Thursday, January 7, 2016

Remembering Judith Kaye, the New York judge who put the “family” in Family Court

Judge Judith Kaye
Judith Kaye, the first woman named to New York State’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, and the first to serve as its Chief Judge, died today at age 77.

Though The New York Times notes many of her accomplishments, the paper neglects some of the most important.  They concerned the state’s Family Courts.  Here are some of them:

Protecting domestic violence victims, and their children

It had been common practice in New York – and remains common practice elsewhere – for child protective services agencies to take away children from battered mothers, just because the mothers “allowed” the child to “witness domestic violence.”

A federal class-action lawsuit brought an end to the practice in New York. (NCCPR’s Vice President, Carolyn Kubitschek, was co-counsel for the plaintiffs.)  During the course of that suit expert after expert testified that while witnessing domestic violence sometimes can, indeed, be emotionally harmful to a child, taking that child from the victim of the violence is much, much worse.  One expert said that, for the child, it is “tantamount to pouring salt into an open wound.”

The section of U.S. District Judge Jack Weinstein’s decision summarizing this testimony remains one of the most popular pages on NCCPR’s website.

After Weinstein ruled, the City appealed.  At one point the federal appellate court sought clarification of New York law from the state Court of Appeals.  That led to a sweeping, unanimous decision, written by Judge Kaye, making clear that New York State law does not allow this barbaric practice.  In effect, that extended the impact of the lawsuit statewide (though, as always, it’s not clear if child protective services agencies actually are following the law).

Giving children real lawyers

Although juvenile court hearings are supposed to be all about the children, often the children are effectively silenced.  That’s because instead of a lawyer tasked with advocating for what the child wants, children often get “law guardians” who are free to substitute their own judgment for that of the child.   And that’s often the easiest course of action, particularly when it simply involves rubber-stamping the recommendation of a child protective services agency.   So if a child desperately wants to return to her or his parents from foster care, but the law guardian disagrees, the child is effectively silenced.  (While less common, a child who desperately wants to remain in foster care also may be silenced, and that is equally wrong.)

Of course, the fact that a child wants a particular outcome doesn’t mean he or she should get it. And some children are too young to express a rational preference, or any preference at all. But deciding what’s best is what judges are for.  And they can’t truly do justice unless everyone has an advocate making the best possible case for his or her side.

The New York State Bar Association promulgated guidelines calling for children’s lawyers to follow the direction of their clients – the children - except where the child was too young.    But the guidelines were not binding.  Judge Kaye made them binding.

Opening family courts to press and public

One of the reasons juvenile courts can get away with trampling on the rights of families, and attorneys can provide representation that’s inadequate – or worse – is that, in much of the country, the hearings are secret.  Slowly that’s been changing, and today, nearly half of America’s foster children live in states where these hearings are open to the public and/or the press. 

In New York, that was done by order of Judge Kaye.  I believe the news stories exposing what went on those courts after the hearings first were opened are part of the reason New York City became a national leader in providing high quality defense counsel for families caught up in the child welfare system through organizations like The Bronx Defenders, Brooklyn Family Defense Practice and the Center for Family Representation.

And no one ever boiled down the rationale for opening these courts better.  Said Judge Kaye: “Sunshine is good for children.”

Her own family has many reasons to be proud of the legacy of Judge Judith Kaye.  And a lot of children and parents who may never have heard of her have reason to be grateful.

Saturday, January 2, 2016

Child welfare in Oregon: A columnist's self-indulgent rage isn't helping

I’ve previously noted that one of the easiest ways for a newspaper columnist to fill space is to write the "boy-if-there's-one-thing-in-the-world-that-I-really-really-hate-more-than-anything-it's-child abuse-and-all-the-people-who-let-this-child-die-must-be-lazy-or-idiots” column. 

Former home of The Oregonian
No actual reporting is required. If anyone disagrees with anything in the column then at best they just don’t care; at worst they’re in favor of child abuse.  Aside from filling space, these columns accomplish nothing except to encourage a rush to take away more children.  That’s dangerous in any state, but especially in one like Oregon, which takes away children at a rate well above the national average.

I’ve noted before that a master of this genre is Steve Duin at the Oregonian in Portland – which is too bad, since he’s also capable of much better work.

