Tuesday, November 10, 2026

NCCPR news and commentary roundup, week ending November 10, 2026

● More than 20 years ago, when he was four years old, Tyrone Hill was starved, beaten, and burned by the cousin who was supposed to be caring for him. A brother, Faheem Williams, didn’t survive. Tyrone was rescued, only to be let down by the foster care system as well. But he survived it all, and now he’s trying to help others. He told his story to New Jersey Spotlight News. 

● Another state “Child Advocate” is misleading the public in an apparent attempt to get a state that already tears apart families at a rate well above the national average to take more. This time it’s Rhode Island. In The Providence Journal, Prof. Kelley Fong, whose brilliant book Investigating Families was based on months embedded in systems in Rhode Island and Connecticut, explains what the child advocate got wrong. 

● From The Imprint:

 A new research initiative at the University of California, Los Angeles will tackle racial disproportionalities in foster care, with the goal of driving reforms. ...

Tyrone Howard, co-director of the UCLA Pritzker Center, said too often child welfare researchers and leaders have overlooked the “racialization of poverty” and a bias against Black and brown mothers. 

“We can’t talk about child separation unless we begin to understand the role of structural racism,” Howard said at a public event last week announcing creation of the research hub. “We have to say the quiet part out loud.” ...

● WHEC-TV in Rochester, New York, has more about the report from Hope585 about how family policing drives families away from seeking help.

● The Imprint reports that, responding to a lawsuit from The Bronx Defenders, New York City’s Family Court has enacted rules to make it harder for judges to demand on-the-spot drug tests from parents just because they damn well feel like it. 

In this week’s (further) reminder that the horror stories go in all directions: 

● Consider what we know so far about the death of Malayshia Alford, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer: 

--According to a lawsuit settlement, in 2021, a four-year-old foster child in the home of Carprice Williams nearly died from bleeding on the brain and severe malnourishment. The treating doctor called it a near fatality. A panel of city and state experts recommended that no foster child ever be placed with Williams again. 

--But at least one other foster child, 10-year-old Malayshia, was placed there. Now Malayshia is dead and Williams is accused of killing her. 

--Malayshia was placed with Williams after being removed from another foster home where, it’s alleged, she also was abused.

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

NCCPR news and commentary roundup, week ending November 4, 2026

● “There has to be a place where you can ask for help without it being used against you.” But if you’re poor, in a world where almost every helping professional is a “mandatory reporter,” such places are almost impossible to find. That’s what Hope585 found after conducting focus groups with 21 parents in Rochester, New York. 

Writing in The Imprint, Hope585 Executive Director Ashley Cross explained: 

Women described reaching out for help and becoming the subjects of investigations. They spoke about unmet basic needs being interpreted as parental failure, children with behavioral challenges being misunderstood, and interactions with child welfare professionals that left them feeling powerless, judged and afraid. 

But perhaps the most consequential finding was this: Many women said they learned that asking for help was dangerous. … 

“If you reach out, someone’s going to judge you and report you,” one participant explained. 

● One of the mothers interviewed told her story in the Rochester Beacon: 

The first time Child Protective Services knocked on my door, my oldest child was only six months old. 

I had barely slept. My baby had cried for hours the night before. I fed him, changed him, rocked him, and walked the floor until my body ached. Nothing worked. Eventually, overcome by exhaustion, I let him cry so I could get some rest. 

I was a young, single mother trying to survive without the support of a village. Every day brought another worry. How would I pay the bills? How would I keep food in the house? How could I be the mother my child deserved when I was barely holding myself together? 

The next morning, CPS was at my door. Someone had reported me because my baby had been crying for too long. I remember the fear and shame. Who called them? Were they going to take my baby? Had being an exhausted mother somehow made me an unfit one? 

● But help without judgment is getting harder to find. Study after study finds that providing more concrete help to families reduces child abuse. Unfortunately, the reverse also is true. A new study finds that when states stopped providing extra SNAP benefits as part of a program initiated during the COVID pandemic, abuse and neglect increased. 

● What would the foster-care-at-all-costs crowd say if a dramatic drop in the number of children in foster care in Los Angeles County had been accompanied by increases in child abuse deaths? Yes, exactly. But when such deaths plummet as foster care goes down, they’d rather you not know. So we’ll have to tell you about it in this blog post. 

● Tearing apart more families doesn’t make children safer. But what does? Nora McCarthy of the NYC Family Policy Project discusses that on the latest edition of The F Word podcast. Also on that episode, Ella Bat-Ami, whose stunning comments on the first episode are discussed here, returns to discuss next steps. 


● KNXV-TV follows up on its story about how the head of the Arizona “child welfare” agency wants to solve the problem of foster youth running from group homes: Delay reporting the runaways to the police. 

