signs that the county child welfare agency already has begun to cave. Cuyahoga DCFS is taking the classic steps seen elsewhere when agencies are in full cave-in mode:

  • They've named an OBRC (Obligatory Blue-Ribbon Commission)
  • They're "reviewing" all open cases and all child reunifications from January 2009 through the present. The problem with that is lack of any comparable review of all cases in which children are in foster care to see if all of them need to be in foster care. The message to the frontlines is obvious.

In "Child welfare gone haywire," even the politician most responsible for the panic in the 1990s, former County Commissioner Timothy McCormack, expressed some regrets. He said he had to do something but "I didn't know there was a better way."

This time, nobody has that excuse.

And, remarkably, one current County Commissioner apparently has learned from McCormack's mistakes and is standing up for Cuyahoga County's reforms. According to one recent Plain-Dealer story:

Cuyahoga County Commissioner Peter Lawson Jones criticized the media scrutiny of the agency over the recent cases and said the workers are dedicated to protecting children.

If you'd like to know more, too bad. Jones was relegated to the last 50 words of a 700 word story.

IN A FUTURE POST: HOW THE PLAIN DEALER EDITORIAL BOARD ENDANGERS BATTERED MOTHERS – AND ESPECIALLY THEIR CHILDREN.