Two cases involving Michigan’s child welfare system have been in the news lately. So far, Michigan lawmakers are ignoring one and learning the wrong lessons from the other.
Read the full commentary in Bridge Michigan.
News and commentary from the National Coalition for Child Protection Reform concerning child abuse, child welfare, foster care, and family preservation.
Two cases involving Michigan’s child welfare system have been in the news lately. So far, Michigan lawmakers are ignoring one and learning the wrong lessons from the other.
Read the full commentary in Bridge Michigan.
Amid all the concern over children in the child welfare and juvenile justice systems forced to endure makeshift placements — some even shipped more than a thousand miles away — Michigan has lost sight of the real causes of the problem. As a result, everyone from the state’s probate judges to the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services pursue solutions that will make things worse.
At the root of the placement crisis is the fact that
Michigan tears apart so many families needlessly. The typical cases seen by
DHHS caseworkers are nothing like the horror stories. Far more common are cases
in which poverty is confused with neglect. In Michigan, 17 percent of children
were thrown into foster care because their parents lacked adequate housing —
that’s more than were taken because of physical abuse. …
The impulse is understandable. For generations, we’ve read horror stories about parents beating, raping and murdering their children. The stories often are followed with statistics leaving the impression that there’s a child abuser under every bed. No wonder people would assume that a decline in child abuse reports due to COVID-19 is cause for alarm.
But the claim is built on a foundation of myth. Accepting it risks scaring vulnerable families away from seeking assistance, it risks deluging caseworkers with false reports, stealing time from finding children in real danger. It even risks increasing the spread of COVID-19.