Duin was at it again on December 22.  This time he seemed intent less on calling attention to child abuse than on distracting readers from where a lot of that abuse has been turning up lately in Oregon – foster care.

He begins this way: 
Oleander Labier weighed 28 pounds when, at the age of 5, her torture finally ended. And while Oleander doesn't rank high in terms of blood money, those millions the state of Oregon has paid out in settlements in cases involving the Department of Human Services, hers is the story of neglect and suffering that still speaks to me. 
It should speak to anyone.  But so should the case that actually prompted the huge payout Duin is talking about.  Here’s what that case involved, according to the Salem Statesman-Journal: 
James Earl Mooney, a former Salem resident, pleaded guilty in 2012 to five counts of first-degree sodomy of medically fragile children, ages 48 hours to 3 years, who had disabilities or other special needs. Mooney was sentenced to 50 years in the Eastern Oregon Correctional Institution for crimes that included sodomizing an 18-month-old foster baby in her car seat while his wife attended a doctor's appointment with another foster child. 
Doesn’t that at least whisper to you, Mr. Duin?

Similarly, the scandal involving the foster-care agency Give Us This Day gets barely a mention and no graphic details. (At least Duin gives credit where it’s due - to Willamette Week reporter Nigel Jaquiss - for breaking the story.)

UPDATE, JAN 4, 2016: And just last week, two Oregon newspapers reported on two more examples of foster care failure, this time in "residential treatment."

On one level, the minimal attention to abuse in foster care is understandable.  Talking a lot about it would make the segue to the Only Public Official Who Really Cares part of the column a bit awkward – I’ll get to that in a moment.  But first, there’s the Ritual Condemnation Of The Rest of Us: 
… [R]efusal to take ownership of a tragedy sums up this state's attitude toward the abuse and death of children under our care. Our attitude. Yours and mine. 
I think he really just means yours, Oregon.  He proves how much he cares by writing columns scolding everyone else: 
In not giving a damn, the governor, the Legislature, the attorney general and the Department of Human Services simply follow our lead. 
As I said, Oregon, I think he means your lead.  As for not giving a damn, I’ve previously noted Duin’s belief in his own extraordinary power to read minds.  Once again, he can detect that almost everyone who works for the state human services agency, the Attorney General and every state legislator (except one – we’ll get back to that) doesn’t care.

By the time he says, much farther down that he knows there are  “people who bring extraordinary commitment to their jobs in child welfare …” he sounds like Donald Trump saying that some of the Mexicans crossing the border actually “I assume, are good people.” 

Oregon State Sen. Sara Gelser
But there is one hero in this story (besides the columnist himself).  He writes: 
In recent months, a legislative committee chaired by Sen. Sara Gelser, D-Corvallis, has called the state's foster care agency on the Capitol carpet. … Gelser has a sustained interest in child-welfare issues. Her family has frequently asked her to give it a rest over Sunday dinner. … "I have not seen engagement on this issue in a meaningful way from our prior two governors," Gelser notes. Until Gov. Kate Brown deeded control of the agency to Clyde Saiki last month, nor has [sic]  Gelser seen anyone at the controls of Human Services prioritize child safety. 
I don’t doubt Sen. Gelser’s commitment or her dedication.  But her agenda suggests she has made the common mistake of confusing child removal with child safety.  Again from the column: 
At the very least, Gelser argues, the agency needs a far better screening process for the initial complaints of child abuse and neglect. "We close far more reports at screening – 60 percent – than any state in the country," Gelser says. "There's no investigation. You call the child-welfare line, and nothing happens. And the majority of calls about foster care are closed." 
That’s probably not exactly what Gelser said.  She said Oregon screened out calls at among the highest rates in the country.  (I know this because when I emailed her, at about 2:15pm her time on the day before Christmas, she immediately responded, personally, with the source for her information and what she had tweeted at the time.  As I said, I don’t doubt the part about dedication.)

But looking only at the rate at which calls to a state’s child protection hotline are screened in or screened out can be misleading.

Oregon does screen out calls at a rate well above the national average – though it’s 56.6 percent, not 60 percent.  But Oregonians also are far more likely to call the hotline in the first place (which is pretty remarkable for a state which, according to Duin, is filled with people who don’t give a damn).  Nationwide hotlines get about 47 calls for every thousand children.  In Oregon it’s more than 76.  

