It’s at least as likely that what Kentucky really leads in is confusing poverty with neglect.
|Source: U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Services, Child Maltreatment 2018
Kentucky still has highest child abuse rate in U.S….– Sentinel Echo, London KY
The first claim, about how a federal agency “slapped this dubious title” on Kentucky is simply false. Some of the rest might be true. Then again, it might not – and neither the people who wrote the stories nor anyone else has the faintest idea.
In fact, the very report cited in all those stories specifically cautions against such comparisons. So not only did the Department of Health and Human Services not slap any "dubious title" on anyone; Kentucky media have recklessly ignored HHS' warning about making any such comparison.
That makes it easy for readers to jump to the mistaken conclusion that Kentucky is such a cesspool of depravity that the state is justified in tearing apart families a rate 70 percent above the national average even when rates of child poverty are factored in.*
And if they don’t jump to that conclusion on their own, the Courier-Journal is glad to help. Here’s how one news story summed it all up:
The Courier Journal reported last year that Kentucky led the nation in abuse and neglect with increasingly violent, sometimes fatal injuries to children so severe an outside panel classified some cases as torture.
|Full details and sources are available here.
So it’s no wonder anyone reading the stories would be likely to conclude that the rate at which Kentucky tears apart families should be even higher. And it’s no wonder neither readers nor the authors of such stories would want to listen to concerns about the enormous emotional trauma and terrible life outcomes often inflicted on children needlessly consigned to the chaos of foster care, and the high risk of abuse in foster care itself. (When the Courier-Journal touches on these outcomes the premise is that foster care can be “even worse” than those awful birth parents, and it’s a shame more kids aren’t adopted.)
Kentucky’s take-the-child-and-run approach is one of the reasons the child welfare system is overwhelmed. It is that overwhelming of the system with false reports, trivial cases and cases in which family poverty is confused with neglect that almost always is the real reason children in real danger of brutality, torture and death - cases that are as rare as they are horrific -- sometimes are overlooked.
That’s because though each is the worst form of tragedy child abuse deaths and near deaths are needles in a very large haystack.
In 2017, using the larger of two different figures in Courier-Journal stories, we estimate there were between 29 and 58 child abuse deaths or near deaths in Kentucky. (The graphic above assumes 58.) That year, Kentucky’s child abuse hotline received calls involving roughly 165,000 children.** Clearly, making the haystack even larger by overloading workers with even more false reports, trivial cases, poverty cases and needless foster care, is only going to make it even harder to find the needles.
All this is why the misreading of
key data by Kentucky media and advocates makes all Kentucky children less safe.
Actually we DO need to “quibble about
Before I even
start the process of analyzing the claim about child abuse in Kentucky, I need
to repeat something I wrote recently about child abuse in Oregon when a data
issue arose there:
When those pushing for more policing of
overwhelmingly poor, disproportionately nonwhite families, more massive
surveillance and more removal of children to foster care get caught hyping the
numbers, they have a standard response. Usually it’s some variation of: “How
dare you quibble about numbers! Children are dying! Even one case is
The second two sentences are, of course, correct. But precisely because we’ve been suckered by fearmongering, hype and hysteria for decades (at least one organization responsible for it effectively admitted as much we’ve spent those decades embracing “solutions” that only make things worse.
As I noted above, the horror stories represent
a tiny fraction of the cases seen by workers for Kentucky’s Cabinet for Health
and Family Services. To get that tiny
fraction down to zero requires a vastly different approach than an
ever-expanding child welfare surveillance state, and doing what Kentucky keeps
doing - tearing apart families, and traumatizing children with needless foster
care, at an obscene rate.
hyper-defensive response from some journalists to any attempt to provide
context is some variation of: “Oh, so you don’t want us to report on children dying!”
Bullshit. What those of us who have been working
for decades to reduce child abuse in all forms to zero want is better reporting on child abuse deaths –
and every other aspect of the child welfare system (Why, for example, has the Courier-Journal never, as far as I know,
run a story such as this such as this?)
because the problem of massive, needless removal of children and the problem of
child welfare systems overlooking children in real danger are directly related.
well do need to “quibble about numbers.” So let’s start
The table that launched those hype-filled headlines
Where does that “worst-in-the-nation”
claim come from? Well, contrary to what
the editor of the Courier Journal
implied, it does not come from any statement from the federal Department of
Health and Human Services. There is no press release or other document that
declares “Kentucky is number one in child abuse.” There isn’t even a ranking.
