Showing posts with label Steve Duin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Steve Duin. Show all posts

Saturday, January 2, 2016

Child welfare in Oregon: A columnist's self-indulgent rage isn't helping

I’ve previously noted that one of the easiest ways for a newspaper columnist to fill space is to write the "boy-if-there's-one-thing-in-the-world-that-I-really-really-hate-more-than-anything-it's-child abuse-and-all-the-people-who-let-this-child-die-must-be-lazy-or-idiots” column. 

Former home of The Oregonian
No actual reporting is required. If anyone disagrees with anything in the column then at best they just don’t care; at worst they’re in favor of child abuse.  Aside from filling space, these columns accomplish nothing except to encourage a rush to take away more children.  That’s dangerous in any state, but especially in one like Oregon, which takes away children at a rate well above the national average.

I’ve noted before that a master of this genre is Steve Duin at the Oregonian in Portland – which is too bad, since he’s also capable of much better work.

Duin was at it again on December 22.  This time he seemed intent less on calling attention to child abuse than on distracting readers from where a lot of that abuse has been turning up lately in Oregon – foster care.

He begins this way: 
Oleander Labier weighed 28 pounds when, at the age of 5, her torture finally ended. And while Oleander doesn't rank high in terms of blood money, those millions the state of Oregon has paid out in settlements in cases involving the Department of Human Services, hers is the story of neglect and suffering that still speaks to me. 
It should speak to anyone.  But so should the case that actually prompted the huge payout Duin is talking about.  Here’s what that case involved, according to the Salem Statesman-Journal: 
James Earl Mooney, a former Salem resident, pleaded guilty in 2012 to five counts of first-degree sodomy of medically fragile children, ages 48 hours to 3 years, who had disabilities or other special needs. Mooney was sentenced to 50 years in the Eastern Oregon Correctional Institution for crimes that included sodomizing an 18-month-old foster baby in her car seat while his wife attended a doctor's appointment with another foster child. 
Doesn’t that at least whisper to you, Mr. Duin?

Similarly, the scandal involving the foster-care agency Give Us This Day gets barely a mention and no graphic details. (At least Duin gives credit where it’s due - to Willamette Week reporter Nigel Jaquiss - for breaking the story.)

UPDATE, JAN 4, 2016: And just last week, two Oregon newspapers reported on two more examples of foster care failure, this time in "residential treatment."

On one level, the minimal attention to abuse in foster care is understandable.  Talking a lot about it would make the segue to the Only Public Official Who Really Cares part of the column a bit awkward – I’ll get to that in a moment.  But first, there’s the Ritual Condemnation Of The Rest of Us: 
… [R]efusal to take ownership of a tragedy sums up this state's attitude toward the abuse and death of children under our care. Our attitude. Yours and mine. 
I think he really just means yours, Oregon.  He proves how much he cares by writing columns scolding everyone else: 
In not giving a damn, the governor, the Legislature, the attorney general and the Department of Human Services simply follow our lead. 
As I said, Oregon, I think he means your lead.  As for not giving a damn, I’ve previously noted Duin’s belief in his own extraordinary power to read minds.  Once again, he can detect that almost everyone who works for the state human services agency, the Attorney General and every state legislator (except one – we’ll get back to that) doesn’t care.

By the time he says, much farther down that he knows there are  “people who bring extraordinary commitment to their jobs in child welfare …” he sounds like Donald Trump saying that some of the Mexicans crossing the border actually “I assume, are good people.” 

Oregon State Sen. Sara Gelser
But there is one hero in this story (besides the columnist himself).  He writes: 
In recent months, a legislative committee chaired by Sen. Sara Gelser, D-Corvallis, has called the state's foster care agency on the Capitol carpet. … Gelser has a sustained interest in child-welfare issues. Her family has frequently asked her to give it a rest over Sunday dinner. … "I have not seen engagement on this issue in a meaningful way from our prior two governors," Gelser notes. Until Gov. Kate Brown deeded control of the agency to Clyde Saiki last month, nor has [sic]  Gelser seen anyone at the controls of Human Services prioritize child safety. 
I don’t doubt Sen. Gelser’s commitment or her dedication.  But her agenda suggests she has made the common mistake of confusing child removal with child safety.  Again from the column: 
At the very least, Gelser argues, the agency needs a far better screening process for the initial complaints of child abuse and neglect. "We close far more reports at screening – 60 percent – than any state in the country," Gelser says. "There's no investigation. You call the child-welfare line, and nothing happens. And the majority of calls about foster care are closed." 
That’s probably not exactly what Gelser said.  She said Oregon screened out calls at among the highest rates in the country.  (I know this because when I emailed her, at about 2:15pm her time on the day before Christmas, she immediately responded, personally, with the source for her information and what she had tweeted at the time.  As I said, I don’t doubt the part about dedication.)