It’s possible this is because Oregon is a cesspool of depravity with vastly more child abuse than the nation as a whole.  More likely, however, people in Oregon just happen to be more prone to heed the constant messages to “report” anything and everything, no matter how absurd the suspicion may be.  With that many more people, proportionately, calling in, it makes perfect sense that a larger proportion of cases won’t meet even the minimal standards needed to be accepted for investigation.

In addition, Oregon “substantiates” cases at a rate 35 percent above the national average.  But that’s still only 23 percent of the cases – which means workers are wasting more than three-quarters of their time spinning their wheels – because the screening isn’t strict enough.

So, to review:

● Oregonians phone in reports of child abuse at a rate above the national average.
● Calls are accepted for investigation at a rate below the national average.
● Investigations are substantiated at a rate above the national average.
● Children are removed from their homes at a rate above the national average.

But Sen. Gelser expresses concern only about the figure for screening.

In fairness, Gelser also notes with concern that a majority of reports alleging abuse in foster care are closed at screening.  In fact, that also makes sense. Though multiple studies, including at least one specific to Oregon, have found abuse in one-quarter to one-third of foster homes, that’s still not a majority.

What does not make sense, however, is the fact that allegations of abuse in foster care are screened out at a significantly higher rate  - more than 66 percent – than allegations of abuse in general.  This is still another indication of where the real bias lies in Oregon.

Duin pays more attention to another of Gelser’s concerns: 
Gelser also notes that the majority of reports from the children's Court Appointed Special Advocates – are also dismissed at screening: "That makes no sense to me." 
Actually, it makes perfect sense.  CASA volunteers mean well, but the evidence is overwhelming that the racial and class bias that permeates child welfare is virtually built in to the CASA model.  That may well prompt CASAs to report cases where no maltreatment has taken place.


None of this means the Oregon hotline is working well.  Odds are, like every other part of almost every other child welfare system, it is arbitrary, capricious and cruel, with some cases wrongly screened out — and others wrongly screened in.  In at least three other states, when hotline operators were given identical hypothetical cases, there was no consistency in whether the cases were screened in or out.  So a truly objective investigation would be worthwhile.

But the whole screening debate needs to be seen in the context of that other disturbing statistic:

Oregon tears children from their families at anywhere from 15 to 34 percent above the national average – and it’s been doing that for decades.  Surely, if take-the-child-and-run were the answer, Oregon would have much safer children by now.

Instead, of course, all that needless removal overloads the system, creating an artificial “shortage” of placements.  So the state looks the other way at abuse in foster care.  And now, it seems, Steve Duin wants us to look away from that part of the picture, too.

Sunday, December 20, 2015

Child welfare in Arkansas: The Legislature is not helping

Last of three parts

If little John or Jane from Little Rock isn't in class today,
a child abuse investigator may be at the door tomorrow.
The previous two posts about Arkansas child welfare deal with the failures of Gov. Asa Hutchinson and the State Division of Children and Family Services.  But while the governor has been leading the state backwards, the legislature has been no help.

Consider the issue of “educational neglect.”  This is how we began a blog post on thisissue in 2010:

Late [in 2009] the highly-regarded Vera Institute of Justice, based in New York, issued a report  on one of the seedier back alleys of child welfare: "Educational Neglect." The majority of states, wisely, don't even include such cases in the mandate of their child welfare agencies. Unfortunately, New York, is not one of them. There, educational neglect reports serve one primary function: They're a lever schools can use to force parents to do what they want – like, for instance, not demand too much in the way of special education for their kids, or not complain about school safety.
 
Here are some highlights from the Vera Institute study, which focused on New York State but applies to any state that still lets CPS investigate "educational neglect":
● Overwhelmingly, these are low-risk cases, and it's idiotic to waste the time of child protective services dealing with them. (While that may be obvious, they've got an actual case reading, from Orange County, to prove it.) In addition to wasting the time of CPS workers, sending a CPS worker to the door only makes the family defensive and makes it harder to solve whatever problem may be causing absenteeism.
● The notion that educational neglect is the "tip of the iceberg," a sign of some other, deeper problem, (the primary excuse for CPS investigating such cases), is nonsense. Generally, "educational neglect" is the tip of nothing except some kind of school problem, often one that is not the parent's fault.

