Showing posts with label obesity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label obesity. Show all posts

Monday, December 6, 2021

UPDATED: A Pennsylvania case illustrates again why, for children, “best interests of the child” is among the most dangerous phrases in the “child welfare” lexicon

         


UPDATE, DECEMBER 15, 2021: The York Daily Record has an excellent story about this case.

  Consider a recent case involving the family policing system in a county in Pennsylvania.  Everything I am about to recount is true except for one detail: 

            Two young children are taken from their mother.  Their father is eager to take them in, but at the time of the removal he’s in the hospital.  That’s because after he was hit by a drunk driver and confined to a wheelchair it led to medical complications that sometimes require hospitalization. 

            But once home from the hospital, the children still are left in foster care – with foster parents who are eager to adopt.  Dad must jump through the usual hoops, but, as is so often the case, it’s never enough.  

            Sure, the usual “bonding evaluation” says, the children are excited to see Dad during visits.  But the court focuses on the part where the evaluator complains that the children have to be the ones to initiate contact with Dad because of Dad’s “compromised mobility.” 

            Then there’s the matter of how long it would take Dad to get upstairs, even with a wheelchair lift in the home.  Three or four minutes – that could be too late in an emergency.  And while it’s true Dad’s aunt is living in the home, the court is worried because she is, to use the judge’s word “elderly.”  She’s 68. 

           


            So the county wants the children taken from their father forever.  They move to change the case goal for the children from reunification to adoption.  The judge rubber-stamps the change with enthusiasm.  An appellate court agrees.  Next stop, presumably: Termination of parental rights, after which the children, now ages five and three may never see their loving father again. 

            But even in a system as riven with every bias under the sun this wouldn’t really happen, right?  Well no* – and yes.  Because, except for that one small detail, it did just happen, in Jefferson County, Pennsylvania. 

            Here’s the detail: Dad’s mobility isn’t compromised because he’s confined to a wheelchair.  It’s compromised because of his weight.  At least partly because of hypothyroidism, he weighs over 400 pounds.  It was complications from his obesity that landed him in the hospital, there was no auto accident.  And, of course, there’s no wheelchair. It’s the obesity that slows him down going up stairs. 

            Everything else, though is straight from the appellate court decision – including the children’s love for their father, and the fact that the trial court judge wrote off the 68-year-old aunt as “elderly.”  I changed the one detail because so many people view obesity as both repugnant and a moral failing – apparently including the trial court judge, whose decision includes finger-wagging comments suggesting the problem is that dad lacked the willpower to embrace a healthy diet. 

            Even were that so, however, that still wouldn’t be grounds to keep this man’s children from him forever – or even for one day.  

            ● For starters, there’s another caretaker in the home.  Apparently, as noted above, she’s ruled out because at age 68 she’s “elderly.”  Presumably this also would rule out a large proportion of those providing kinship foster care, since they tend to be grandparents. 

            The appellate court had no problem with this. In fact, in one way the appellate court decision may be even worse.  In a footnote, the judges write that 

 “While Father complains that the ‘Agency offered no evidence that the aunt is a threat to the children and nothing more than a helping hand[,]” Father has not offered any evidence that his aunt was an appropriate, substitute caregiver.” 

            But why should it be up to a father who never has himself been accused of abusing or neglecting the children, and an aunt who faces no such accusation either, to prove the aunt is suitable?  Shouldn’t it be up to the family policing agency to prove she isn’t suitable?  By this court’s logic, every family that decides to have grandma babysit while they go on vacation should have to go to court and get approval first – with the burden of proof on them to show grandma is “suitable.” 

            ● Even if there were no aunt available, the decision still is wrong.  Federal law
requires that states make “reasonable efforts” to keep families together.  This case is one more illustration of the fact that
the law is routinely ignored.  In this case, home health care should have been enough to alleviate all of the family policing agency’s concerns.  And if they were still obsessing over Dad’s ability to climb stairs, how about finding the family a place to live that doesn’t have stairs?  This is what affluent families do in such situations.  That’s one reason why, you may be sure, rich parents don’t lose their children because of obesity. 

            The case also illustrates bigger problems. 

  


          ● The fundamental fact of American “child welfare” is that if you’re not white and affluent the system will discriminate against you. (That’s not unique to “child welfare” of course, but the field seems to be “in denial” about it to an extraordinary degree.) Usually we see this in the form of discrimination based on race and class.  But discrimination against families with physical or mental disabilities gets far less attention, even though it is just as widespread. 