But looking only at the rate at which calls to a state’s child protection hotline are screened in or screened out can be misleading.

Oregon does screen out calls at a rate well above the national average – though it’s 56.6 percent, not 60 percent.  But Oregonians also are far more likely to call the hotline in the first place (which is pretty remarkable for a state which, according to Duin, is filled with people who don’t give a damn).  Nationwide hotlines get about 47 calls for every thousand children.  In Oregon it’s more than 76.  

It’s possible this is because Oregon is a cesspool of depravity with vastly more child abuse than the nation as a whole.  More likely, however, people in Oregon just happen to be more prone to heed the constant messages to “report” anything and everything, no matter how absurd the suspicion may be.  With that many more people, proportionately, calling in, it makes perfect sense that a larger proportion of cases won’t meet even the minimal standards needed to be accepted for investigation.

In addition, Oregon “substantiates” cases at a rate 35 percent above the national average.  But that’s still only 23 percent of the cases – which means workers are wasting more than three-quarters of their time spinning their wheels – because the screening isn’t strict enough.

So, to review:

● Oregonians phone in reports of child abuse at a rate above the national average.
● Calls are accepted for investigation at a rate below the national average.
● Investigations are substantiated at a rate above the national average.
● Children are removed from their homes at a rate above the national average.

But Sen. Gelser expresses concern only about the figure for screening.

In fairness, Gelser also notes with concern that a majority of reports alleging abuse in foster care are closed at screening.  In fact, that also makes sense. Though multiple studies, including at least one specific to Oregon, have found abuse in one-quarter to one-third of foster homes, that’s still not a majority.

What does not make sense, however, is the fact that allegations of abuse in foster care are screened out at a significantly higher rate  - more than 66 percent – than allegations of abuse in general.  This is still another indication of where the real bias lies in Oregon.

Duin pays more attention to another of Gelser’s concerns: 
Gelser also notes that the majority of reports from the children's Court Appointed Special Advocates – are also dismissed at screening: "That makes no sense to me." 
Actually, it makes perfect sense.  CASA volunteers mean well, but the evidence is overwhelming that the racial and class bias that permeates child welfare is virtually built in to the CASA model.  That may well prompt CASAs to report cases where no maltreatment has taken place.


None of this means the Oregon hotline is working well.  Odds are, like every other part of almost every other child welfare system, it is arbitrary, capricious and cruel, with some cases wrongly screened out — and others wrongly screened in.  In at least three other states, when hotline operators were given identical hypothetical cases, there was no consistency in whether the cases were screened in or out.  So a truly objective investigation would be worthwhile.

But the whole screening debate needs to be seen in the context of that other disturbing statistic:

Oregon tears children from their families at anywhere from 15 to 34 percent above the national average – and it’s been doing that for decades.  Surely, if take-the-child-and-run were the answer, Oregon would have much safer children by now.

Instead, of course, all that needless removal overloads the system, creating an artificial “shortage” of placements.  So the state looks the other way at abuse in foster care.  And now, it seems, Steve Duin wants us to look away from that part of the picture, too.

Monday, March 1, 2010

When big bureaucracies fail – in foster care and in journalism

There was one warning sign after another, yet nothing was done. Lower level people reported to higher ups, but either they were ignored or the information "fell through the cracks." In some cases, they were afraid to bring up their concerns – until the whole thing blew up in everybody's face.

A child welfare agency ignoring warning signs about an endangered child? No. Our intelligence community, failing to connect the dots in the case of the attempt to bomb a plane on Christmas Day? No. I'm thinking of another great big bureaucracy: The New York
Times, and how it allowed serial fabricator Jayson Blair to get away with making stuff up for such a long time.

The similarities are eerie. Don't think so? Just compare any in-depth account of how a child welfare agency's screw-ups contributed to the death of a child known-to-the-system to this story: The Times' own account of how Jayson Blair's fabrications "fell through the cracks."

Top editors at the Times came in for plenty of criticism and two of them, including Executive Editor Howell Raines, lost their jobs. But no journalist ever said those editors "didn't give a damn." No journalist said they didn't care. No journalist said they were "automatons," all of which are among the characterizations Portland Oregonian columnist Steve Duin used to characterize some Oregon child welfare workers he does not know and never met, after a child was starved and tortured to death on their watch, despite repeated warnings. (I don't mean to pick on Duin, who has done some very good work; his column is just the most recent example of this genre.)