So guess what the Arkansas Legislature did this year: It passed a law expanding the jurisdiction of the state Division of Children and Family Services to include educational neglect.  The rationale: Exactly the “tip of the iceberg” assumptions that the Vera Institute study found were wrong.

This is a bad idea in any state.  It’s even dumber in Arkansas, where one of the key problems identified in a report from child welfare expert Paul Vincent (a report commissioned by the state itself) is impossibly high caseloads.

The other issue concerns cases where DCFS does not remove the child, but demands that the family meet certain conditions to keep the child in the home.  In most states, these “safety plans” are used in low-risk cases, and are agreed to by the agency and the family.

The Arkansas Legislature has decided, however, that in Arkansas, every single one of these plans is going to have to be accompanied by a formal charge of abuse or neglect and approved by the court.

According to Vincent’s report:

Regardless of the merits of the Act, it will undoubtedly increase the DCFS workload, including administrative tasks and time in court. It is also likely to increase the number of children placed in foster care.

But there’s more – and it says a lot about the mindset both of DCFS and some in the court system, Vincent writes: 
It is likely that this bill was introduced because of doubts on the part of some stakeholders that DCFS could assure child safety without court oversight. Some legal stakeholders criticized a DCFS practice which they called coercive placements, meaning that DCFS would threaten removal unless the caregiver placed the child with another family member, for example, … 
OK, let me interrupt here.  When I first read this, I thought: Good.  The courts have discovered that DCFS is unfairly strong-arming parents into placing the child into what is foster care in all but name.  This also raises questions about how many times DCFS does this but doesn’t officially report the placement as an entry into foster care, something discussed on this blog here.  So it’s possible the real rate of removal in Arkansas is much higher than the official figures reported to the federal government.

But now, let me allow Vincent to finish his thought (I've put the portion I left out above in bold): 
Some legal stakeholders criticized a DCFS practice which they called coercive placements, meaning that DCFS would threaten removal unless the caregiver placed the child with another family member, for example, without properly reviewing the alternative caregiver’s suitability or petitioning the court.
In other words, these “legal stakeholders” were just fine with DCFS strong-arming the parents – but, in keeping with the profound bias against kinship care that permeates the state, they just didn’t like where the child went after the parents were strong-armed.

Saturday, December 19, 2015

Donald Trump and the child savers: It's not a band, but they sing the same song

Photo by Gage Skidmore

This post originally appeared at the Chronicle of Social Change

Last month, author and political commentator Jeff Greenfield wrote an essay for Politico on the politics of fear – and how Donald Trump exploits it.  He wrote:

History teaches us lessons of what can happen when genuine public fears are co-opted by the demagogues, fear-mongers and over-reactors. There was a reason to fear crime in the 1960s and 1970s, because violent crime in America was increasing by leaps and bounds, but that didn’t mean the only response [had to be] four decades of over-incarceration, driven by politicians’ fears of looking soft on crime. There was a reason to fear a Soviet espionage network looking for military secrets during a Cold War waged in the shadow of countless nuclear weapons, but that didn’t require McCarthyism as a response.There was a reason to fear where Al Qaeda might strike next after 19 men with box cutters killed 3,000 people in the heart of two great cities, but that didn’t mean we had to invade Iraq.

Let me add one to Greenfield’s list: There is a reason to fear that a small number of parents are brutally abusive and will do terrible things to innocent children if they are not stopped.  But that doesn’t mean we needed to create a system that puts millions of children through frightening investigations every year, and casts thousands of them into a chaotic system of foster care, traumatizing some of them for life. 

Yet that’s what we’ve done. Some of the same people who probably are horrified by Donald Trump seem to have no problem using his tactics in the fight against child abuse.

Case in point: Suppose someone tried to set up a role-playing exercise concerning international relations. But every Muslim character was a terrorist and they all said things like “death to America” and “kill the infidels.”  The furor at this blatant bigotry would be enormous.

Yet a column in the Chronicle of Social Change recently sang the praises of a role-playing exercise about foster care in an article that begins with the script for those taking the role of birth parent:

The birth parent leans in and whispers horrific things to her child.“I don’t want you.”“I can’t protect you.”“Don’t tell anyone our family secret.”

