Sunday, October 11, 2026

“When you’re in foster care, your brain is perpetually on fire.”

How often is institutionalizing children, and the foster-care system in general, not the cure for children’s “behavioral problems” – but rather the cause?

 

On this podcast, Ella Bat-Ami and Lily Colby speak truth to family police power.

It’s become almost a mantra in news stories. Some lobbyist for institutionalizing children or some family police agency leader looking for excuses stops blaming the parents just long enough to blame the children.

It’s their mental health issues, they say; it’s their severe behavioral problems, they say, which are soooo much worse than they used to be. So they “blow out” of foster homes and simply must be institutionalized. 

In fact, such people have been making exactly these claims for decades. I heard it when I began reporting on child welfare as a journalist 50 years ago. When I was researching my book on the topic, the earliest example of this claim I could find dated back to 1948. And given the enormous turnover in “child welfare,” I wonder how in the world all those people saying the kids have gotten worse have any idea what the kids were like in the good old days? 

But hey, slap a label onto a kid, throw in a reference to COVID, and voila! Too many reporters all over the country buy into it all, and write stories parroting this party line without question. 

As with almost every other claim from the foster care-industrial complex, there’s a molehill of truth under the mountain of hype. Some mental health problems almost certainly were exacerbated by COVID. But even when there really are serious behavioral issues, there are vastly better alternatives to group homes and institutions. 

And that still begs the question: What’s causing those so-called behavioral problems and mental health issues? 

Perhaps if some of these reporters and others would take a few moments to listen to Ella Bat-Ami, they might ask themselves: How often is institutionalizing children, and the foster-care system in general, not the cure for children’s “behavioral problems” – but rather the cause? 

Bat-Ami was a guest on this season’s first episode of a podcast aptly named The F Word. The episode also featured Lily Colby, another former foster youth who is founder of the National Network for Fostering Sibling Connections, an organization devoted to another quiet crisis, the forced separation of foster youth from their siblings, often for mind-bogglingly stupid bureaucratic reasons. 

Ella Bat-Ami spent nearly two years in the Tennessee foster care system before aging out at 18. During the podcast, she described the level of toxic stress that is inherent in the status of foster child – regardless of whether a given placement is good or bad: 

When you're in foster care, your brain is just perpetually on fire. You don't know if you're going to be in the same place the next week. You don't know if you're going to have to say goodbye to all your friends. You don't know if you're going to be given a trash bag and 10 minutes to pack your stuff. That's just the reality. 

What I think people need to understand and remember is that we are still children. Regardless of our age, we are still children. … We forget the kids part. And you have to understand that kids make mistakes. Kids make age-appropriate mistakes, and we are told from the beginning that those mistakes will cost us our home. Instead of getting grounded, we'll lose our home. 

And so we are just operating in fight or flight. That's what it is. And even when we trust somebody while we're in the system … we're always going to be defensive. It's going to be perceived as acting out, but you have to understand that what we are experiencing is not normal; it is not natural, and our brains - especially a developing brain - were not built for the level of stress that we endure in foster care. 

Being moved from placement to placement also meant constantly having to adapt to new rules, like getting in trouble for saying “yes,” instead of “yes, ma’am.” As Bat-Ami put it: 

As a foster kid, you feel like an invasive species in your own home. 

And that’s best case. That assumes no actual abuse or neglect in foster care itself – though such abuse occurs in at least one-quarter to one-third of placements. It also assumes a home, and not some kind of institution, like the makeshift night-to-night placement where, Bat-Ami explains:

 The water [was not] potable, so there's lead in the pipes. You are able to shower maybe once a week. There's barbed wire around it so you can't get out, and it's just a bunch of kids in a room. … it's one big room, and so we have cribs on the wall, … and then the big kids sleeping on the floor. 

You don’t suppose all that might lead to “behavioral problems,” do you? 

But the response from Margie Quin, the commissioner of the state family police agency, the Department of Children’s Services, was to attack the kids at a legislative hearing – and support legislation to make it easy to just throw them in jail if they so much as threatened to get out of line in any way. (You can read more about the bill and Quin’s cruelty here.)  As Bat-Ami explained: 

The commissioner of DCS has said really degrading things about foster youths who are in these night-to-night … offices. She said that they are violent. She said all these things; but we act out because we're literally not able to leave. I met kids on night-to-Night when I was in the offices who had been taken into custody for truancy. Only truancy, but they don't bring us to school. … And so he was reasonably upset because he had been removed from his mother for not being taken to school, and then we still weren't being taken to school, and we were in a worse position. 

And so, those are the conditions that we're forced to endure. Like bugs, not being allowed to shower, sharing just a giant room, and so, yeah, sometimes we do act out. 

Bat-Ami said one thing more about “acting out:” 

The only way anyone would listen to me is when I was getting into trouble. 

As for how she endured and became successful, Bat-Ami says that, unlike many foster youth, she was able to stay in the same school, where caring adults knew her from before she entered care. She also got an internship with a public defender’s office where, again, at first, her mentors didn’t know she was in foster care.  As she put it: 

Most of what went right actually had nothing to do with the system doing the right thing. It was the community of Tennessee and my local community stepping up. 

That echoes, almost word for word, the comments of former foster youth in this NPR story. They said, repeatedly, that, while sometimes they encountered supportive foster parents and caseworkers, as the story put it: “Often, that key adult was someone totally outside the foster care system.” 

So who really has mental health issues? Who has the real “behavioral problem” – the children who endure these conditions or the adults who force the children to endure these conditions and then rationalize their behavior to themselves and the rest of us?