No, those are characterizations reporters tend to save for other lines of work – at least publicly. And while Duin might be right about these workers, when throwing around those kinds of insults, "might" isn't good enough. (Going to the other extreme and finding some worker to canonize, what I've come to call the National Model Worker story, doesn't help either.)

Some might argue that the Times is different because, after the Blair fiasco, it fired people and it learned from its mistakes. But child welfare agencies also fire agency chiefs after high-profile fatalities; quite often, in fact. And it's not clear how much the Times has learned.

Consider the case of Alessandra Stanley, a reporter whose job is to write sneering columns filled with maximum condescension about television. Since many print journalists hate television, especially television news, they tend to love stuff like this. That explains why the Times' "public editor" (a job created in response to the Blair case) could describe Stanley as "… much admired by editors for the intellectual heft of her coverage of television."

It also made her editors remarkably forgiving of mistakes. Stanley's reign of error became a public issue when the Times had to run a correction setting the record straight on seven separate mistakes in just one story, an assessment of the life of Walter Cronkite. It was published shortly after he died – but written well beforehand. (Stanley said she'd meant to go back and check the facts before it was published.)

As to how the story fell through the cracks, according to the public editor: "even a newspaper like the Times, with layers of editing to ensure accuracy, can go off the rails when communication is poor, individuals do not bear down hard enough, and they make assumptions about what others have done." Sure sounds like a child welfare agency to me.

But there's more. When the public editor looked into Stanley's record, he found she made so many mistakes that, at one point, she was assigned a personal copy editor to keep her blunders from getting into print. Stanley's work improved, the arrangement ended and, it is claimed, things went fine until the Cronkite story.

But just imagine, for a moment, what any columnist or editorial writer would say if it were revealed that the CPS worker involved in some tragedy had a record that was so bad she'd been assigned a personal supervisor whose specific job was to keep her from screwing up.

None of this excuses the very serious and very real failings of child welfare agencies – failings that go in all directions. But it does suggest that before assuming a posture of sneer and swagger toward frontline workers, those who write about these systems might want to do a little more reporting, and dispense with some of the, uh, "intellectual heft."

Monday, February 22, 2010

Fostering foster care panic in Oregon

The column in the Portland Oregonian last Jan. 5 certainly wasn't the worst of its kind I've ever seen – not by a long shot. But the column, just about the easiest in the world to write, was more disappointing than some of the others because the columnist, Steve Duin, usually does better work. It was the usual "boy-if-there's-one-thing-in-the world-that-I-hate-more-than-anything-it's-child abuse-and-all-the-people-who-let-this-child-die-must-be-lazy-or-idiots column. Such general venting of rage requires no actual reporting. Duin didn't even call the Juvenile Rights Project, the group that knows these issues better than any other in Oregon, and a group he's praised in a column a few years ago. Worst of all, this general venting of rage can only encourage a foster care panic and make an already bad system even worse.

Duin was responding to an Oregonian story about the death of 15-year-old Jeanette Maples. Allegedly starved and tortured over a period of years, here's what the girl's step grandmother told the newspaper she found after her death:

She found food padlocked in kitchen cupboards and a blood-spattered bedroom. … Investigators urged her not to view her step granddaughter's body. "They all told me that I did not want to see this body because it was the most horrific thing they'd ever seen."

There were plenty of warnings that Jeanette was in danger – it was one of those cases with more "red flags" than a Soviet May Day parade.

On Jan. 5, Duin weighed in. There was no new information, no new reporting. Just: Boy am I furious and here's who I'm mad at.

GOOD REASON FOR RAGE, BUT IT'S STILL NOT HELPING

There is plenty of good reason for that fury. But that makes it no less self-indulgent, and no more likely to fix the Oregon child welfare system.

Part of his fury was directed at the secrecy that shields the Oregon Department of Human Services from scrutiny and accountability in such cases – much as it does with most child welfare agencies. He's right about that. It's why NCCPR has, for years, called for total transparency; not only open court hearings (which they already have in Oregon) but a strong rebuttable presumption that almost all records are open in every case, not just deaths or near deaths. (See our Due Process Agenda for details.) And that includes the names of workers involved in the case at every level.

But the rest of Duin's fury was directed at everyone in DHS who ever went near the case. "No one cared enough to connect the dots…" he declared. They're "automatons" who "can't be trusted to give a damn." He complained that no one will be fired, and quoted with approval a lawyer who has sued DHS who said. "…there needs to be accountability in the rank and file, where people get fired or turned out."

And that pretty much was the theme of the column: Off with their heads!

Duin could be right about the workers in this particular case. Maybe they don't give a damn. Maybe they don't care. Maybe they really are automatons who all deserve to be fired. Or maybe they care but they're incompetent – which is no better. Or maybe they care desperately. Maybe they are passionate about protecting children but were so overwhelmed that they missed even warning signs that, it would seem, were blatantly obvious.