            As Prof. Robyn Powell of Stetson University College of Law has written: 

The disproportionate rate of child welfare system involvement in families headed by parents with disabilities is striking. Although children of parents with disabilities comprise only 9 percent of the nation’s youth, they make up 19 percent of the children in foster care. 

The National Council on Disability—an independent federal agency that advises the President and U.S. Congress on disability policy—described the child welfare system’s bias against parents with disabilities as “persistent, systemic, and pervasive.” 

Similarly, the U.S. Department of Justice and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services have stated that the child welfare system’s discriminatory policies and practices toward parents with disabilities are “long-standing and widespread.”     

Indeed, those two departments demanded reform from Massachusetts family policing officials for violating the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.  They eventually reached a settlement.  Similar issues have arisen in Oregon.  

But the ADA rarely is raised in family policing cases. UPDATE, DEC 15, 2021: Though it is not always clear when it applies in cases involving obesity, Prof. Powell told the York Daily Record it does apply in this case.  According to the story:

Under the Americans with Disability Act, the father in this case would likely be considered a person with a disability, Powell said after reading the court document.

"It seems to me that they’re discriminating against him because of the disability and not recognizing the in-home support he has," she said. 

Why “best interests of the child” isn’t in the best interests of the child 

This case also illustrates why one of the most common and most revered phrases in the child welfare lexicon is, for children, one of the most dangerous.  The phrase, of course, is “best interests of the child.”  It is an invitation for family policing agencies and courts to inflict their own biases, whether based on race, religion, ethnicity, sexual preference, disability – or weight, on a family and then confiscate and transfer children at will. 

You can’t say you’re doing that, of course, but that is the practical effect or such broad, vague language in a system with no real checks and balances. 

That’s always been true in American family policing, but it was made worse with the passage of the so-called Adoption and Safe Families Act.   The appellate court appears almost gleeful when it cites ASFA, even putting the last sentence in this paragraph in bold: 

Placement of and custody issues pertaining to dependent children are controlled by the [Pennsylvania] Juvenile Act, which was amended in 1998 to conform to the federal Adoption and Safe Families Act (“ASFA”) The policy underlying these statutes is to prevent children from languishing indefinitely in foster care, with its inherent lack of permanency, normalcy, and long-term parental commitment. Consistent with this underlying policy, the 1998 amendments to the Juvenile Act, as required by the ASFA, place the focus of dependency proceedings, including change of goal proceedings, on the child. Safety, permanency, and well-being of the child must take precedence over all other considerations, including the rights of the parents.  [Emphasis in original, citations omitted.]

 By that standard, of course, family policing agencies should be empowered to walk into any and every home, regardless of whether there is even an accusation of abuse or neglect and if they decide the child would be in any way better off with someone else take them away on the spot. 

            That is why, in theory, courts are not supposed to reach the issue of “best interests” until after determining birth parents are unfit.  The one good thing about this decision is that it reveals what judges really do. 

Even if we were to accept the judges’ reasoning, and even if we were to accept that ASFA was necessary for any of these goals – and, on the contrary, it impedes them -- in this case there was no safety issue that couldn’t be remedied with “reasonable efforts” – and possibly no issue at all.  There should have been no issue of the children languishing in foster care because there was no need for them to be in foster care once the father was out of the hospital. That takes care of “permanence.”  And there is nothing to indicate that tearing these children from their father forever would improve their “well-being.” 

So this case perfectly illustrates how ASFA is simply a license to take children from people we don’t happen to like and hand them over to people we do. 

            Strip away the legalese and the decision of the trial court judge in this case, in its entirely can be boiled down to: “Eeewwwww, he’s so fat.  I’ll just give the kids to the people I like better.”  The decision of the appellate court boils down to “We have no problem with that.” 

            Come to think of it, substitute “Black,” “Brown,” “Native American” “LGBTQ” or “poor” for “fat” and you have a huge body of “child welfare” caselaw. 

*-That “no” might be overly optimistic.  I’m not aware of a case in which children were taken from a parent forever because the parent was confined to a wheelchair, but sadly, it wouldn’t surprise me if it’s happened.  This post may yet be updated.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

Foster care in Cleveland: Did Plain Dealer sleaze claim another victim?