Everyone playing a birth parent is instructed to “choose an addiction” – since, of course, every parent who loses a child to foster care must be an addict. 

In fact, the problem of drug abuse, like the problem of child abuse, is serious and real. But both also have been subjected to enormous hype, and inflated figures.

Where in this role-playing exercise are the birth parents who lost their children because their poverty was confused with neglect? Where are the mothers who were beaten by their husbands and then had their children taken away because they “allowed” the children to “witness domestic violence”?   And where are the ones who lost their children because of a false positive drug test, or whose “drug problem” consists of smoking marijuana?

This same role-playing exercise features only “enlightened foster parents.”  There are many of these.  But since multiple studies have found abuse in one-quarter to one-third of foster homes, they can’t all be enlightened.

And where are the caseworkers who immediately jump to conclusions about families because they are poor, and especially if they are poor and African-American?  has shown that to be a common problem.

Yet this exercise in stigma and stereotyping not only isn’t condemned, it is honored. The guy who came up with it, David White, won and “Angels in Adoption” award.

Donald Trump would be proud.

Or suppose Donald Trump were asked which states were doing the best job at solving a social problem. Suppose he replied that it’s complicated, “but I will tell you the states that do the best overall are the ones that have smaller, whiter populations” [emphasis added].

Even Trump never actually said that - but Michael Petit did, when asked which states are best at preventing child abuse. He’s the founder of the group that calls itself Every Child Matters, and he said it at a Congressional hearing. 

And then there is this, from a former social worker for the Washington, D.C. child welfare agency. She laments the fact that a judge would not let foster parents adopt a child, and instead awarded custody to

The 19-year-old father, jobless and a high school dropout. … He had not abused or neglected Davon. Nevertheless, it was clear that Davon would do better with his foster parents. 

In other words, why do we need actual maltreatment to take away a child forever? And why help a birth father with employment and child-rearing?  Let’s have a society in which mostly white, middle-class caseworkers descend upon impoverished communities and take black children from parents because they would be “better off” elsewhere! 

Perhaps she should send the idea to the Trump campaign. I’m sure they’d love it.

None of this is new. In the 19th Century, Protestant Minister Charles Loring Brace snatched away the children of poor Catholic immigrants whose parents he deemed genetically inferior and threw them onto “orphan trains” even though many were not orphans.  Brace knew how to whip up a crowd with scare stories. 

Other child savers, as they proudly called themselves, hid their agenda of fear and loathing of the immigrant poor – and their efforts to confiscate their children -- behind horror stories of brutally beaten children, complete with “before” and “after” pictures for the media.

They, and their latter-day counterparts, could be Donald Trump’s role models.

If there is a difference between Donald Trump and today’s child savers it is this: The child savers mean well.  They want to help children and they really believe their “solutions” will work. 

But Greenfield wrote something else in his Politico column on the politics of fear:

The dilemma, of course, is that in every one of these examples, the lunge toward useless, or foolish, or dangerous, or deplorable responses seems almost built into the political system.

In child welfare, we have a system that subjects millions to needless investigations, traumatizes thousands with needless foster care – and still overlooks children in real danger.

Useless, foolish, dangerous and deplorable seems like a pretty good description of that system. If we’re ever going to change that, America’s latter-day child savers need to stop playing the Trump card.

More about the impact of Trump-style paranoia, and the implications for child welfare, in this post. 

Thursday, December 17, 2015

Child welfare in Arkansas: Asa Hutchinson and the faith-BIASED orphanage

Second of three parts

The previous post to this blog described how Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson commissioned a good report about the failings of child welfare in Arkansas – and then proceeded to ignore one of its most important recommendations.  The report, issued in July, found that Arkansas could go a long way toward ending a “shortage” of placements if it would just end the bias against kinship care – foster care provided by grandparents and other relatives.  Indeed, Arkansas makes far less use of this option than neighboring states.

In contrast, Arkansas badly overuses the worst form of care – group homes and institutions, in other words, latter-day orphanages.  The child welfare euphemism is “congregate care.” As the report notes:  “There is considerable evidence that children do better in family-based settings than congregate settings.”