● And Gene Weingarten has an update on the story of a Georgia mother persecuted after her infant died in a hot car – and the damage that’s doing to the surviving children.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Some remarkable data from America’s largest locally-run family policing system. Interpret with caution – but don’t overlook it:

In Los Angeles County, from 2015 through 2025:
 
●The number of children reported trapped in foster care on any given day dropped dramatically:


● The number of children reported torn from their families over the course of a year dropped dramatically:

● And child abuse fatalities, including deaths of children “known to the system,” ALSO dropped dramatically:
 

(See below for details about how to find these data after clicking on the links.)

Maybe the best way to save children’s lives is to cut short all that needless foster care. Or maybe we should simply stop pretending we can measure system performance by fatality numbers, no matter what those numbers show in one community.

Long ago I proposed something to those who constantly push for a take-the-child-and-run approach to child welfare: a mutual moratorium on the use of horror stories to make our case. Of course they haven’t accepted. They can’t. That’s because horror stories are all they’ve got. 

The overwhelming weight of the evidence is that the child welfare surveillance state they have championed and nurtured for decades, reveling in its growth to monstrous proportions, has not only destroyed millions of families, it’s made all vulnerable children less safe. 

So, since they didn’t accept the offer, we include regular reminders in our weekly roundups of family preservation journalism and commentary that the horror stories go in all directions. Here’s a sampling from last year. 

More recently, I suggested going further: I proposed a mutual moratorium on using statistics about child abuse fatalities. The reason is one for which we all can be grateful: Though each is the worst imaginable tragedy, the number is low enough to rise or fall for all sorts of reasons unrelated to the behavior of the family policing system, sometimes including random chance. 

But those wedded to tearing apart families don’t want to do that either. On the contrary, they have a habit of cherry-picking fatality data, sometimes over short periods of time and in relatively small jurisdictions. 

The worst demagogues exploit horror stories even when the statistics show no evidence of a change in the rate of child abuse fatalities. That’s happening now in Santa Clara County, California. 

Given that, let’s look at data in one of the largest jurisdictions in the country, in fact, the largest locally run family policing system in America, in a locality with a larger population than 40 states: Los Angeles County, California. And let’s look at the fatality data going back as far as the County has posted it online, to 2015: 

As the screenshots at the top of this post make clear: From then through 2025, child abuse fatalities went down by a lot – both total child abuse fatalities and deaths of children “known to the system.” (2026 data are for the first half of the year only.) 

And what happened to foster care numbers during that time? Well, the fact that none of the child removal evangelists in academia, government or media has sought to bring this to your attention is a pretty good giveaway: As child abuse deaths declined sharply, so did known entries into foster care and the number of children trapped in foster care on any given day. (As always, there's a caveat: We don't know how much of the decline is real and how much is simply making the placements "off the books" using hidden foster care.) 

Los Angeles still has plenty of room to improve. Even with the dramatic declines, it still takes away children at one of the highest rates among America’s largest cities and their surrounding counties.

Did the decline in foster care entries cause the lower number of fatalities? Who knows? The best available evidence, from a massive nationwide study, shows no connection, one way or the other, between foster care entry rates and child abuse deaths. Even in a jurisdiction as huge as Los Angeles, the number of fatalities is small enough to merit caution about drawing conclusions about system performance from fatality numbers. 

There are better measures, including overall re-abuse of children left in their own homes (which, in Los Angeles, has remained about the same even as foster care entries declined), foster-care “recidivism,” the proportion of children reunified who are placed again (which also has remained about the same in Los Angeles) and, potentially most reliable: random-sample casereadings done by experts who come to the task from all points of view. So once again, I’ll suggest that mutual moratorium.

Because, at a minimum, all this tells us that those who cherry-pick data to claim that foster care declines lead to increases in fatalities are engaging in rank intellectual dishonesty. 

They do it because, once again, that’s all they’ve got. 

Into the weeds: Here are the details and sources: 

Los Angeles County makes available online child abuse fatality data starting from 2015. Between then and 2025, total child abuse fatalities declined by 50%. Deaths of children “known to the system” declined 43%. (The data for 2026 are for only the first half of the year.) 

During that same time period, according to the California Child Welfare Indicators Project, the number of children taken away each year started to decline, slowly at first, then, starting around 2020, much more quickly, to the point that, by 2025, entries into foster care were cut by more than half compared with 2015. 

Something similar happened to the number of children in foster care on any given day. It stayed largely the same through 2019 and then plummeted. By 2025, the number had decreased by more than 45%. 

In both cases the declines in foster care numbers didn’t start until about 2020. We provide the data back to 2015 because that’s how far back the fatality data are available. 

(Foster care links will default to statewide data. Click on “Single County View” and then “Report Options” to get data specific to Los Angeles. For the fatality data, after clicking on the link, click on “fatality determinations.”)