UPDATE, NOV. 30: Citing court records WKYC-TV is now reporting that, in foster care “the child is having dreams of dying, is wetting the bed, and is anxious that the world is going to end in 2012.”  The station also reports that part of the reason Cuyahoga County DCFS took the child away is that the mother missed some appointments.  As noted below, the foster mother also is having trouble keeping up with appointments, but DCFS is responding somewhat differently.


            You’ve probably already heard about this one: the eight-year-old boy who weighed 218 pounds and has been consigned to foster care as a result.

            Apparently oblivious to the emotional trauma of tearing this child from his mother, (including the fact that, at age 8, this child may now believe he did something wrong and now is being punished) the Cuyahoga County Department of Children and Family Services showed up at his school one day last month and refused to let him go home.  They shoved him directly into a foster home.   His mother can’t even visit him for more than two hours a week.

            The Cleveland Plain Dealer actually did a very good job with the story.  Among other things the story noted that:

            ● The child was on the honor roll at his school and participated in school activities.

            ● The child only came to the attention of child welfare authorities, early in 2010, because his single mother, a substitute teacher who also is taking vocational school classes, brought him to the hospital because of breathing problems.  He was diagnosed with sleep apnea, which often is caused by obesity.

            The story doesn’t say exactly how this led to DCFS intervention, but, as we all know in the wake of Penn State, doctors and nurses are “mandated reporters” required to call in any suspicion of “child abuse.”

DCFS did not remove the child then and there; instead, the agency started monitoring the family.  There is no mention of the agency helping the family.

            ● The boy did, in fact, lose weight.  But recently he began gaining it back – apparently siblings were sneaking him food.

            ● The mother voluntarily enrolled the child in a special hospital program to help obese children.

            What mom could not do, of course, was hire a personal trainer, or enroll the child in special camps or even keep an eye on him at all times, as wealthy families can do.  So it’s no wonder that Dr. Arthur Caplan, America’s most quoted medical ethicist, told the Plain Dealer he was concerned that, as the newspaper put it, “families with the fewest resources, which often are minorities, will end up being the ones with their children removed.”

            No kidding.

            Prof. Vivek Sankaran of the University of Michigan Child Advocacy Center is dealing with a similar case in Detroit.  "This is really dangerous stuff we're talking about," he told a Time magazine blog in July.  "A lot of people don't realize how traumatic it is for children to be ripped away from their parents."

In the case he’s working on, Sankaran said:

What we've seen … is that the actual removal causes irreparable damage to the child — emotional problems, behavioral problems — and it's the type of thing that can't be remedied.  People think [removing the child] is a quick fix, but you need to make sure you have tried every other possibility to protect the child.

Clearly in the Cleveland case they didn’t.  Because here’s the kicker – according to Mom’s public defender it turns out that the foster mother, who lives in a nearby suburb, can’t keep up with all the child’s appointments – even though that’s what was expected of the boy’s single mother, even as she juggled her efforts to improve her education and make a living.

But The Plain Dealer reports that DCFS was far more solicitous of the foster mother.  The newspaper reports that, according to the mother’s public defender, “There was even a discussion about getting the foster mother additional help or moving the child again, this time to a foster home with a personal trainer.”

            That prompted the public defender to ask the obvious question: “I wonder why they didn’t offer the mother that kind of extra help.”
           
THE NEWSPAPER AS ENABLER

            So if the Plain Dealer covered the story so well, why do I think the newspaper shares responsibility for this travesty?  Because the Plain Dealer did so much to create the climate made it almost inevitable.

            Early in 2010, after the Plain Dealer rediscovered two facts:

1.       Cuyahoga County has a child protective services agency and
2.      sometimes children known to that agency die,

it was the sleazy reporting by Harlan Spector and the even worse editorials by Sharon Broussard, falsely blaming the deaths on efforts to keep families together, that set off a huge foster-care panic in Cuyahoga County.

            The panic began in March of 2010.  By September of that year, the number of children taken from their homes had soared 65 percent over the same period in 2009 – and the panic has continued at the same rate this year.

            So why did the Plain Dealer do better on this story?  Probably because it was written by a different reporter, Rachel Dissell.

            I don’t know how it happened that Dissell was assigned to the story.  Perhaps in the midst of all the misery this family has been forced to endure, they got one stroke of luck.  Maybe Harlan Spector was taking the days around Thanksgiving off.