That is an understatement.  It takes three single-spaced pages just to list the citations for some of the studies showing the harm of congregate care.  In addition, no matter how well-meaning the founders may be, orphanages have an unnerving tendency to go bad.  Orphanages are institutions for the poor, and institutions for the poor almost always are poor institutions.

None of the standard excuses for these places stands up to scrutiny.  They do not make children’s lives more stable, they do not help siblings, and often, they doom children to languish in substitute care.

Vincent’s report goes on to suggest that Arkansas adopt a series of guiding principles for its child welfare system including:

Placements should be made in the least restrictive, most normalized setting responsive to the child’s needs. Children should not be placed in congregate settings unless that environment is the only setting in which needed services can be provided [emphasis in original].

Five months later, the governor issued a statement touting “progress” in fixing foster care.  The statement said not a word about increasing kinship care.  Instead it touted the opening of new orphanages.  He even released the statement at a dedication ceremony for one of them, a place called Maggie House.

One thing you can say about Maggie House – it doesn’t try to hide its true nature.

Most of the time, modern orphanages try to do just that.  “How can you call us an institution?” the people who run them say.  “We have ‘cottages’ and beautiful grounds.  
  
But no matter what it may look like, a building that houses large numbers of children, most of them strangers to each other, to be cared for by paid staff hired to dispense indiscriminate pseudo-love to whoever walks in the door – staff that, at best, are  likely to change every year or two - is not a home. It's a dormitory. And a collection of dormitories is an orphanage.

Children are not fooled by pretty grounds and immaculate “cottages.” They know the difference between “homelike” and home. An orphanage is an orphanage is an orphanage. The new ones just come complete with Potemkin Village façades.

At Maggie House, it looks like they’ve pretty well dispensed with the façade.  It’s one building, a former nursing home.  The “cottages” are just different parts of the same building.  Have a look around.  Why place children with grandma when they can be at a place like this, right?

Also, although Maggie House is run by a group calling itself Free Will Baptist Ministries, exercising free will may be difficult for those residents whose religious beliefs don’t precisely match those of the people who run the place.  On their website, before they say almost anything else, the people running Maggie House say this: 
At Family Ministries’ Maggie House, we strive to create a Christian family atmosphere. In addition, we will teach the Word of God as the rule of life. Every child is given the opportunity to accept Christ as their personal Savior. Given the circumstances of many of these children, it is of upmost importance that we share the love of Christ with them. We find that most of them have never been taken to church, owned their own Bible, or had the opportunity to learn about Christ.  
That sounds more faith biased than faith-based.

One can only imagine how the governor would respond if a local mosque decided to build an orphanage for foster children because “we find that most of them have never been taken to a mosque, owned their own Quran, or had the opportunity to learn about Allah.” 

What happens to an LGBT youth placed at Maggie House? 

What about a teenager who wants access to contraception?

But the most important question remains: Why does Arkansas keep opening new institutions of any kind to warehouse children, instead of concentrating on keeping children out of the system and, when children must be taken, placing more of them with  relatives?

In part three: How the Arkansas Legislature made things worse

Wednesday, December 16, 2015

Child welfare and terrorism: Lessons from the paranoia in Los Angeles


                                                                                     Photo by John Picken
Over at the Chronicle of Social Change, I have a blog post called “Donald Trump and the Child Savers: Not a Band But They Sing the Same Song.”  It’s about how people in child welfare, many of whom abhor Trump, use his tactics to whip up hysteria over child abuse and scare us into supporting policies that lead to the widespread, needless removal of children from their homes.  This does terrible harm to the children needlessly taken.  It also steals time and resources from finding children in real danger.

Anyone who lives in a poor neighborhood knows this, of course.  The threat that Child Protective Services (CPS) will confuse family poverty with neglect is a constant, nagging fear.  It dates all the way back to the 19th Century when Societies for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children – who disguised an agenda of hatred and fear for the immigrant poor with lofty rhetoric about saving the children – were known in poor neighborhoods simply as “The Cruelty.”

Yesterday, the rest of America got a small taste of how much disruption can be caused when we give in to the Trump-style paranoia that has long dominated the child welfare system.  It happened in Los Angeles, when one crude hoax email led to the shutdown of the entire Los Angeles Unified School District – the nation’s second largest.  The only system that’s bigger, the one in New York City, got a nearly identical email.  They knew a hoax when they saw one, and decided not to overreact.