I don't know. And neither does Steve Duin. In effect he's saying: I demand full public accountability – but why wait? I'll jump to my own conclusions now.

And that is enormously dangerous for children – especially in Oregon.

FIRING BLIND

For starters, when you're firing blind, it's easy to hit the wrong target. A couple of years ago, Sam Cook, a columnist for the Fort Myers News Press, was relentless in attacking a caseworker who'd been connected with a case where a child died. He didn't actually know much about the caseworker's role in the case but, hey, the child died, there were warnings, so the caseworker must have been, to use Cook's favorite word, "incompetent."

Later, a very good reporter for the same newspaper found out that this caseworker had an exemplary record, and was someone no CPS agency could afford to lose. But by then it was too late. The caseworker had quit. "The things that have been written about me have not only affected me, but have also affected my family, friends, and co-workers," she said. "I love my job, really I do, but the stress of this was just too much."

There are some differences: Even from what little is known, the case in Florida was not as clear-cut as the one in Oregon. And Steve Duin is more careful and more measured than Sam Cook.

But there are worse consequences.

Oregon already takes away children at one of the highest rates in the nation, a rate 70 percent above the national average – and Oregon has been taking children at obscenely high rates for decades. Now, every caseworker has been reminded once again that they can take hundreds of children needlessly and, while the children will suffer terribly, the caseworker is safe – even if, at some point down the line, a child dies in foster care. But leave one child in her or his own home and have something go wrong and you'll be pilloried as not giving a damn, an automaton and so on.

ONLY DAMNED IF YOU DON'T

And that's just the beginning. Though Duin complains that no one ever gets fired, to the extent that workers are disciplined at all, it's only for leaving children in dangerous homes, never for taking children from safe ones. (Contrary to what caseworkers often claim, when it comes to taking away children they are not damned if they do or damned if they don't – they're only damned if they don't.) In other words, the column is sure to accelerate any foster-care panic already underway in Oregon.

That means even more false allegations, more trivial cases, more children needlessly removed – and even less time to find the children in real danger. So the odds are, there will be even more tragedies like the death of Jeanette Maples. (For more on this, see our Issue Paper on foster care panics.)

Duin could argue that it's not fair for me to complain that he's firing blind when it's DHS that blindfolded him – and everyone else. But Duin didn't limit his shots just to the people who blindfolded him - who may, or may not, be the same people who played a role in the death of Jeanette Maples. He aimed a lot of his fire at the people at the bottom of the heap – frontline caseworkers who often want to defend themselves but are, themselves, gagged by their bosses.

It gets even worse if there happens to be a demagogic politician nearby. No doubt Duin would have loved the way Washington, D.C. Mayor Adrian Fenty responded to the tragic deaths of the children of Banita Jacks. Within days, he'd fired everyone who had come anywhere near the case. (An arbitrator reversed the firings of those who had a right to appeal them.) The Washington Post loved it. They loved it less after the actions collapsed the entire D.C. system and sent removals of children soaring by 41 percent in a year. (Details are on our website here and in these previous posts to this Blog.) An independent court-appointed monitor overseeing a class-action lawsuit settlement found that years of work slowly rebuilding the system has collapsed like a house of cards.

Here, again, there are differences – the facts in the Jacks case are far more ambiguous than in the case of Jeanette Maples (though The Washington Post didn't think so at the time). Nevertheless, foster-care panics are why columns like Duin's – and stories like the story that preceded it, never make child welfare systems better, and sometimes make them worse. And you'd think the Oregonian would have noticed. This cycle has been playing out at that paper since 2004, when the Oregonian first discovered that there is such a thing as a child welfare system in that state. Over and over Oregonian reporters write the same story, only the name of the child is different. Over and over, Oregonian opinion writers vent their anger about it. And, except for an occasional glance, everyone averts their eyes from the elephant in the room – the state's obscenely-high rate of tearing apart families.

FLOGGING THE MULE

Perhaps in another year or so Duin will ask the same question ultimately posed by Sam Cook in Florida, who wrote: "I've flogged the Department of Children and Families like a rented mule. Where has it gotten us?"

Duin also writes that the failings by DHS in this case reminded him of the failure of our national security apparatus in the case of the attempt to bomb a plane on Christmas Day. I thought much the same, in reverse. As all the stories about red flags and miscommunication in connection with the attempted bombing came out, I thought of how much it sounded like what happens in CPS agencies. But the whole thing also reminded me of another big, powerful institution where big failures have been known to fall between the cracks.

That story in a future post to this Blog