[R]eaders should exercise caution in making state-to-state comparisons. Each state defines child abuse and neglect in its own statutes and policies and the child welfare agencies determine the appropriate response for the alleged maltreatment based on those statutes and policies.
What that table actually measures is the percentage of the child population for whom child protective services workers check a box on a form saying they think it’s at least slightly more likely than not that a parent or caretaker abused or neglected a child. This can be little more than a caseworker’s guess. In Kentucky workers check the box for a higher proportion of the total child population than any other state.
Now, let’s unpack this.
For starters, all those stories that claim even the data table said Kentucky leads America in “child abuse” are false – the figure is for alleged abuse and alleged neglect combined.
And there are indications that, in Kentucky, we are talking almost entirely about so-called “neglect.” Another table in the same publication, on page 41, shows that, on average 60.8 percent of so-called substantiated reports are for “neglect only.” But in Kentucky it’s 88.1 percent – the second highest such proportion in America. In contrast, physical abuse and sexual abuse combined account for, at most 11.2 percent. That compares to a national average of 32 percent.
Of course some in Kentucky might say: Well, of course we have a higher proportion of neglect cases, we’re a poor state! There are two problems with this: First, child welfare agencies say they never confuse poverty with neglect – so that should be largely irrelevant. Second, there are seven states where the rate of child poverty is as high or higher than Kentucky. In all of those states, the percentage of cases involving alleged neglect is lower than Kentucky.
Perhaps most notable among these is Alabama, a state which became, relatively speaking, a national leader in child welfare when a lawsuit settlement required the state to rebuild its system to emphasize safe, proven alternatives to tearing apart families. (A member of NCCPR’s volunteer Board of Directors was co-counsel for plaintiffs in that lawsuit.) So it's worth repeating the graphic at the top of this post:
|Source: U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Services, Child Maltreatment 2018
There’s been some backsliding in recent
years, but Alabama still takes away children at half the rate of Kentucky – and
independent monitors found that child safety improved. Alabama did this in part by dramatically
reducing the confusion of poverty with neglect.
In Alabama of all “substantiated” cases only 31.3 percent involved
That leaves the Courier-Journal, which, for all its other failings, at least says
the figure is for “abuse and neglect.”
“Does not provide the child with adequate care, supervision, food, clothing, shelter, education, or medical care necessary for the child's well-being.”
There is hardly a poor child in Kentucky who could not be deemed neglected at some point if a caseworker chose to do so. That alone may well explain the so-called “worst in the nation” claim.
But it’s not just the vagueness of the definition. Different state and local child welfare agencies have different cultures. As noted above in the discussion of Alabama, there are a few agencies that take seriously trying to avoid confusing poverty with neglect. But Kentucky does not appear to be one of them.
On the contrary, Kentucky child
welfare’s contempt for families was the subject of a scathing
report by the child welfare agency’s own inspector general in 2007.
At about the same time the state made national
headlines over rushing children needlessly to termination of parental
court decisions suggest attitudes
haven’t changed. The Lexington Herald-Leader has covered all
this extensively – it is they only news organization in the state I know of
that has offered a measure of nuance in its child welfare coverage.
We do know that, as of 2017, in Kentucky, in the cases where families manage to make their way through an appeals process, with the appeal decided by the same agency that made the initial determination, well over half the time the decision to “substantiate” the allegation is overturned.
*- Normally, when I use that “cesspool of depravity” phrase I’m being sarcastic, but in Kentucky, one of the Courier Journal’s favorite sources for fearmongering quotes – a child abuse pediatrician – actually said "I think Kentucky continues in some areas to have a fairly significant culture of violence." In fact, this is someone who, however well-intended, has no qualifications I know of to measure the culture of an entire state. Rather, her job requires her to focus almost entirely on the worst of the worst – which may distort her perspective. Problems with the perspective of some child abuse pediatricians, have been well documented in The Atlantic and The Marshall Project, and by NBC News and the Houston Chronicle .
** Courier Journal stories give two different figures (from different state agencies) for child abuse deaths and one for near deaths. Using the larger figures, the total is 107. Nationwide, 27.3 percent of child abuse deaths involve children in some way “known to the system” – which can mean no more than that at one time there was a call to the child abuse hotline. That would mean there were 29 such deaths or near deaths in Kentucky. But just for the sake of argument, I’ve doubled the number in the graphic.
State data in the annual Child Maltreatment reports count the number of calls hotlines receive, but not the number of children per call. Other data in the report suggest that calls to Kentucky’s hotline probably involve an average of 1.5 children per call.