By the time Los Angeles officials made their decision, many students were on their way to school, or already there.  According to The New York Times:

The decision [In Los Angeles] threw the lives of millions of people — students, parents, teachers — into disarray and sent a wave of concern across an already tense region. “If they sent an alert, I never received it,” said Christine Clarke, who showed up at Hollywood High School looking frantically for her son after hearing the news on the radio. Parents scrambled for last-minute day care or called in sick at work, …

And that may be the least of it.  Police inspected more than 1,500 school sites before the search finally was called off.  How much real crime was missed while all those police officers were chasing down a hoax?

It could have been even worse.  How many very young children could have been left unsupervised, or gotten lost, in the chaos as parents tried to change plans and find them?  In short, the response to the hoax caused more danger to the children than the hoax.

The mentality on display in Los Angeles is the mentality that pervades child welfare.  It’s why caseworkers barge into the lives of more than three million children every year, sometimes based on little more than an anonymous call to a child protective hotline – and 80 percent of the reports are false.  As caseworkers spin their wheels on false reports and trivial cases, children in real danger are overlooked.

The mentality of those defending the response in Los Angeles is strikingly like the mentality that dominates child welfare.  Again from the Times:

[Rep. Brad] Sherman said elements of the message did not appear credible, including the number of potential attackers and the claim that they had access to nerve gas. ([New York City Police Commissioner William] Bratton … suggested that the writer might have been inspired by recent episodes of “Homeland,” with its plotline of a sarin gas attack on Berlin.) The message was signed by a male Arabic-appearing name, Mr. Sherman said, but added: “The word ‘Allah’ appears several times in the email, but once it’s not capitalized. A devout Muslim or an extremist Muslim would probably be more careful about typing the world Allah.”
But then Sherman says:
The author appeared knowledgeable about the structure of the Los Angeles Unified School District, referring to the system by its full name, which added to the concern, Mr. Sherman said. “Just because parts of the email are false doesn’t mean it’s all false,” he said [emphasis added].
Classic.  I’m reminded of the CPS caseworker who told me that even if someone is harassing a family with false reports, workers should keep right on going out and investigating the family time after time after time because of “the cry wolf example.”
There’s still another parallel.  Some have said, in effect, of course New York and Los Angeles responded differently – L.A. is near San Bernardino.  (Whereas New York, of course, has had no experience with terrorism.)
In child welfare, agencies are more likely to take the child and run if a high profile child abuse death is in theheadlines.
Or maybe it’s partly cultural.  Even when rates of child poverty are factored in, Los Angeles County takes away children at more than double the rate of New York City.  There is no evidence that Los Angeles children are twice as safe as their New York City counterparts.
There is one difference though.  When CPS agencies behave this way the stakes are a lot higher.  A child abuse investigation is not a benign act.  Having a stranger come to the door – or your school – pull you aside and ask questions about the most intimate aspects of your life can be an enormously traumatic experience for a child; and the younger the child the greater the trauma.  It can leave lifelong emotional scars.
Even worse, when the allegation is physical abuse – and, sometimes, even when it’s not - the investigation often is accompanied by a stripsearch by a caseworker or a doctor looking for bruises.  If anyone else did that it would be sexual abuse.  And if the allegation is sexual abuse, the medical exam can be a lot more traumatic.
      
Indeed, try to imagine the terror for a young child, suddenly taken from family by strangers, often including police.  She goes to a strange hospital, where doctors and nurses she’s never met before perform the most intimate possible examination.

All this is before we even reach the harm of panicky caseworkers using flimsy allegations to throw children needlessly into foster care.

Some will read this and say: But what if there really had been a terrorist attack and the school officials had ignored the warning?

Well, everyone involved would have been fired, we know that.  In contrast, no one will be held accountable for the chaos caused by the overreaction – once again, the parallel to child welfare is perfect.

But we also should know this: Life comes with risk.  Every time we get into a car we run the risk that a drunk driver is heading toward us in the next lane.  Every time we go for a swim we risk drowning.  But trying to take every last bit of risk out of our lives not only debilitates our psyches – it also, paradoxically, puts us all at more risk.